Showing posts with label The Bible. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Bible. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 31, 2013

A plea for expositional teaching

[I wrote this over-impassioned post for something else a little while ago, and just amended it slightly in honour of my 1000th post... I had in mind both preaching and small group study]

God inspired both the form and the content of the Bible. The Bible is a work of literature, a symphony or a work of art. The Bible’s content is words and concepts, even truths, but this content is always presented in the form of a collection of books of law, history, poetry and more. Only when the Biblical content is put in the Biblical form do we meet Christ.

If I want to read Shakespeare I could learn Elizabethan English, or study the sonnet form, but still never hear Shakespeare’s voice. I could read a library of literary critics telling me what Shakespeare is trying to communicate, but I won’t hear him say it without reading his words.

If I want to hear Beethoven’s fifth I could memorise the rhythm of the opening five bars, practice the C minor scale or even read a biography of his life. None, by themselves, will allow me to hear Beethoven.

Doctrines are sometimes understood as the grammar of the Christian faith. George Linbeck describes the historic creeds as “the grammar of religion”. The Reformation Catechisms can be understood in a similar way. They help us understand what is already being told in the Bible. They are introductions intended to make guide us to listen to the Bible, not to distract from it. That is partly why they are so short compared to the length of the Bible. They’re not meant to compete with God’s voice, but to open our ears to all that he’s saying.

I am often jealous of musically trained people who can enjoy a piece of music at a level I can never reach. But, I also remember how my uncle recalled being envied by his brother who felt he had lost the ability to enjoy music through over-criticism. There is a line to tread, but the key is to understand which has the priority. Gerhard Forde has a book entitled “Theology is for Proclamation” because he thought theology’s role was as a servant of proclamation. I agree. Theological study, at whatever level, is the servant of proclaiming Christ in the Bible.

When Calvin sat down to write the Institutes he intended it as an introduction to the study of Scriptures, with his commentaries and exegetical sermons as his major life’s work (Letter to the Reader 1539). I believe that this is a model we should follow. Thematic teaching, and Bible study skills have their place as aids, but the moment they crowd out God speaking in the form and content he chose as his revelation, we’ve made a big mistake. Biblical teaching shouldn't be an exercise in archaeology: digging through the muck, extracting the doctrines/applications and putting them in a glass box. Biblical teaching is proclaiming to someone what you’ve just heard God announce in the text. In doing this you become God’s mouthpiece, introducing the listeners to the same Jesus you saw, tasted and touched as God spoke to you by his Spirit.

We cannot explain sin better than David in Psalm 51. Theories of the atonement will not sing like the Passion narrative. Exhortations to evangelism will not encourage like hearing Paul ask for prayer that the door to the message be opened even as he sits in prison for the Gospel (Col 4). The incarnation won’t make sense until Jesus’ miracles make any other option nonsensical.

Similarly, “the one who does these things will live by them” (Lev 18) taken out of the melody line of the dialectic between law and Gospel, will lead you away from God to hell. As part of the melody it will lead you to Jesus and resurrection life, against which there is no law.

Thematic teaching will indirectly help people hear God, but they are less likely to directly hear God through it than through expositional Bible teaching. I think we should be going where the action is; where God meets us...his Word. The primary reason Christians assemble together to hear God speak, whether it is round the feet of Sinai (the original ecclesia in the Greek Old Testament) or the shore of Galilee. It should be the same for the church.

I also think that the Bible will always be more exciting than anything else. We never wanted to spend long doing football skills at school, we always just wanted to play games. Playing scales was always boring in comparison to playing a tune. Spelling was annoying, but Tolkien was engrossing. The former things are all good for enjoying the latter more, but they must play the supporting role for the main event. In the same way, having done some thematic/systematic teaching, lets go where the Father speaks in his own voice to his children.

I can’t finish without quoting Luther, who in the Preface to the German edition of his collected works, disparaged the volumes of his own writing, saying: “It was also our intention and hope, when we ourselves began to translate the Bible into German, that there should be less writing, and instead more studying and reading of the Scriptures. For all other writing is to lead the way into and point toward the Scriptures, as John the Baptist did toward Christ, saying, "He must increase, but I must decrease" [John 3:30], in order that each person may drink of the fresh spring himself.”

Tuesday, June 25, 2013

Why trust the Bible, according to the Bible

1. History doesn't contradict it, and often confirms it

"when a prophet speaks in the name of the Lord, if the word does not come to pass or come true, that is a word that the Lord has not spoken" (Deut 18:22)

Under this heading comes most standard apologetics: historical evidences (archeological findings, history of manuscripts), fulfilled prophecies, how the Bible convincingly explains human nature (selfishness, dignity, longing for more etc) and personal testimony (i.e. the Bible says it brings new life and it does - look at the church).

2. It encourages our worship of God in Christ alone

"If a prophet or a dreamer of dreams arises among you and gives you a sign or a wonder, and the sign or wonder that he tells you comes to pass, and if he says, ‘Let us go after other gods,’ which you have not known, ‘and let us serve them,’ you shall not listen to the words of that prophet or that dreamer of dreams." (Deut 13:1-3; cf. 1 John 4:2, 12:3)

God says through Moses that the historical evidence is not enough for something to be God's word. Evidential apologetics only gets you so far. The ultimate question is: does it speak of the real Jesus?

For my earlier and different thoughts on the same passages (!) see here.

Saturday, May 14, 2011

Written for us AND to us

Listening to: Bach: Well-tempered Clavier

"The Bible is written for us, not to us"

Is that right?

I understand that it is usually meant to encourage us to take understanding the cultural and redemptive-historical context of a passage seriously, and that is a good aim. But is it a good phrase on its own?

Union with Christ through baptism and by faith means that all that happened to Christ happened to us too. We are not to be equated with Christ, but we are "in Christ", which means that we died with him and were raised with him (although both are to be consummated, esp the life).

All that was said to Christ is said to us. When God justified Christ (1 Timothy 3:16) then he justified us (Romans 4:25). When he was declared by God to be his Son (Romans 1:4), the one in whom he delights, we were also at the same time called his sons.

Similarly all of Israel is in him, but he is also in Israel (it is mutual indwelling - ala John 15:4, or think of how in the OT Israel is God's "inheritance" and vice versa). For him that meant he entered into the region of judgement that was Israel and the church (which will be judged first - Romans 2:9; 1 Peter 4:17). So for him to dwell in us cost him dearly.

But this means that the Gentile church is also "in Israel", as Paul says in Romans 11. Therefore Israel's history is our history, and what was said to them is said to us. We are now called "his people"! This is an amazing privilege because it means we join in Israel's story, which although it is a story of disciplining, persecution and sin, is the one true story with a happy ending. Or should I say, a happy new beginning?

Israel heard the word of God and so experienced all they did for us, as Jesus suffered for us. But their experience is also our experience and all that was said to them is said to us as well. Because there is both unity and distinction within the "unions" of the Bible with Christ and his people, the Bible is written both to them and to us and not just one or the other.

This means when we read passages like Zephaniah 3:17 we should read them as promises to us (and to Christ). Similarly, when Israel is rebuked for their idolatry, we should not just talk about the mistakes they made as if we have somehow advanced beyond them. Of course we should explain that they are our promises, and our rebukes only because of our baptism and Christ's death. But we shouldn't reduce the OT to mere examples for us to learn from. It really is God's word to us.

Saturday, April 30, 2011

Let the witnesses correct our notebooks

I'd want to say more, but this is well put:

[the modern theologian or ordinary Christian] is not justified in comporting himself in relationship to those [biblical] witnesses as though he knew more about the Word than they... Still less is he a high-school teacher authorized to look over their shoulder benevolently or crossly, to correct their notebooks, or give them good, average, or bad marks. Even the smallest, strangest, simplest, or obscurest among the biblical witnesses has an incomparable advantage over even the most pious, scholarly, and sagacious latter-day theologian From his special point of view and in his special fashion, the witness has thought, spoken, and written about the revelatory Word and act in direct confrontation with it. All subsequent theology, as well as the whole of the community that comes after the event, will never find itself in the same immediate confrontation... For this reason theology must agree to let them look over its shoulder and correct its notebooks.

(pp. 31-32, Karl Barth, Evangelical Theology)

Tuesday, March 08, 2011

The OT is ALL prophecy

Listening to: Regina Spektor: Soviet Kitsch

You can read the OT as purely the religious literature of the Ancient Israelites. In that way it may have parallels, and be compared and contrasted with the NT message of Jesus Christ. It also may provide case studies of experiences of God from which similarities and differences to our experiences can be observed. In this way it can provide important lessons for us.

I suggest that this is how the OT is often read. It's audience is assumed dead, and the situation it spoke into is entirely past. In that sense it is now a "word spoken into empty space". Having considered the original situation the reader and preacher then moves onto "stage 2: application". Application is then done by taking the second step of imagining what the different word spoken by the same God would be to us in our situation. God is no longer speaking to us directly, but we try and work out what he would say to us if he were speaking now.

An alternative way of reading the Bible is to understand it as prophecy. That this is the fullest way of understanding the Bible was seen by the Jews who included even historical books within "the Prophets", and by Jesus and the NT writers who understood all the books of the OT (inc law, Psalms, history etc) as "fulfilled" in their day.

What is the content of this prophecy? In the first instance it is prophecy about Jesus. Jesus says all the Bible is about him, not just those that we see as odd prophecies of the Messiah.

But, as the likes of Richard Hays have noticed, Paul (and the other NT writers) interpret the OT ecclesiocentrically as often as they interpret it Christocentrically. They can do both because the church is "in Christ" his body. The one is not opposed to the other.

As an example you could consider the story of David and Goliath.

Many would say that this was a story which provides an example of the person of faith. We could say that there are similarities between the "giants" David faced and our battles, and notice how we also have to exercise faith. Of course we would also note that there are also differences so we can't draw too close a parallel. The problem is that the awareness of the differences so blunts the force that we wouldn't be able to really grasp it as a promise to us. Christ would simultaneously be sidelined at the same time as his church is. We are left on the sidelines looking at God's word to and about someone other than Christ or us.

In contrast, Christocentrically we could note that actually this is prophesying the coming of the greater Davidic King Jesus. We would also see that the fulfilment of the death of one man representing a sinful people was Jesus Christ too. But seeing it as prophecy we would not say that this is a 'spiritual meaning' or 'additional meaning' but the primary reading of the text.

Ecclesiocentrically we can see that the story of David and Goliath is prophesying that we as Gentile mockers will be put to death. But we will also see that anointed by the Holy Spirit we are also going to be victorious over the enemies of God, including our sin and death, so the grave will hold us no stronger than it held Christ.

[This is a rather rushed attempt to explain to Steve what I have got out of Wingren's quotation. I may try to do better sometime]

Wednesday, February 16, 2011

A few random thoughts on God's Word

God's word is personal:

  • The speaker is a person - the Father
  • The content is a person - the Son
  • The hearers are people - the church past and present

It is tempting to forget who is addressing us, and treat it merely as the opinion of another human.

It is tempting to forget that it is all about Christ, his person and work. We can think that it is all about me and meeting my felt needs, a rule-book, or about an irrelevant religion of a dead people.

It is tempting to forget that it is meant to be spoken to people. If it is not applied to individuals then it is not doing what it is meant to.

God's word is an arrow:

  • It has a target: God's Word is addressed to us
  • It will impact: God's Word is powerful and does what it says

It is tempting to treat God's Word as an object to be 'engaged' with. It is, but it is also a moving object that is 'engaging' us.

It is also tempting to treat God's Word as for someone else (either the sinner sat next to me in church who needs rebuking, the saint who we think deserves to be loved by God, or an ancient nation long past). It is for them, but it is also for us.

Sunday, January 02, 2011

Wisdom on reading well (part 1): Michael Reeves

I thought I'd do a little series on advice that has impacted how I read, and in particular how I read the Bible. This is the first piece of advice (not in order of importance by the way!) although it is implicit rather than explicit:

"Luther opened the Bible to find Christ, Zwingli sought more simply to open the Bible." (p.75, Michael Reeves, The Unquenchable Flame: Discovering the Heart of the Reformation)

This one sentence is probably the most important thing to me I read in Mike Reeves's book. It reinforced the video below which I had seen on Dave Bish's blog.

I found that massively personally challenging. Am I reading the Bible with the clear intention to meet Christ and see his glory? If I'm not, I'm perverted in my use of the Bible.

One caveat. It is helps to come to the Bible with questions and a knowledge of Christ beforehand, but we must then allow the Bible to question our questions and our knowledge of Christ so that we don't find exactly the Christ we expected to find. You could argue that Luther did not do that as well as he should have, and that is why he had a bad attitude to James, Revelation etc.

Where is our authority?

Listening to: Mozart: Die Zauberflöte (Klemperer)

The Father's authority: God the Father is the supreme authority, Creator of heaven and earth.

The Son's gifted authority: He has given all authority to his Son (John 17:2). The Father is in him so he carries the Father's authority, but (importantly) he is also in the Father (John 10:38) so while that authority is delegated it is of the very being of the Father that he acts to give authority to the Son whom he loves. It couldn't be any other way.

The Church's gifted authority: By his Spirit the Son abides in his church and we abide in him (John 15:4). It is a mutual indwelling that mirrors the mutual indwelling that the Father and the Son have together (John 17:11). The Son is gifted authority by the Father, the church is gifted authority by the Son. However, Christ is the head of the body because we do not dwell in the Father, and we are one step removed from the Father who is the source of all authority.

The gifted authority of reason and the civil authorities: The authority of the reason and the civil authorities is also derived from the Son. In the New Creation it will merge with the authority of the church as the personel will totally overlap! Even now it cannot be utterly separated because there is some overlap (Christian judges, Christian bosses etc). What distinguishes the two in the present is the word they have been given to speak. The civil authorities are given the word of order (the word of creation - or better 'continuing creation') and church is given the word of the cross (the word of redemption - or 're-creation').

The power and reality of the gift in the word and Spirit: This connection between the Church and Christ is effected by the Spirit which invariably accompanies the words of Christ (John 3:34). The words of Christ, are found for us in the Bible, and secondarily in the Church's word.

The sacramental word of Christ (the Bible): The Son abides in the Bible so that every word is said by him and about him. He fills every corner of the Bible, but he is not the Bible. The Son is the Word of God the Father, but the Bible is the Word of God the Son. It is through the Son's words dwelling in us that he dwells in us (John 15:7).

The sacramental word of the church (the word and sacrament): The Church hears from the Father in the Son. They hear from the Son in the Bible. They also hear from the Son in the word and sacrament, which re-present Christ of the Bible to us in countless fresh ways as he re-engages an ever changing world and individuals in ever changing situations.

The non-sacramental word of the civil authorities: This word creates order in creation but does not bring the Spirit with it. It cannot create from nothing (as the word of the Gospel can) but can only order creation as it is already there.

The difference that the presence of sin makes: We do not find sin present in either the Father's word to us, or in the Son's word to us. However, the church is caught between the ages. It is both Adam and Christ to the world, although constantly in the process of clothing itself with it's new identity in Christ. It dwells in the midst of the world (in the Johannine sense of fallen humanity), but the world also dwells within it, until the new Creation when it will be purged. Therefore the word of the church is fallible. At times it speaks the truth which comes from Christ, and at other times lies which come from the devil. The words of the church need therefore to be tested to see which spirit inspired them (this is true whether the words are prophetic or preached, and also true of sacraments which can be falsely administered). In one sense the Bible is the word of the church, not directly the words of Christ, but because it is untainted by lies of the Devil it has a priority over the church which remains a mixture of truth and lies until the second coming. It is the priority of being a norm by which to judge the words of the church. A prioritising of the church over the Bible is not wholly incorrect because the Bible was written by the church, but reflects a over-realised eschatology.

[I'm less sure about this bit] The difference that the absence of sin will make: The word and sacraments of the church are words of redemption to the fallen, whether in the world without or in world that still dwells in each of our hearts. Therefore when the New Creation is consummated then the church will stop declaring love to a sinful world that finds it difficult to believe because it will be seen and experienced (1 Corinthians 13:9-10). Instead it will experience love (we will no longer be the bride, but the wife) and we will act it out towards the rest of creation. The church will need to continue to speak to the created world as it rules creation as the civil authority, but it will be the word of continual creation not re-creation.

[This is pretty closely argued, and a massively important subject. I'm laying out a whole swathe of my systematic theology here so if you think I'm in error you should say so. This is why I'm not a Catholic, but also why criticism of bibliolatry can be warranted, but doesn't require you to believe in a fallible Bible. I'm sorry that I gave up on the Bible references for lack of time, but think I could give them for most of the sentences if you ask. I'm sorry as well that I didn't have the patience to edit it.]

Thursday, July 01, 2010

Why the deepest truth has to be mythic

Listening to: Laura Marling: I speak because I can

Why don't we abstract all the truth found in the Bible and cast of the 'husk' of story, and 'myth'?

CS Lewis argues that the mythic elements of Christianity are actually the "vital and nourishing element in the whole concern". The story of the Bible is the "substance", and not "vestigial".

"And yet the human intellect is incurably abstract. Pure mathematics is the type of successful thought. Yet the only realities we experience are concrete - this pain, this pleasure, this dog, this man. While we are loving the man, bearing the pain, enjoying the pleasure, we are not intellectually apprehending Pleasure, Pain or Personality. When we begin to do so, on the other hand, the concrete realities sink to the level of mere instances or examples: we are no longer dealing with them, but with that which they exemplify. This is our dilemma - either to taste and not to know or to know and not to taste [...] As thinkers we are cut off from what we think about; as tasting, touching, willing, loving, hating, we do do not clearly understand. The more lucidly we think, the more we are cut off: the more deeply we enter into reality the less we can think. You cannot study Pleasure in the moment of the nuptial embrace, nor repentance while repenting, nor analyse the nature of humour while roaring with laughter. But when else can you really know these things? [...]

Of this tragic dilemma myth is the partial solution. In the enjoyment of a great myth we come nearest to experiencing as a concrete what can otherwise be understood only as an abstraction. [...]

Now as myth transcends thought, Incarnation transcends myth. The heart of Christianity is a myth which is also a fact."

("Myth became fact" in CS Lewis: Essay Collection: Faith, Christianity and the Church)

Wednesday, June 09, 2010

Luther's prayer to receive the Word

Eternal God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, grant us Your Holy Spirit who writes the preached word into our hearts so that we may receive and believe it, and be gladdened and comforted by it in eternity. Glorify Your Word in our hearts. Make it so bright and warm that we may find pleasure in it, and through Your inspiration think what is right. By Your power fulfill the Word, for the sake of Jesus Christ, Your Son, our Lord. Amen.

(TLWA, p. 38 and endpaper of the LSB)

Sunday, March 21, 2010

Some thoughts on the canon

Whenever anyone challenges me about the church's role in choosing the canon I still come back to a quotation I read in my first few years of being a Christian:

"the church did not select and authorize the canon but recognized it and sat down under its authority. When a patient returns to a doctor and says, 'Yes, that medicine is exactly what I need', the patient does not authorize the medicine but recognizes its inherent authorization." (p. 207, Alec Motyer, Look to the Rock)

One reason why I think Motyer's point works, even if it could be refined, is because it does not separate the Bible's authority from its purpose. You cannot know the authority of scripture apart from its saving work in your life, and the early church didn't try.

But how did the early church know that the purpose of any books claiming to be the word of God should be salvation of sinners? They could, and to some extent did, think of it as a political tool, a guidebook to life etc instead. However, from creation onwards the church has experienced the word of God and has known that it is characterised by the creation of life. The word of God and God's saving activity have always been inseparable.

So when it came to deciding the canon the primary question asked of any book was does this book bring salvation? Questions about historical reliability and apostolic authority are also valid, but are correctly understood as part of this question. The church cares that they provide historically reliable access to Jesus of Nazareth because he is our Saviour, and we care that their authority derives from Jesus because only he has the authority to forgive our sins.

But how do we know if a book brings salvation? We know salvation by the Spirit who gives life and freedom (John 6:63; 2 Corinthians 3:17). In this sense the Spirit authenticates the Bible. Not by a little voice in the head saying "yes that's true" or "no that's a fake", but by the new life that accompanies it (cf. John 3:8). Paul appeals to the Galatians experience of the Spirit ("Did you receive the Spirit by works of the law or by hearing with faith?", 3:2) not just to verify the sufficiency of faith but to verify the Gospel of Christ he preached and they heard (1:6-7). God's word, God's salvation and God's Spirit are all inseparable. Our salvation is hidden with Christ, but we have the down-payment of the Spirit, so if we have the Spirit we can know we have life as an inheritance waiting for us (cf. 1 Peter 1:4-5).

But finally, how do we know if we have the Spirit? Paul and John both agree on one answer to this:

"No one can say 'Jesus is Lord' except in the Holy Spirit" (1 Corinthians 12:3)

"By this you know the Spirit of God: every spirit that confesses that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh is from God" (1 John 4:2)

So to a degree, we can ask the question about the canon apart from our personal experience. We can ask, does the Bible confess Jesus Christ as Lord? Jesus thought the OT did (John 5:39) and I'm convinced all the NT does too. And if it does, when we can be sure that it is the Spirit-breathed, salvific word of God. But when I have come across non-canonical 'Gospels' I've been less convinced they confess the Jesus as Lord.

In Matthew and Luke I find that Jesus is confessed as the Lord who goes searching after lost sinners like a good shepherd (Matthew 18:12-14; Luke 15:3-7). In the Gospel of Thomas I find a Jesus confessed as the Lord who who also goes searching for a lost sheep, but that sheep also happens to be the largest sheep and is never identified with sinners (saying 107). That seems like a different Jesus, and a different Lord to me, and it brings no salvation for a lost sinner.

Saturday, January 16, 2010

What God is doing in the Bible according to Tim Saleska

I made some notes on a MP3 lecture by OT lecturer Tim Saleska entitled "Interpreting Scripture in a Systematics Context". He describes the lecture as a few thoughts on what he sees God doing in the Bible. It is always interesting what people choose to highlight and what to miss out in introductory summaries, and I really liked Tim Saleska's selection.

  • You can't escape God - God is the 'problem'. Because the Bible clearly presents God as in control of everything, there is nowhere we can go to avoid him.

  • Israel is chosen by God - it is Israel's heart that God is interested in. His relationship with Israel is a love story, husband and wife, father and son. But because Israel is unfaithful she needs to disciplined and put to death so that she can have a new heart that beats for God. So it is Israel who gets the resurrection, and the blessing belongs to Israel
  • Who gets to be Israel? God decides. Throughout the OT God is choosing some and not others.
  • His choice is Christ. In his Baptism, and throughout his life God shows his choice of Jesus as his people in one person. Christ receives all of God's promises to Israel.
  • Christ is God's Word to us - so in Christ he speaks to us of his choice of us, our death and resurrection, which makes us his children with Jesus.

Friday, January 01, 2010

How to read the Bible in 2010

Listening to: Andrew Bird: Noble Beasts

We're starting a New Year and so for many people its time to restart that Bible reading plan, or at least resolve to try and read the Bible more regularly. But more important than just reading the Bible is how we do it, or what use we make of it. I often come to reading the Bible with no aim whatsoever - more fool me. We should ask "what is the Bible for?" Here are three possible answers:

1. To bring Christ to us - the Christological use of Scripture

Jesus Christ, crucified and risen, is the content and theme of the Scriptures. It is all about him. So when we read the Bible we should be expecting to meet him in its pages. Of course it tells us how to live our life, it tells us about the religious customs of the Ancient Near East, it gives us words to express some of our deepest emotions, and all-sorts. But that is all with one aim - to drive us to Jesus Christ, his death and resurrection for us.

When I read my daily Bible reading I want to look to Christ. I don't want to look at the knowledge that I gain in by studying it. I also don't want to look at myself piously using my time to read it.

I love Dave Bish's little video of Mike Reeves on this.

I want to to be transfixed by Jesus this year through reading my Bible. To know Christ, and his work, better.

2. To be proclaimed - the Centrifugal use of Scripture

Luther apparently said that "The church is not a pen-house but a mouth-house". By which he meant that the church is not meant to be studying Scripture but proclaiming it. So we are not Gnostics, reading the Bible to gain secret knowledge for ourselves. We are to declare its content (Christ) to our brothers and sisters in the church, and to those we know who are not yet Christians. When we read Scripture we should be thinking: "What does this have to say to Jack struggling with motivation in his job?" "What relevance does Christ declared here have to Jill who finds a God who sends people to hell intolerable?" "What does the passage I have read have to say to the culture I live in?" We should then take what we have heard in the Scripture and share it with people. Like the Jews, we have been "entrusted with the oracles of God" (Rom 3:2), but entrusted with them in order to declare them to the world. We receive Christ through the Scriptures, but that is a gift for us to pass on.

I want to see my friends and family change by my reading of the Bible this year. To see some turn to Jesus, and others be built up by the truth of the Gospel.

3. To be applied - the Centripetal use of Scripture

Last year I often thought about Bonhoeffer's observation that American Christianity was "Protestantism without Reformation". In context he meant that American Christians hadn't understood that "God's 'criticism' touches even religion". So it is not "us and them" (i.e. the Church and the World) because we too are still sinners. The Church is still sinful, and we need the Gospel as much as the world. As Solzhenitsyn famously said "the line separating good and evil passes not through states, nor between classes, nor between political parties either, but right through every human heart". The condemnation of the "law" and the encouragement of the Gospel is for us.

The "them" who we imagine "need to hear this" is not just our contemporaries either. Practically, I often sense that we are particularly poor at applying the Scripture to ourselves when reading the OT. We often read the OT condemnations against the faithlessness of Israel, as against either non-Christians, or worse as merely historical fact. Instead we should read the OT like the Apostles who saw Israel as the Church - which means both the condemnations and the promises that they heard belong to us too.

So we should always be asking questions like: "what does this say to our church?" "where am I in this parable?" "what is the appropriate response for me to make to this passage?"

I want to be changed by my reading of the Bible this year. To put to death sin, and rejoice in what I have been given.

The first use is the primary one, and in a way contains the other two. But if we don't use the Bible Centrifugally we become hermits and if we don't use it Centripetally we become self-righteous. I fear I often don't use it in any of the three ways, but I pray 2010 will be different.

[Inspired/plagiarised from Leo Sanchez's lecture 'Uses of Scripture' in the Lutheranmind series]

Sunday, August 23, 2009

Biblical recommendations

1. The Books of the Bible

The TNIV bible set out in single column without verse numbers, chapter numbers or section headings. They have annoyingly messed with book order as well, but overall it is now my favourite bible to read from in chunks. Its dirt cheap too if you buy it from AbeBooks.

2. Tim Keller: Isn't the Bible historically unreliable and regressive?

Probably the best apologetic talk on why we should trust the bible. I particularly like how it focuses on challenging the challenges that those who are not yet Christians bring. I recently burnt it onto a CD and gave it to someone I know who is not yet a Christian. He still isn't a Christian, but he found it quite sensible and helpful.

Thursday, August 06, 2009

The formal and material principles

Philip Schaff defines the formal and material principles of the Reformation thus:

the material of life principle (principium essendi) of the Reformation [...] is no other than the great doctrine, which is presented by Paul especially as the entire sum of the gospel - the doctrine of the justification of the sinner before God by the merit of Christ alone through faith [...]

the formal or knowledge principle [...] consists in this, that the word of God, as it has been handed down to us in the canonical books of the Old and New Testaments, is the pure and proper source as well as the only certain measure of all saving truth.

(italics original, p.80-98, The Principle of Protestantism)

Martin Luther may be everyone's go-to guy for the material principle, but would we point to the person who called James an 'epistle of straw' as a great exponent of the formal principle? A lot could be written about Luther's doctrine of Scripture, but I think Oswald Bayer gets to the heart of why Luther doesn't fit into the standard neat distinction of formal and material principles. For Luther the 'authority of Scripture is not formal but is highly material and is content driven' (p.69, Martin Luther's Theology: A Contemporary Interpretation). This means that we don't follow a two step plan to knowing the truth of God:

  • Step 1: Establish source of revelation
  • Step 2: From that source derive knowledge of God and how we relate to him

This is the way that many Protestant confessions seem to proceed (at least post-Reformation), and it is the way many systematic theologies are organised. Oswald Bayer certainly does not like to do things that way though:

one does not arrive at the solution to the question [of the authority of Scripture] "in the passionless calm of a knowledge which is in the element of pure thought alone" [Hegel]; instead, it includes a change in the existence of the reader and interpreter. The Holy Scripture verifies itself, in that it awakens faith. As has been stated already, it does not work for one to take the so-called scriptural principle and try to differentiate between a "Protestant formal principle" and a "Protestant material principle," which states the teaching about justification; one certainly ought not to treat them as separate. Both are one and the same: wrapped up in the event that takes place when the righteousness of God is actually given as a gift, at the moment the promissio is articulated, one encounters the authority of Scripture, its efficacy and clarity - its ability to enlighten - as well as its sufficiency: its power to bring one to salvation - if indeed Scriputure is given "for the salvation" of human beings (2 Tim. 3:15). The question about the significance of the reformational turning point in Luther's theology and the question about Luther's understanding of biblical authority are the same; they are one and the same question.

(p.75-76, ibid)

I think this is related to what Mike Reeves is getting at when he says when you treat revelation as 'the ladder to get you up into the actual playroom of Christian theology, you tend to treat revelation and scripture in a non-Christian way because it is outside the room' (beginning of talk 2 here). Mike Reeves concern here is with the relation between Christology and revelation, but one thing I have begun to see lately is that Christology, revelation and salvation are all so bound up together that you cannot really separate them without doing some serious harm. John Calvin's Geneva Catechism, 1541, exemplifies that:

1. Minister. What is the chief end of human life?

Child. To know God

[...how do we know?...]

C. By His Word, in which He declares His mercy to us in Christ, and assures us of His love toward us

14. M. Then the foundation for true reliance upon God is to know Him in Jesus Christ (John 17:3)?

C. That is true

(pp.5-7, Trans. and ed. TF Torrance, The School of Faith: The Catechisms of the Reformed Church - that is the beginning and end of the introduction section prior to the section on the Apostles Creed)

This may seem to be the height of obscure theological discussion, but if you think that just meditate a while on what this means for how you try and witness to the truth of the Gospel to non-Christians.

Thursday, March 26, 2009

Luther's rules for studying theology

Luther's rules for studying theology, which he sees as almost synonymous with the study of the bible, may surprise you. They are:

  1. Prayer, because you know that you cannot understand anything without the Holy Spirit enlightening you.
  2. Meditation, by which he means 'not only in your heart, but externally' by talking, speaking, singing, hearing, and reading the same passage over and over again.
  3. Anfechtung, by which he means the devil harrying and assaulting you.

[see "Preface to the Wittenberg Edition of Luther's German Writings" [1539] in Selected Writings of Martin Luther, Vol 1]

Travelling widely in our backyard

Mark Meynell quotes Eugene Peterson:

Henry David Thoreau, one of our canonized American sages, wrote of having "travelled a good deal in Concord" (the small New England village in which he spent his life). An item in the oral tradition that formed around Louis Agassiz, the celebrated Harvard biologist and professor, remembers that he returned to his classroom after the summer vacation and told his students that he had spent the summer travelling and made it halfway across his backyard. I want to hold out for travelling widely in Holy Scripture. For Scripture is the revelation of a world that is vast, far larger than the sin-stunted, self-constricted world that we construct for ourselves out of a garage-sale assemblage of texts.

(p.45, Eat This Book)

Isn't that beautiful? I want that too, but get easily distracted.

Martin Luther wanted us to do the same. He commented:

I would have been quite content to see my books, one and all remain in obscurity and go by the board. Among other reasons, I shudder to think of the example I am giving, for I am well aware how little the church has been profited since they have begun to collect many books and large libraries, in addition to and besides Holy Scriptures [...]

It was also our intention and hope, when we ourselves began to translate the Bible into German, that here should be less writing, and instead more studying and reading of the Scriptures. For all other writing is to lead the way into and point toward the Scriptures, as John the Baptist did toward Christ, saying, "He must increase, but I must decrease" [John 3:30], in order that each person may drink of the fresh spring himself [...]

My consolation is that, in time, my books will lie forgotten in the dust anyhow, especially if I (by God's grace) have written anything good.

(pp.7-8, "Preface to the Wittenberg Edition of Luther's German Writings" [1539] in Selected Writings of Martin Luther, Vol 1)

I've always found this a funny thing for such a voluminous writer to say. There are a few naiveties about the both Peterson and Luther describe things too (but they know that). Nevertheless, I want to be a person who drinks thirstily from the spring, even if that means I miss out on other things.

Thursday, October 16, 2008

Some problems with Luther's theology

Just in case you were beginning to think that I think Luther is perfect...

If I had to do without one or the other - either the works or the preaching of Christ - I would rather do without the works than without his preaching. For the works do not help me, but his words give life, as he himself says [John 6:63]. Now John writes very little about the works of Christ, but very much about his preaching, while the other evangelists write much about his works and little about his preaching. Therefore John's Gospel is the one, fine, true and chief gospel, and is far, far to be preferred over the other three and placed high above them. So, too, the epistles of St. Paul and St. Peter far surpass the other three gospels, Matthew, Mark and Luke.

("Preface to the New Testament" (1546), in Luther's Works, Vol. 35, p. 357)

Can we blame Luther for two of the problems that have continued today? An emphasis on the didactic rather than narrative parts of the Bible, and a approach that listens only to what it already agrees with.

I think we can but I also recognise that these two issues come out of some of the strengths of Luther's theology. Firstly, the Bible is not a book of examples for us to follow, but God speaking to us. Secondly, the recognition that the Bible points beyond itself to Jesus. However, I think they are still serious problems... I need to think more about this.

Sunday, June 22, 2008

Why all Christians need to think about Biblical Theology

How can we read the scriptures like Jesus on the road to Emmaus, Peter at Pentecost, and Paul in Romans, when the word Jesus is so small in a Wordle of the bible (from the ESV blog; what is a Wordle?)?

A start may be made by realising that Jesus is in one way or another also 'Lord', 'God', the Word ('said'), 'Israel', the 'people', and 'king'.

Monday, October 01, 2007

Swimming

This is a stupid post really. But I just thought I'd post on the great thing that is the The One Year® Bible. Yes it may be a registered trademark but God by his grace has used it to get me into regular daily reading of the bible. There is really nothing like it. If you want to get yourself a bible reading plan for the coming year I'd highly recommend it. I'd also say that take a look at this clever page visualizing loads of the plans out there for people like me who don't feel they have understood anything unless it can be described graphically. But the best thing about The One Year® Bible is that it rearranges the bible into the daily readings. It may seem like the definition of laziness to buy a bible that saves you jumping around the bible for each passage of the day, but in some way it has helped me.

My next plan to get into the bible is to start reading though a few books of the NT with John Calvin and John Chrysostom as company. I hope to do this in the break I have between law courses in the next few weeks. In reading up on John Chrysostom because I don't know much about except what I have picked up through John Calvin, and I found this quote on reading the bible:

"Listen carefully to me, I entreat you…. [P]rocure books that will be medicines for the soul.... At least get a copy of the New Testament, the Apostle's epistles, the Acts, the Gospels, for your constant teachers. If you encounter grief, dive into them as into a chest of medicines; take from them comfort for your trouble, whether it be loss, or death, or bereavement over the loss of relations. Don't simply dive into them. Swim in them. Keep them constantly in your mind. The cause of all evils is the failure to know the Scriptures well."

(Homilies on Colossians, Cited in Hall, Reading Scripture with the Church Fathers, 96]

What a great truth that is. If I ever needed reminding of the sovereign mercy of God, and the darkness of my contrary soul, I just need to be pointed to my irregular habits of reading the bible. I so often neglect it, but when God moves in my life to make it a regular thing it is like water to a thirsty soul.

A bit of a random post - but at least I've documented the link to that clever web page and that wonderful quote.