Friday, April 22, 2011

Faith is how we feed

Listening to: Mozart: Violin Concertos

[This is an attempt to explain why only those with faith are saved by putting it in the context of the nature the salvation itself. I'm a bit torn whether I've succeeded. Let me know your thoughts if you have any]

1. God lays on a meal for everybody, no matter who they are

In the Parable of the Great Banquet, Jesus begins by encouraging generosity to all types of people.  He says that ““when you give a dinner or a banquet, do not invite your friends or your brothers or your relatives or rich neighbours, in case they also invite you in return and you be repaid. But when you give a feast, invite the poor, the crippled, the lame, the blind” (Luke 14:12-13).

It is obvious why Jesus needs to say this isn’t it?

We are nice to those people that we want to be nice to us in return.  Who among us can say that we treat the shop attendant with the same attention we do someone interviewing us for a job?  We will buy a round for someone who we know has a record of buying rounds for us, but we won’t do the same for someone who never offers to get us a drink.

Or we can be prejudiced against whole classes of people who we don’t identify with.  Historically we have treated those of a different race as second class citizens, but perhaps now are more likely to express contempt towards those both above and below us on the class ladder.  Paul seems to be combating just that attitude in 1 Timothy 2 when he encourages the Christians to pray for their political leaders, because God cares for ‘them’ as much as ‘us’.  Although for them it may have been even tougher given the oppression they would have experienced from their leaders.

Like Paul, Jesus sees that how we treat other people will mirror how we believe God treats people.  Often we are tempted to feel that God loves people like ‘us’, not people like ‘them’, and we think that justifies us in our lack of love to those people.  Where we do that we need to be sorry and change because God should be our model and is not like that.  God loves “all” people, as Paul says.

Jesus illustrates how God loves all people in this Parable of the Great Banquet.  He compares “the Kingdom of God”, or as Paul would say it “salvation”, to a great banquet.  It is not a bring-your-own meal and it is not beans on toast, instead it is a lavish feast provided entirely at God’s expense.

And this feast is not just for God’s friends or those who have something to offer him.  He has “made everything ready” for “many” people, even those who we read later in the parable don’t like him very much.  

God models just what Jesus says that we should do.  Love everyone and happily share what we have with everyone.

2. The meal is Jesus and he gives life

But what is the banquet that God puts on?  The disciple in verse 15 talks about “bread”, which doesn’t sound all that lavish.  But in John 6 we learn what type of bread is on offer.

Jesus explains that he is “the bread of God” (v.33) who gives “life”.  When we eat food we are nourished and sustained in life.  The difference with this bread is that Jesus gives not just “life” but “eternal life”.  Normal bread fills us up for a little while but then we need more to keep on living, but in contrast if we eat “the bread of God” then we shall “never hunger” (v.35).

I often feel it is a bit weird and disgusting that Jesus is talking about himself as food to be eaten.  When it says that the disciples said in response that “this is a hard saying; who can listen to it?” (v. 60) I have to sympathise with them.

It is pretty offensive that a lamb is slaughtered so we can eat it, but it is even more offensive that Jesus is crucified so that we can eat him. There is no getting round that. You cannot prettify death, but Jesus’ death is the major event of the Gospels and Christianity as a whole so you cannot avoid talking about it.

But as well as an offensive image, there is a sense in which this is the most beautiful image you could imagine. It is a beautiful thing when someone empties their fridge to lay on a meal when you visit. It is an even more beautiful thing, although also more tragic, when a single mother goes out to work all the hours she can manage to put food on the table for her family. It is the most beautiful thing I have ever heard of that Jesus died so that everyone can have eternal life. That is why it is at the centre of what Christians believe.

It is interesting how Jesus defines life in John’s Gospel though. The image of food suggests that Jesus is just the source of life. However, later in the same Gospel he also says that he is “the life” itself (14:6).

Jesus explains that “eternal life” doesn’t mean just existing for a long time, living a life of leisure or having lots of stuff. Instead he defines it in terms of a relationship: “this is eternal life, that they know you the only true God, and Jesus Christ” (17:3).

If Jesus stayed dead to give us life, then that would be no kind of life at all. One of the best things about life is the people, but the very best thing, and source of all other good things, is knowing God and his Son, Jesus. The reason that Christians celebrate Easter is that Jesus was raised from the dead after 3 days being dead, so that we could have a relationship with him and his Father by his Spirit.

Jesus Christ is the feast that God the Father has put on for us, and his company at the table is what makes it worth looking forward to.

3. God invites people to the meal through people speaking about it and eating bread and drinking wine

God has provided a feast which he wants every single person to come and enjoy. But how will people come and enjoy it?

In the first place they need to know that there is feast to enjoy.

In the Parable of the Great Banquet Jesus says that the host sends out his servant to tell everyone that the banquet is ready to be enjoyed (14:17). In a similar way at the end of every Gospel Jesus says that the invitation to him is to go to all the nations. It is not just for the Jews, because God wants everyone to come, so the disciples will have to pass on the message to people all over the world (Matt 28:18-20, Mark 16:15; Luke 24:46-48; John 20:21).

This message is passed on by preaching and by the sacraments of Baptism and the Lord’s Supper, all of which have a fundamental role in the life of all Christians. When Paul preached he said he aimed to preach “Christ crucified” (1 Cor 1:22). Not advice, not rules on how to live and not philosophy, but an offer of a death to give us life. Jesus’ death is also prominent in the sacrament of the Lord’s Supper which originates from when, the night before he died, Jesus told the disciples to regularly eat bread and wine as his body and blood given for us.

When the bread is broken in two at the front of a church meeting, or when we hear someone talk about how Jesus died so that we could live knowing him, then we are invited to come and eat at the feast. We will only get tasters now, but when Jesus comes again then we will sit down to a great feast (as many other Bible passages talk about).

It is a sobering thought that if people do not receive the invitation they will not come to the feast. If we love people like God loves them then as his servants we will carry out the task Jesus gave to his disciples at the end of each Gospel and go to every corner of the earth to tell people invite people along. And that is what thousands of Christians have done, even if like Jesus it cost them their life.

4. Eating the meal by faith

This odd concept of eating Jesus, even though it is rich and meaning-packed, begs an important question: ‘how do we eat someone who is alive but we cannot see?’

Jesus makes clear what he means by eating in John 6:35-40. To eat him is to come to him (the feast) and we do that by believing in him.

In the Parable of the Great Banquet the invitation goes out to lots of people who come up with excuses not to come. But why would someone not want to come to a free party?

You only don’t accept an invitation because you believe that the alternative is better. If you don’t think you will enjoy the company, or that the food won’t be that good you make your excuses and don’t come. That is what lots of people do in Jesus’ parable. They thought that staying at home has more to offer than Jesus.

As any host the Father is offended by this. He has been the great giver, but people refuse to receive the gift. It is irrational and morally reprehensible, but people do that to other people and they do that to God. God is angry with those who despise his beloved Son.

The offer still stands until Jesus comes again though. Jesus says that he is offered “so that one may eat of it and not die” (John 6:50). It is important to remember that the reason people will die in hell is because they have chosen to refuse the invitation to eat. This seems mad, but people do have their reasons. They refuse the gift of salvation in Jesus because they that they have a better offer of salvation somewhere else.

That people do not hear about this great feast is a terrible tragedy and the fault of the church. That people hear about this great feast and yet believe it to be a poor offer not worth taking up is also a tragedy, but it is their fault not God’s.

The truth is stark, but if you don’t believe you don’t eat and you don’t live. But if you do believe Jesus is the bread of life he promises and you do eat of him visibly at the Lord’s Supper and by invisibly by listening to the Bible taught, then you will live and feast with him when he comes again.

Wednesday, April 20, 2011

Gathered and scattered

The church is a gathered people.

It gathers in order to receive from God by faith.

From the whole world it comes to hear the Word preached and administered in the sacraments and so to receive Christ.

The church is a scattered people.

It scatters in order to give to the world by works.

It sends its people in every direction to preach the Word and administer the sacraments and so to offer Christ, all in the context of practical care.

Taste life in John's Gospel

I would encourage anyone with a spare couple of hours to read the Gospel of John looking out for what Jesus, through John, wants us to know about “life”.

Jesus calls his Father “the living Father” (6:57). Like all beings that have life he is not inactive but outgoing and like human fathers he gives life to his child, Jesus (6:57). However, unlike human fathers who give life in the act of conception and maybe through loving nurture, God the Father is always giving the Son life by his Holy Spirit. It doesn’t say that he “gave” life to Jesus in the past tense because from the very beginning the Son has been with the Father (1:1-2). As the early Christian church taught, the Son was “eternally begotten of the Father”. The alternative would mean that there was a time when the Father was not giving life - which would actually mean that he was static, dead, and not “the Father” because he didn’t have a Son!

So, God the Father and Son are living and always have been.

But, what does it mean to be living?

Clearly, until Jesus became a man God did not have a pumping heart or electricity pulsing through his brain. But we all know that there is more to life than organic mechanisms. Relationships are at the heart of what it means to be living, so Jesus shows the depth of his understanding in describing life for human beings to be found in knowing him and his Father (17:3). Within God the Trinity, Jesus lives for his Father, and his Father lives for him. As parents often say that their children are their “life”, God the Father could say the same for his Son.

But we recognise that while there is something good about someone looking for their life in other people, whether children or lovers, there is also something self-destructive. Jesus saw that clearly in the woman that he met by a well in Samaria (4:1-45). She had married five times and was now living with a sixth man. We don’t know the details but it is clear that by her fault, their fault, or perhaps nobody’s fault she was not finding in men the life that she wanted. When Jesus offers her “living water” that won’t just quench her thirst for a while but satisfy forever she longs to have it (4:10-15). We are just the same as that woman. Looking for life in other people or things we may be satisfied and feel ‘alive’ for a while, but as time passes we either find they don’t satisfy as they used to, or they’re taken away. Nothing lasts, but everything seems to die in the end. We are all thirsty for lasting life - or as John’s Gospel calls it, “eternal life”.

But the Son doesn’t experience this thirst for life when he lives for his Father. His Father is God and has infinite resources of life and joy that leave the Son eternally and infinitely alive. If we want to have our thirst quenched we will have to receive from this heavenly well too.

Thankfully Jesus is his Father’s Son. As the Father has life in himself, he has given it to his Son to have the same (5:26). And as he loves to give life to his Son, the Son also loves to give life to us (4:14, 4:50, 10:28, etc). So with the Father and by the Holy Spirit, God the Son made the world (1:10). A world reflecting the character of its maker and teeming with life.

But as well as life, we sadly also experience death in this world. In the book of Genesis, God teaches us that the reason for this is because he cut us off from the “tree of life” - that is from a close relationship with himself - because we chose to rebel against him. Humanity didn’t trust him to provide us with life, so we tried to take over the world so we could provide for ourselves. Like the woman at the well we started looking for life somewhere other than God. God had only ever done us good and had unfailingly given us life but we were ungrateful and disobedient because we didn‘t trust him to keep on providing and we thought we could do better on our own.

This is the world we all find ourselves in now. There is life and goodness, but there is also death and evil. The Bible is clear that the death and evil is our fault, but that God has lovingly kept on giving us some life and goodness to keep us going. But this imperfect and short life that we know by experience is not the end of the story, because God did not just create, but became a creature. That is the story we find in the Gospels. God the Son became flesh (1:14)!

But why would God who is life and light come into the darkness that we know all too well (1:5) and die as we die under judgement?

Jesus says that he came into this world scarred by death to give us “abundant life” (10:10). All through John’s Gospel Jesus is explaining how he gives life (4:14, 4:50, 10:28, 11:43, 17:2).

God is a god who just keeps on giving, despite our ingratitude! That is truly amazing. But what is even more amazing is how he gives and how much he gives.

Jesus does not just dole out life from heaven, or just give us what he has to spare. He gives us all the life that he has because that is the only way that the death in our world can be overcome. As I have said the Bible teaches that death is in the world because of the rebellion that we have staged against the giver of life. This rebellion and lack of trust is what the Bible calls sin. To get rid of death so that life can be given again sin has to be got rid of first. So right at the beginning of John’s Gospel, John the Baptist recognises that Jesus came to take away the sin of the world by being “the Lamb of God” (1:29).

To twenty-first century Britons, “the Lamb of God” is a strange title to give Jesus, but to the Jews of Jesus’ day it was loaded with meaning. Being a lamb to the Jews meant being a sacrifice. So John was saying that Jesus came to be a sacrifice of a life that would take away our sin and death. Strikingly, right at the beginning of Jesus’ public ministry John the Baptist was pointing to Jesus’ death. This was not just a prediction but was Jesus’ own intention from the very beginning (10:18). As a consequence all four Gospels are dominated by Jesus’ deliberate journey to death on a cross.

But from the larger context of John’s Gospel it emerges that John the Baptist had in mind a particular lamb sacrifice. Once a year, at Passover, Jewish families killed a lamb in the place of their eldest son. John the Baptist understood that Jesus, the Son of God, had come to die as the ultimate lamb in the place not just of one person, but of all the world.

In order to benefit from the Passover sacrifice the Jews used to eat the lamb that they had killed in the place of their son. Shockingly to the Jews that he met, Jesus says that those who want to benefit from his sacrifice have to do something similar. They have to eat him (6:51-58)!

Why does Jesus say something so disgusting?

In the first place, he says it because food is how we live. Without the energy we get from food we would die, and Jesus is saying that without him we will also die.

Secondly, by referring so starkly to his “flesh” and “blood” he is pressing home that in order for us to live he had to die. This food didn’t grow on supermarket shelves but cost him dearly.

Although it may not have been clear to the Jews listening to Jesus, it was clear to John the Gospel-writer that Jesus didn’t mean that his body was going to be carved up for the disciples to eat after he died on the cross. As we find out later in the Gospel, although Jesus died he was laid in a tomb and raised to new life in his own body, so we must “eat” him in a different way.

But how can we eat Jesus?

Many people think that in order to get eternal life we have to do something like exercise. We have to work hard at being the best person we can be and if we finish in the top few we will win a prize. But when Jesus says that to get eternal life we have to eat then that should make us realise that this is entirely the wrong way to think about things.

Instead of impressing, we get eternal life by receiving Jesus as a gift. Right at the beginning of the Gospel, John writes about people who “receive” Jesus by believing him (1:11-12). Throughout the Gospel John says that those who “believe” in Jesus have life (3:15, 4:50, 6:47, 11:26). Then at the end of the book John explains that the whole reason that he wrote it was that “you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that by believing you may have life” (20:31). To eat Jesus you have to believe that he is good to eat, which means believe that he is who he says he is and that he can give life.

Jesus may be drawing a parallel with the story of how humanity lost life in the first place in the Garden of Eden. In the Garden of Eden God provided a “tree of life” which Adam and Eve ate from in order to live. They distrusted God’s promise that this tree would give them life and thought they would do better eating from another tree. Similarly we have a choice. Do we believe that Jesus can give us life by his death, or will we believe the promises of the advertisements we see, or the advice we hear, that we can get life somewhere else?

Jesus gives us his own life for free. There is nothing we have to do to enjoy it, simply take and eat and enjoy. But there are other things we can trust to give us life. Careers take our time, possessions take our money, religions take our good works, but none of them give us what they promise. Jesus said that he is “the way, and the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through [him]” (14:6). As we have mentioned at the beginning “life” and relationship “to the Father” are the same thing. Without believing the Son that he is “life” from the Father we will “perish” (3:16), and be judged by the God the Father (3:36, 5:29) who will not tolerate us calling his beloved Son a liar. Without his sacrificial death to take away our sin, we remain stuck with the consequences of the choice of humanity from Adam to the present day to disbelieve God and chose the wrong meal. So like Adam and Eve, we will remain hungry and thirsty, dissatisfied, and ultimately we will decay and die.

How much better to chose life? To chose a relationship with God the Father who is more awe-inspiring than the universe he created and more loving than anyone we have ever met. To chose to know Jesus as our brother who was willing to die for us even when we disregarded him. To chose to receive God the Holy Spirit to live with us (14:17). God the Father, Son and Holy Spirit united in giving us themselves at such great cost!

It may seem odd that Jesus presents himself as a free gift which we just need to receive. Jesus predicts that believing his offer for life may mean that people mock you or worse (15:18-20). Believing Jesus also means we will trust him when he says that the best thing for us to do with our lives is to love people to the extent that he loved us (13:34). That cost him his life, so if we believe him we will seek to give up all that we have for the sake of other people, including our money, time and care.

In some ways this is a ‘cost’ of believing in Jesus. But as when a husband gives himself to his wife she shares his possessions along with him, we will one day also share in all that he possesses. As the bride of the owner of the universe the church will be given the whole earth to share with him. All those things that we may end up giving up when we believe Jesus’ radical promise to provide all we need to live, we don’t really give up because we will receive them all back when we are married to Jesus when he comes again (cf. 3:29, 2 Cor 11:12, Eph 5:29-32, Rev 19:7). Jesus gave up everything, even his life, and yet was given everything including his life back again from the Father as a gift. As followers in a similar way we may lose everything but we will also receive everything, and more, back from the Son when we are raised from the dead (4:14, 4:50, 5:29, 10:28, 11:43, 14:19, 17:2). As Jesus says, whoever “loves his life loses it, and whoever hates his life in this world will keep it for eternal life” (12:25).

So if you want to have the life Jesus promises, in relationship with his living Father and by his Spirit, then we must come to him (5:40), look to him (6:40), listen to him (5:25), and believe him. There is no other place to find eternal life (6:68), and there is no better life to live than one of perfect relationship with God and each other (Chap 17).

“Taste and see that the Lord is good!” (Psalm 34:8).

Starting points for seeing the Trinity in the Bible

Robert Jenson points out the need to read the Bible as narrative to see the persons of the Trinity as dramatis personae in the Old Testament:

The church has its own way of reading Scripture. There are others. By way of putting the contrast let me say a word or two about the other most important way - Rabbinic Judaism...

Rabbinic Judaism reads the Old Testament fundamentally as Torah - guidance for life. The narrative simply provides the context. Now, this is obviously a perfectly possible way of reading the Old Testament, but it is not the Church's.... The Church's second volume, the New Testament, is fundamentally narrative, with comment on the narrative. The Church then reads the Old Testament from this viewpoint. From the viewpoint of this new volume and accordingly reads the Old Testament basically as narrative, with Torah and Wisdom and Prophecy providing the moral and spiritual context...

The narrative is of God's history with his people from creation to fulfilment...it is an obvious question, but one too often not asked, 'how would a narrative display the reality of God?'

How for example would a narrative show that God is merciful? Not primarily by pronouncing the proposition 'God is merciful', though it can do that too. Rather, by telling and pondering his merciful behaviour. Or by recording prayers uttered by his people on the way, prayers for mercy that are answered. Or by telling stories of heroes of Israel who found mercy with God...

So how would a narrative tell us that God is one God and three persons? It would not do it primarily, or perhaps even at all, by saying 'God is three persons' a proposition that indeed never appears in Scripture, but rather by telling a history of God with us which displays three actors, or as David Scaer put it 'three performers', of that history. Each of which is indeed other than the other two, and yet is at the same time the same God as the other two.

(10:00-14:50, MP3 lecture, Confessions - The Bible and the Trinity)

Richard Bauckham stresses that we should consider the concept of "divine identity" when reading the New Testament to find out the true identity, and not the nature, of Jesus Christ:

The God of Israel had a unique identity...the biblical God has a name and a character, since this God acts, speaks, relates, can be addressed and, in some sense, known...

personal identity [is] a concern with who God is. The value of the concept of divine identity appears partly if we contrast it with a concept of divine essence or nature. Identity concerns who God is; nature concerns what God is or what divinity is...That God is eternal, for example - a claim essential to all Jewish thinking about God - is not so much a statement about what divine nature is, more an element in the unique divine identity, along with claims that God alone created all things and rules all things, that God is gracious and merciful and just, that God brought Israel out of Egypt and made Israel his own people and gave Israel his law at Sinai and so on. If we wish to know in what Second Temple Judaism considered the uniqueness of the one God to consist, what distinguished God as unique from all other reality, including beings worshipped as gods by Gentiles, we must not look for a definition of divine nature but for ways of characterizing the unique divine identity...

Once the category of divine identity replaces those of function and nature as the primary and comprehensive category for understanding both Jewish monotheism and early Christology, we can see that the New Testament's lack of concern with the divine nature of Christ is by no means an indication of a merely functional Christology. We can see that, throughout the New Testament texts, there is a clear and deliberate use of the characteristics of the unique divine identity to include Jesus in that identity. Once we have rid ourselves of the prejudice that high Christology must speak of Christ's divine nature, we can see the obvious fact that the Christology of divine identity common to the whole New Testament is the highest Christology of all. It identifies Jesus as intrinsic to who God is.

(pp.6-31, Richard Bauckham, "God Crucified" in Jesus and the God of Israel)

A few treats from around the web

Tuesday, April 19, 2011

Israel condensed into One

"Jesus is... Israel condensed into One. The obedient and faithful Israel... Matthew emphasises that Jesus is to be seen as Israel. Jesus recapitulates and and fulfils Israel's history. As for example he is called out of Egypt and tested for a period of forty in the wilderness"

(Paul R. Raabe, 31:20, MP3, Delighting in the Good Law of Yahweh: An Old Testament Perspective)

Saturday, April 16, 2011

Pulling away the mask

God's providence is striking sometimes. This evening I was flicking through The Bruised Reed by Richard Sibbes and came across him saying something remarkably similar to my last post...

`But for all this, I feel not Christ so to me,' says the smoking flax, `but rather the clean contrary. He seems to be an enemy to me. I see and feel evidences of his just displeasure:

Christ may act the part of an enemy a little while, as Joseph did, but it is to make way for acting his own part of mercy in a more seasonable time. He cannot restrain his bowels of mercy long. He seems to wrestle with us, as with Jacob, but he supplies us with hidden strength to prevail at length. Faith pulls off the mask from his face and sees a loving heart under contrary appearances. Fides Christo larvam detrahit (Faith pulls away the mask from Christ).

The Hidden God

"O Lord, why do you cast my soul away?
Why do you hide your face from me?" (Ps 88:14)

TF Torrance, and others, critique a Christianity with a "God behind the back of Jesus Christ" (p.248, The Christian Doctrine of God). Rightly, Torrance is concerned that for many people Jesus is the friendly face of God, but behind the mask they believe that there stands the more fundamental, more true and more complete God who predestines some to salvation/damnation and causes earthquakes etc. Torrance and others therefore reject the long-standing theology of the "Hidden God".

But there is better option and that is to understand the Hidden God is God wearing the mask of his wrath and not the God behind the mask. I.e. the Hidden God is not the God behind the mask, but the mask itself. Jesus Christ is where that mask is removed and we see God as he truly and completely is. As far as I understand it that is what Luther (and others) mean when they vigorously teach the Hidden God. For someone so saturated in both the Psalms and experience as Luther this is understandable. In several Psalms we read the Psalmist addressing the Revealed God, asking why he is the Hidden God in their experience. As Oswald Bayer notes, the Hidden God "does not allow himself to be addressed directly" so the prayer of the Psalmist is always addressed the Revealed God. They appeal to the Revealed God to act consistently with who he has revealed himself to be in his past works, promises, and supremely in Jesus Christ.

Why does God hide himself? The only answer we ever get is because of our sin. It was because of our sin that he hid himself behind the curtains of the Tabernacle and the walls of the Temple. It was because of sin that he refused to listen to prayers of rebellious Israel. But in the Gospel we are promised that the hiding is over, the curtain has been torn.

There are still experiences and even doctrines where he is hidden to us. To deny that is to walk by sight and not by faith, over-realise our eschatology, and cut us off from any point of contact with non-Christians living in this present evil age. But for Christians we know there is a time and place where we can see God and address him. Through Jesus Christ we can see through to the future, the Most Holy Place and God the Father. To those with intellectual and heartfelt questions about the God who is hidden to them we point them to Jesus Christ where we can really see who God is.

Friday, April 15, 2011

One of many reasons we should prioritise hearing the word, not studying and reading

'...preaching in its essence is an authorized human being speaking the words of God to listening human beings; and every culture understands that.

An interactive Bible study is not culturally-neutral. To sit around drinking coffee with a book open, reading and talking about that book in a way that forces me to keep looking at that book and finding my place and showing a high level of mental agility, functional literacy, spoken coherence and fluency, that is something that only some of the human race are comfortable doing. Not everyone feels comfortable when the bright spark in the corner pipes up, "Ah, yes, but I was wondering about the significance of the word "However" in verse 3b. What do you think about that?" Some of us love that kind of seminar interaction, but many do not. For those who can do it, it may way be profitable; but many people can't, and just feel daunted or excluded by the exercise.

In some churches we have slipped into assuming that personal Bible reading and one-to-one Bible studies and Bible study groups are the normative way for Christian people to hear the Word of God. This, we say, is what a healthy Christian life looks like. But in redefining the Christian life like that we may unwittingly have alienated the illiterate, the functionally illiterate, the less-educated, those less confident in studying a text. I wonder if, quite unintentionally, we may have contributed to making some of our churches more monocultural than they might otherwise be. Paradoxically it is not that preaching is culturally outmoded, but rather that the study of written Biblical texts is culturally narrow.'

(HT Ed Shaw, Christopher Ash, The Priority of Preaching, p.28)

Sunday, April 10, 2011

God against God

Bobby Grow comments:

A doctrine of salvation that pits God’s justice against God’s love and mercy — what Karl Barth called a theology of "God against God" — is bad theology. This posits a rift in God's being and preaches a God that is inauthentic to the "good news" of Holy Scripture. This is not to deny that wrath and judgment are vital aspects of Christian soteriology. But we have to make sure that (in Barth’s words, again) we are not proclaiming that the No of God is the first word or the last word to men and women.

This is really at the heart of what I read as many Lutheran critiques of Barth. Many Lutherans seem to see in Barth a denial that we are always in relationship to God, even before the preached word. This is a relationship with what Forde calls the God-not-preached, or the hidden God. The God-not-preached is the same loving Creator God, but his primary word to a sinful world is "No". The God-preached however is the God of the Gospel who says "Yes" to us.

I'm not 100% convinced by either Barth or Forde but it is KEY that the God-not-preached, is NOT the God we should be preaching. On this both Barth and Forde agree, although Forde recognises the importance of acknowledging the experience of the God-not-preached.

But experientially, I do appreciate what Forde (and other Lutherans in the same line) has to say, even if it causes me more headaches:

From Luther's perspective, the question about whether we in our Angechtungen wrestle with God, and do not solely experience God as gracious, is quite plausible. Believers and non-believers deal with this hidden God in their various life experiences, precisely in their attempts to master the world and their fate. It is the role of the gospel to turn us to the "preached God," who through Jesus Christ as sacramentum gives us assurance with regard to God's disposition toward us. The person of faith holds this "hidden God" accountable to the promise, even appealing to God against God!

(p. 40, Mark C. Mattes, The role of justification in contemporary theology)

This post is a bit of a 'first thoughts' post. It is really a marker for future discussion. If I ever get time to read some proper theology again, I would like it to be Barth and Lutherans on just this topic.

Christus Victor and PSA

Mike Bird explains how he sees Penal Substitution and Christus Victor as interconnected:

CV and PSA go together because Jesus is only Christus Victor because he is also Agnus Dei. PSA deprives the Satan of his key weapon: accusation against the saints!....Romans 8 and 1 Corinthians 15 both start off with the sacrificial nature of Jesus' death, but then climax in affirmations of divine victory! PSA is the basis for CV, but CV is then the goal of PSA.

He explains that of the two he thinks that CV is more "comprehensive". I think I prefer when he says it is the "goal", in the same way that the Resurrection is the climax of the one work that included the Crucifixion.

Friday, April 08, 2011

Presenting the moral argument for Christianity

Why be good?

The objective existence of a good creator means there is a universal meaning of goodness.

What kind of good?

God, pre-eminently in Jesus in his cross-centred mission to the world, as a demonstration of what good is.

How is it possible to be good?

The Gospel as the only way in which change can happen so that people become consistently good.

[Seems a good structure for presenting the moral argument in it's fullness - inspired by Michael Green's approach]

Escapism

I've been dipping into a old book by Michael Green called Runaway World. Very stimulating and well written. He explains that to many people:

Christianity is the religious man's form of escaping from reality; it is his private way of 'getting away from it all'.

I believe this charge to be largely though not entirely false. Certainly we live in a runaway world, but for the most part it is not the Christians who are running away from reality. We have our escapists in the churches, no doubt. But this book is written in the conviction that the Christian faith itself is the very antithesis of escapism. It provides us with the most credible account of the universe and man's place in it, with the motive and the dynamic for serving our fellow men, with the ability to face the harshest of situations with realism, and with a message of urgent relevance to the many who suspect Christians of escapism but are themselves running away from truth. The issue before us in this book resolves itself into this question: 'Who are the escapists?'

The chapter titles are:

  1. Running away from history
  2. Running away from science
  3. Running away from reality
  4. Running away from adventure
  5. Running away from Christ

In each chapter he explains the charge that people level at Christians and shows how Christianity in comparison to many other worldviews is actually the least guilty of that charge.

It is the first time I've read a Michael Green book and I love his style, approach, knowledge and heart. It won't be the last.

Sadly, it is out of print, it assumes too much knowledge for many, and is very of-its-time, so is not the kind of book you can give away (feast your eyes on the cover). But someone else loved it enough to put online (probably illegally but I suspect Michael Green doesn't mind) so you can read it if you like.

I mention it because I think this is really good apologetics. Escapism along with immorality are two of the biggest charges people level against Christianity in my experience. Engaging with the questions and acknowledging their weight, turning the questions back on the questioner, and presenting Christ as an answer of truth and beauty seems the way to respond.

Words in Romans 3:1-20

Again, a friend showed me part of what is going on in Romans. Romans 3:1-20 is saturated in talk about talk.

v. 2: The Jews have the Oracles of God, God's word in the OT.

v.4a: People speak lies, but God is true.

v.4b: God's "words" will be "justified" and shown to be true.

...how?

v.5: Our lies actually serve to show the truthfulness of God, because God has previously declared us liars.

v. 7: So, through my lying "God's truth abounds to his glory".

v.7: But we don't take this easily and still we question why we being condemned. We continue to question God, to put him in the dock and charge him with claiming to be just when actually he is not being. We call God a liar.

v.8: This is slander against God and is mirrored in slander against his apostles. But as has been said, that person is condemned by their own words.

v.11-18: In the OT God speaks judgement, particularly against the use of the mouth ("throat is an open grave; they use their tongues to deceives. The venom of asps is under their lips. Their mouth is full of curses and bitterness")

v. 19: Why does God speak like this? "so that every mouth may be stopped."

No more questions.

Actually, genuine questions are good...

Why should we celebrate the justification of God in his contention against humanity? The answer must be Jesus. It is because God's justification is in the incarnate Christ it is also the justification of sinful humanity too! Our justification is God's justification.

In faith, one takes the side of God in his claim against one's self, giving God justice. At the same time, one takes hold of God's gift in Christ, whom he has 'put forward' as an atonement and in whom he has taken the side of the sinner. In Christ and in faith, the justification of God the Creator meets the justification of the godless.

(Mark A. Seifrid, p. 18, 'The "New Perspective on Paul" and Its Problems', Themelios, Issue 25-2)

Thursday, April 07, 2011

God's judgement

How can we know that God hates evil? How can we know what hell is like? How can we believe that justice is done in this universe?

  • Romans 1:18-32: It is seen in our experience - just look around, and you can see hell.
  • Romans 3:1-20: It is declared verbally in the Bible which repeatedly shows that we are in the wrong and the consequences of that.
  • Romans 3:21-31: It is executed to the full on Jesus Christ

It is important to see that each is clearer than the one proceeding it.

There is a crescendo as the ugly theme becomes louder and louder, so that it is tempting to cover your ears.

Irreligious folks block their ears early in the crescendo when they suppress the knowledge of God in their experience.

Religious folks hear what their experience says, but when things become sharper and more personal when God addresses them in the Bible they put a different kind of ear-plug in. They say the Bible isn't really addressed to them because it was for a different era, or that it was for the younger son living immorally far from home.

But Christians listen to the full crescendo despite the unpleasantness. This is not because they rejoice in the oppressive noise but because they want to have their ears utterly unblocked for the crash at the end which ends that discordant note and marks the beginning of a new and beautiful melody.

Saturday, April 02, 2011

Cutting God out of the picture?

Listening to: Sovereign Grace: The Cross-Centred Life

We tried to cut God out of the picture...

But God

  • We were still running away when God took the initiative.

rescued us from God

  • We have many secondary things we need to be rescued from, but our ultimate problem is God and his wrath.

by God

  • We are powerless to save ourselves, but God in sending his Son and pouring out his Spirit has rescued us.

to God

  • We are brought to receive many secondary gifts (good works, wealth, health, heaven, etc) but the ultimate gift is a relationship to God himself.

for God

  • Our happiness is not the end of this story. It is all to, and for the purpose of, the glory of God the Father, Son and Holy Spirit.

I was reflecting this evening about where in the story I tend to cut God out of the picture... probably all over the place:

  • I don't celebrate that God has predestined the gathering in of his people and think that it is down to chance and human decision.
  • I don't show the full depth of the seriousness of our plight, as I describe our unsatisfied longings, or even death, as the worst consequence of sin.
  • I don't trust that the cross achieved our salvation, but think that it just made it possible. I doubt that the Spirit can do anything without our permitting him to first.
  • I don't treasure God himself, but love the gifts far above the giver.
  • I see myself as the end of history. God was acting to save me - end of story. Even if I see God throughout the story, I see myself at the centre.

Where do you cut God out of the story you tell yourself and others?

"For from him and through him and to him are all things. To him be glory forever. Amen." (Rom 11:36)

Tuesday, March 29, 2011

What are you noticing?

The other bit of Mike Cosper's review of Radiohead's album I noticed was this:

I have a friend who’s a pastoral counselor. In almost any situation, when he puts on his "counseling" hat, he opens the conversation by asking, "What are you noticing?" and follows that line of questioning with, "How are you processing that?" I think these are great questions to ask when we look at art in the wider world: What are the artist noticing, and how are they processing it?

Very good questions for all of life.

Pausing in the dark places

Mike Cosper has a great review of the latest Radiohead album.

He explains part of their appeal:

There’s a kind of alarm bell being sound by Radiohead. They want us to see how deeply trapped we are in the milieu. They offer no solutions, though they hint at the idea of community and connection....It’s a fairly hopeless perspective, but their fans aren’t listening to them for solutions. They listen for solidarity. Someone else feels lost. Someone else feels like everything is too big, too fake, too plastic.

We are used to observing the longing of our culture and our friends for something more than they know. We also know from experience that only Christ can truly satisfy, and if you ask he will give you that living water.

But I wonder if in our various ministries we run too quickly to the good news? (Can I say that?!) Before people want answers and hope, they want to hear "solidarity" - someone else that feels thirsty.

One of the strengths of law-Gospel preaching is that it does just that. It doesn't rush to the Gospel, although that is its goal. It recognises that these feelings do not just belong to those who are not yet Christians, but are known by all Christians as they are continually moving from death to life until the final resurrection of the dead. Having identified with people in the lostness of their broken dreams, destructive relationships, painful experiences, guilt and shame it then carries them with it, out of the tomb into the glorious dawn of Sunday morning.

The reason for hope in relationships

Does the challenge and mess of relationships leave you discouraged? Does the biblical honesty about human community shock you? Are you feeling overwhelmed by the hard work relationships require? If so, you are ready for this last fact: The shattered relationship between Father, Son and Holy Spirit at the cross provides the basis of our reconciliation. No other relationship ever suffered more than what Father, Son and Holy Spirit endured when Jesus hung on the cross and cried, "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" (Matthew 27:46). Jesus was willing to be the rejected Son so that our families would know reconciliation. Jesus was willing to become the forsaken friend so that we could have loving friendships. Jesus was willing to be rejected Lord so that we could live in loving submission to one another.

(p.13, Timothy S. Lane & Paul David Tripp, Relationships: A mess worth making)

Saturday, March 26, 2011

Sibbes: What is it to preach Christ?

This is essentially for Dave Bish, a great lover of Richard Sibbes. It is an except from The Fountain Opened, an exposition of 1 Tim 3:16, pp.505-509 of Volume 5, Complete Works.

-----------------------

To preach is to open the mystery of Christ, to open whatsoever is in Christ ; to break open the box that the savour may be perceived of all. To open Christ's natures and person what it is ; to open the offices of Christ : first, he was a prophet to teach, wherefore he came into the world ; then he was a priest, offering the sacrifice of himself ; and then after he had offered his sacrifice as a priest, then he was a king. He was more publicly and gloriously known to be a king, to rule. After he had gained a people by his priesthood and offering, then he was to be a king to govern them. But his prophetical office is before the rest. He was all at the same time, but I speak in regard of manifestation. Now 'to preach Christ' is to lay open these things.

And likewise the states wherein he executed his office. First, the state of humiliation. Christ was first abased, and then glorified. The flesh he took upon him was first sanctified and then abased, and then he made it glorious flesh. He could not work our salvation but in a state of abasement ; he could not apply it to us but in a state of exaltation and glory. To open the merits of Christ, what he hath wrought to his Father for us; to open his efficacy, as the spiritual Head of his church ; what wonders he works in his children, by altering and raising of them, by fitting and preparing them for heaven : likewise to open all the promises in Christ, they are but Christ dished and parcelled out. 'All the promises in Christ are yea and amen,' 2 Cor. i. 20. They are made for Christ's sake, and performed for Christ's sake ; they are all but Christ severed into so many particular gracious blessings. 'To preach Christ' is to lay open all this, which is the inheritance of God's people.

But it is not sufficient to preach Christ, to lay open all this in the view of others ; but in the opening of them, there must be application of them to the use of God's people, that they may see their interest in them; and there must be an alluring of them, for to preach is to woo. The preachers are paranymphi the friends of the bridegroom, that are to procure the marriage between Christ and his church; therefore, they are not only to lay open the riches of the husband, Christ, but likewise to entreat for a marriage, and to use all the gifts and parts that God hath given them, to bring Christ and his church together.

And because people are in a contrary state to Christ, 'to preach Christ,' is even to begin with the law, to discover to people their estate by nature. A man can never preach the gospel that makes not way for the gospel, by shewing and convincing people what they are out of Christ. Who will marry with Christ, but those that know their own beggary and misery out of Christ? That he must be had of necessity, or else they die in debts eternally; he must be had, or else they are eternally miserable. Now, when people are convinced of this, then they make out of themselves to Christ. This therefore must be done, because it is in order, that which makes way to the preaching of Christ ; for 'the full stomach despiseth an honeycomb,' Prov. xxvii. 7. Who cares for balm that is not sick? Who cares for Christ, that sees not the necessity of Christ ? Therefore we see John Baptist came before Christ, to make way for Christ, to level the mountains, to cast down whatsoever exalts itself in man. He that is to preach must discern what mountains there be between men's hearts and Christ; and he must labour to discover themselves to themselves, and lay flat all the pride of men in the dust ; for ' the word of God is forcible to pull down strongholds and imaginations and to bring all into subjection to Christ,' 2 Cor. x. 4. And indeed, though a man should not preach the law, yet by way of implication, all these things are wrapped in the gospel. What need a Saviour, unless we were lost ? What need Christ to be wisdom to us, if we were not fools in ourselves ? What need Christ be sanctification to us, if we were not denied in ourselves ? What need he be redemption, if we were not lost and sold in ourselves to Satan, and under his bondage? Therefore all is to make way for Christ, not only to open the mysteries of Christ, but in the opening and application to let us see the necessity of the gospel Christ is preached with sweet alluring. 'I beseech you, brethren,' and ' We as ambassadors beseech you, as if Christ by us did beseech you,' &c., 2 Cor. v. 20. This is the manner of the dispensation in the gospel, even to beg of people that they would be good to their own souls. Christ, as it were, became a beggar himself, and the great God of heaven and earth begs our love, that we would so care for our own souls that we would be reconciled unto him. It was fitter, indeed, that we should beg of him. It was fit we should seek to be reconciled to him, but God so stoops in the dispensation and ministry of the gospel, that he becomes a beggar and suitor to us to be good to our souls. As if he had offended us, he desires us to be reconciled. The wrong is done on our part, yet he so far transcends the doubtings of man's nature, that he would have nothing to cause man's heart to misgive, no doubts or scruples to arise. He himself becomes a beseecher of reconciliation, as if he were the party that had Christ. In a word, being to bring Christ and the church together, our aim must be, to persuade people to come out of their estate they are in, to come and take Christ. Whatsoever makes for this, that course we must use, though it be with never so much abasing of ourselves. Therefore the gospel is promulgated in a sweet manner. 'I beseech you, brethren, by the mercies of God,' &c. The law comes with 'Cursed, cursed;' but now in the gospel Christ is preached with sweet alluring. 'I beseech you, brethren,' and 'We as ambassadors beseech you, as if Christ by us did beseech you,' &c., 2 Cor. v. 20. This is the manner of the dispensation in the gospel, even to beg of people that they would be good to their own souls. Christ, as it were, became a beggar himself, and the great God of heaven and earth begs our love, that we would so care for our own souls that we would be reconciled unto him. It was fitter, indeed, that we should beg of him. It was fit we should seek to be reconciled to him, but God so stoops in the dispensation and ministry of the gospel, that he becomes a beggar and suitor to us to be good to our souls. As if he had offended us, he desires us to be reconciled. The wrong is done on our part, yet he so far transcends the doubtings of man's nature, that he would have nothing to cause man's heart to misgive, no doubts or scruples to arise. He himself becomes a beseecher of reconciliation, as if he were the party that had offended. This is the manner of the publication of the gospel.

[...]

Quest. But must nothing be preached but Christ ?

Ans. I answer, Nothing but Christ, or that that tends to Christ. If we preach threatenings, it is to cast men down, that we may build them up. If a physician purge, it is that he may give cordials. Whatsoever is done in preaching to humble men, it is to raise them up again in Christ; all makes way for Christ. When men are dejected by the law, we must not leave them there, but raise them up again. Whatever we preach, it is reductive to Christ, that men may walk worthy of Christ. When men have been taught Christ, they must be taught to walk worthy of Christ, and of their calling,' Col. i. 10, that they may carry themselves fruitfully, and holily, and constantly, every way suitable for so glorious a profession as the profession of Christian religion is. The foundation of all these duties must be from Christ. The graces for these duties must be fetched from Christ; and the reasons and motives of a Christian's conversation must be from Christ, and from the state that Christ hath advanced us unto. The prevailing reasons of an holy life are fetched from Christ. The grace of God hath appeared' saith St Paul, 'it hath shined gloriously' 'teaching us to deny all ungodliness and worldly lusts, and to live soberly, and righteously, and holily, in this present evil world,' Titus ii. 12. So that Christ is the main object of preaching. This made St Paul, when he was among the Corinthians, to profess no knowledge of anything but of 'Christ, and him crucified ;' to esteem and value nothing else. He had arts and tongues and parts. He was a man excellently qualified, but he made show of nothing in his preaching, and in his value and esteem, but of Christ, and the good things we have by Christ.

Now Christ must be preached wholly and only.

-----------------------

PS. Dave may also be interested to note that Sibbes uses the phrase "the sunshine of the Gospel" a few pages later, where Sibbes notices how the Gospel began in the East and has moved over the land going West, presumably to the New World. If you like what you read you may enjoy Dave Bish's modernisation of Sibbes.

PPS I wonder what people feel about the answer that we should preach "Nothing but Christ, or that that tends to Christ" and then discusses the use of the law. I really should post about the use of the law in preaching, although I don't think I'm enough of a preacher to comment too much. I wonder if we have reacted against a simplistic preaching of 'law'->Gospel and chosen to just preach the Gospel. I think part of why Tim Keller is such a great preacher because he does preach the law as well as the Gospel - although he preaches it almost completely as the 'unrecognised demand'. Any thoughts?

Friday, March 25, 2011

Decisions about giving and all that jazz

In a comment on my review to God So Loved He Gave, Steve asked if Kapic and Borger discussed how we give. I think this says something about their approach:

On a practical level, what does it actually mean to imitate Jesus in our personal giving?

...We must also be careful before trying to specify certain behavioral norms since even the most devout and thoughtful Christians can differ widely over such details, and our individual callings and particular situations will inevitably impact the way Christ's cross takes shape in our lives...

This important word of caution does not mean, however, that the call to imitate Jesus lacks any clear implications for our lives. There is freedom within Jesus' example, but there is also a basic form. Thus, the challenge we face is always the challenge of knowing Jesus more so that we can discerningly apply his example more and more freely within form - like a jazz soloist who is able to improvise long rifts because he is so intimately familiar with the basic beat of the song

(p. 158, Kelly M. Kapic, with Justin L. Borger, God So Loved, He Gave: Entering the Movement of Divine Generosity)

He then identifies two particular aspects of this "basic beat". Firstly, giving up your rights, and secondly, giving up resources.

Much Western aid, and interpersonal giving can be marked by a desire to retain control. Because of that the gift goes sour and it is ineffective. The mistake of communism and Victorian do-gooders?

But we should not just give away power but material resources as well. It is not enough to give 'freedom of opportunity', there has to be actual transfer of wealth too.

Romans 1

A few textual notes on Romans 1 (with a lot of help from AJ):

  • God's "power" is "declared"/"revealed" in three places:
    1. Jesus: The declaration of Christ to be the Son of God in the resurrection of Jesus (v.4)
    2. The Church: The Gospel which brings salvation (v.16)
    3. Creation: In the things that are made (v.20)
      • God's power creates life in all three instances
  • Paul longs to see the Christians in Rome because he is "eager" to preach the Gospel to them. Do we have that same passion?
  • "from faith for faith" could mirror the "Jew first and also to the Greek" in the previous verse. In which case faith is from the Jews for the sake of the world. That mixture of mission and Jew/Gentile relationship would fit with the theme of the letter as a whole.
  • In verses 23-25 we are told that men "exchanged...God" for created things, and so God "gave them up". In verses 26-27 we are told that women "exchanged natural relations for those contrary to nature...and the men likewise gave up natural relations with women". Sensitive thing to speculate about, but the parallel would seem to be deliberate. The patterns of our relationship with God are replayed on the smaller scale of human relationships.
  • Verses 18-32 goes through 3 cycles of denying God->sin. In the first two cycles the sin is sexual immorality, in the third cycle Paul widens the fallout to all kinds of (mainly horizontal) sin. Why? Perhaps to build up to 2:1. We all get busy judging those committing those sexual sins which are markers of a world in rebellion, then in the third cycle our sins are equated with them and the condemnation which we've applauded suddenly falls on us and Paul declares "Therefore you have no excuse, O man, every one of you who judges. For in passing judgment on another you condemn yourself, because you, the judge, practice the very same things." The rhetoric is quite powerful, but also deeply theological. He knows exactly what he's doing.

Tuesday, March 22, 2011

'God So Loved He Gave': A review

God So Loved, He Gave: Entering the Movement of Divine Generosity by Kelly M. Kapic with Justin Borger, Zondervan.

We might expect a book about giving to be a guilt-trip and focused on our wallet. This book is neither of these.

It begins “Let me tell you a story...the story about God.”

That tells you a lot about this book. It is not a long book, although its 200 pages are closely typed and it is tightly written. Nevertheless, it a big book in other ways. The book sweeps from creation, through the fall to redemption with God himself as the centre of the story. As the main actor in this drama God is thoughtfully and beautifully shown to be God the Father, Son and Holy Spirit. And the story’s major theme is God giving himself in the Son and the Spirit to a people who never deserved such grace.

With this as the big picture the application becomes refreshingly different to many exhortations to generosity you may have heard.

  • It is saturated in grace – we are reminded to give because we have first received.
  • It is God-centred – you are inspired to grow in generosity, but wonder and thankfulness for the Triune God is the dominant melody.
  • It is inviting rather than pushy - as the subtitle suggests, we are invited into God’s story and into the relationship between the three persons of the Trinity.

But this God of grace takes you to quite dizzying heights, and things look a bit different from his perspective. Just as God invites you in to join him, he invites you to join him going out in self-giving. Kapic and Berger show that it is the grace of the Triune God which will make generosity so much more radical than it would be otherwise. E.g.

  • God didn’t just give things, but his person - so how can we respond by just giving a percentage rather than our whole person?
  • We are rich because we have received so much - so how can we not give lavishly?

Personally the most memorable theme was that of belonging. We belong to God because he created us. This was perfect freedom but we rejected belonging to God and chose bondage to sin. God reclaimed us by giving (!) so we can experience the gift of being his slaves.

This book is so rich that I could spend a long time trying to describe its content but I would struggle to do it justice.

If you are wondering about the form: It is theological but I was pleasantly surprised how expositional it was. It would probably be enjoyed by any regular reader of Christian books but may be too demanding for an occasional reader. Finally, it is distinctly Reformed Evangelical in its theology but (in-keeping with the theme) Kapic is generous in drawing on a wide range of thinkers.

God So Loved He Gave is one of the very best books I’ve read in several years. It engaged me on every level (mind, heart and will) and there are not very many books you can say that about. I highly recommend this beautiful book.

[A detailed overview of the contents/headings/sub-headings and more on Kelly Kapic.]

Sunday, March 20, 2011

Responding to confession

Good headings from Stephen Altrogge, with my thoughts afterwards:

  • Do Respond Humbly
    • Requires you to know yourself a sinner
  • Do Identify With Their Struggle
    • Requires you to know yourself to struggle with similar, if different, sins
  • Don't Act Shocked
    • Requires you to know them, and all humanity. Sin is not a surprise, even in a Christian.
  • Don't Blow It Off
    • The initial, very strong, temptation. Count to ten, let the sinfulness of sin sink in. They know the sinfulness of sin so show that you know it as well.
  • Do Follow Up Later
    • Change is slow, and until we die temptations will probably recur. Even if not, the devil's accusations about past sin can eat away at assurance.
  • Do Remember the Gospel
    • The most important. Absolution should overshadow all confession. The announcement of their forgiveness. Also talk about the promise of freedom in Christ and our future hope.

Always open to more thoughts if people have them.

Glory

  • The Father is glorified in Jesus (John 13:31)
  • Jesus is glorified in the church (John 17:10)
  • The church is glorified in other churches (1 Thessalonians 2:19-20)

So, in other words:

  • The Father's glory is his Son
  • The Son's glory is the church
  • The church's glory is the growth of other congregations