Wednesday, May 04, 2011

The bronze serpent

"the Lord sent fiery serpents among the people, and they bit the people, so that many people of Israel died. And the people came to Moses and said, 'We have sinned, for we have spoken against the Lord and against you. Pray to the Lord, that he take away the serpents from us.' So Moses prayed for the people. And the Lord said to Moses, 'Make a fiery serpent and set it on a pole, and everyone who is bitten, when he sees it, shall live.' So Moses made a bronze serpent and set it on a pole. And if a serpent bit anyone, he would look at the bronze serpent and live." (Numbers 21:6-9)

"as Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness, so must the Son of Man be lifted up, that whoever believes in him may have eternal life." (John 3:14-15)

These passages were favourites of the Lutheran reformers. They often appear in their writings and also their art. Philip Melanchthon's coat of arms (above) was even the bronze serpent on a pole.

It was a favourite of theirs because it was a clear demonstration of what faith is. Faith is simply looking to Christ, specifically Christ crucified, and trusting the promise that if you look to him you will be saved.

However, I've always found the story in Numbers a bit odd. Perhaps it is just me, but why a bronze serpent?

I think the answer struck me yesterday. The serpent on the pole is a rigid and lifeless serpent. Jesus lifted up on the cross is a dead man. In Numbers God is promising the death of that which causes death and so life as a result. In John he is also promising the death of the law which causes us death so we can enjoy life as a result.

Looking at a dead serpent is not very palatable and looking at a dying man isn't either. But if that means the death of death, then it becomes a Good Friday.

Meetings at the well

Genesis 24: Abraham's servant and Rebekah

The young woman was very attractive in appearance, a maiden whom no man had known. She went down to the spring and filled her jar and came up. Then the servant ran to meet her and said, "Please give me a little water to drink from your jar." She said, "Drink, my lord." And she quickly let down her jar upon her hand and gave him a drink.

Genesis 29: Jacob and Rachel

While he was still speaking with them, Rachel came with her father's sheep, for she was a shepherdess. Now as soon as Jacob saw Rachel the daughter of Laban his mother's brother, and the sheep of Laban his mother's brother, Jacob came near and rolled the stone from the well's mouth and watered the flock of Laban his mother's brother.

Exodus 2: Moses and Zipporah

Now the priest of Midian had seven daughters, and they came and drew water and filled the troughs to water their father's flock. The shepherds came and drove them away, but Moses stood up and saved them, and watered their flock.

John 4: Jesus and the Samaritan Woman

A woman from Samaria came to draw water. Jesus said to her, "Give me a drink." ... The Samaritan woman said to him, "How is it that you, a Jew, ask for a drink from me, a woman of Samaria?" (For Jews have no dealings with Samaritans.) Jesus answered her, "If you knew the gift of God, and who it is that is saying to you, ‘Give me a drink,’ you would have asked him, and he would have given you living water."

I've some detailed thoughts on the connections between John 4 and Genesis 24 here.

Today I'd just like to note that Jesus begins by testing the Samaritan Woman, as Rebekah was tested by Abraham's servant. Through that test Rebekah was shown to be worthy of being Isaac's wife and the Samaritan unworthy of being a member of Jesus' bride. As well as this moral worth, Rebekah is physically beautiful. The Samaritan woman has had 5 husbands, and it is probably fair to speculate that she was past her prime by this stage.

However, Jesus doesn't reject this woman. Like Jacob and Moses before him he acts as a saviour. They provided water from the well, but Jesus provided living water.

Tuesday, May 03, 2011

God's love in a rubbish diagram

How can you describe God's loving activity in a diagram? It feels so stupid to even try. God wrote a whole Bible, and I try and sum it up in a diagram! I know it is so incomplete but hopefully it communicates something true.

click for bigger image

This is what I'm trying to express:

  • God's love breaks down into two categories: God's love for the lovely, and God's love for the unlovely. Too often we oppose love to wrath. Or we equate love with mercy. Both are category errors of massive proportions with massive implications. Often I want to ask, "which love are you talking about?"
  • God's love for the lovely is initially our problem. But God's love for the unlovely means we are born again into Jesus Christ in whom God's love for the lovely become good news. There is a story. Initially God's love for the lovely (including, but not equal to wrath) is bad news, but it becomes good news if we are found in Christ as it means we are glorified and the enemies of the church are destroyed.
  • Everywhere you see an arrow see the Spirit. The Spirit is how God acts, and God's love is always active. The Spirit's principle action is love, so we can call him God's love (although he is also a personal lover).
  • I know that the it is a big omission that the diagram doesn't show how God's love for the unlovely is the reason that Jesus Christ is sent to be born in the flesh.
  • God's Son becomes flesh in order to experience the wrath that is a result of God's love for his Son. That is amazing love. Or, as the Bible calls it, 'grace'.
  • Yes, you've guessed it. God's love for the lovely corresponds to 'the [Lutheran doctrine of] law' - it is good, but death for sinful humanity. God's love for the unlovely corresponds to the 'Gospel' - wonderful undeserved grace!
  • God's love for the unlovely is totally incomprehensible. I dare you to make sense of it! It is pure grace, there is nothing in it for God, but he pours it out anyway!
  • One of the most amazing things that Martin Luther ever wrote was the final theological thesis of his 1518 Heildelberg Disputation. You could meditate on it for ages:
  • The love of God does not find, but creates, that which is pleasing to it. The love of man comes into being through that which is pleasing to it.

Thoughts welcome. Praise God for love!

Monday, May 02, 2011

We are how we worship

Worship is where we meet God, and worship is how the Spirit forms us into the people of God... worship is a formative encounter with a living, active, covenant-keeping Lord... We are what we worship; we are also how we worship.

("Buried Treasures?" by James KA Smith)

I appreciate Jamie Smith's continual attempts to remind us of how the form of our worship shapes us.

God and his Gospel

"whoever loses his life for my sake and the gospel's will save it" (Mark 8:35)

Still thinking over my previous post on 'perichoretic salvation' I am struck today how, as Peter Mead comments, we often "have the notion that we know about God" already. Cor Deo and the like are excellent at saying 'actually you don't know the half of who God is'. He is much better than you think or could even imagine. I am really thankful for people like them encouraging me to seek to know God better and love him more.

However, this can be perverted (not by them) into saying that we just need more information about God. The cross becomes an exclusively revelatory event and before we know it grace has been lost and we're having to love and emulate this wonderful God in our own strength.

In contrast to this revelatory emphasis I know many will talk about 'gospel' all the time but never about God! We are 'saved', but are left wondering whether salvation all that attractive.

I don't think the answer is to equate the gospel and God. God is the Gospel is probably a great book and a helpful corrective, because without God the Gospel is not good news, but I'm not sure about the title. Perhaps the answer is to keep them distinct but intimately united, not separating them but not equating them either. I.e. lets be Trinitarian about this...

The Life of God in the Soul of Man

Henry Scougal's classic little book The Life of God in the Soul of Man has had a massive impact on many, including George Whitefield who said he "never knew what true religion was" until he read it. Fred Sanders includes it as one of his ten favourite theology books. You can read the book online for free, but I'd also recommend JI Packer's introduction to the CFP edition, which is also online. He sings its praises but he also offers a helpful corrective:

One could wish, however, that his exposition had been more explicitly and emphatically Christ-centred. Like so many seventeenth-century writers, he lets himself assume that his readers know all about Jesus and need only to be told about real religion, the life of faith and faith-full turning Godward as opposed to the orthodoxism, formalism, emotionalism and legalism that masquerade as Christianity while being in truth a denial of it. Had Scougal elaborated on the Christian’s union with Christ, which the New Testament sees as regeneration by the Holy Spirit; had he explained incorporation into the Saviour’s risen life, whereby Jesus’s motivating passion to know and love and serve and please and honour and glorify the Father is implanted in sinners so that it is henceforth their own deepest desire too; had he thus shown, in black and white, that imitating Jesus’s aims and attitudes in serving God and mankind is for the born-again the most natural, indeed the only natural, way of living, while for the unregenerate it is hard to the point of impossible; his little treatise would have been immeasurably stronger. As it is, Scougal’s profile of divine life in human souls is much more complete than his answer to the question, how do I get into it? – or, how does it get into me? This is a limitation.

Perichoretic salvation

In my previous post I quoted Fred Sanders who asked:

  • Did Good Friday and Easter happen so that Pentecost could benefit us, or
  • did Pentecost happen so that Good Friday and Easter could benefit us?

Another way of asking the question is:

  • Do we receive the Spirit in us because we are in Christ, or
  • are we in Christ because the Spirit is in us?

Yet another way of asking the question would be:

  • Is salvation the Trinitarian life of God in the soul of man (ala Scougal), or
  • is salvation the soul of man in the Trinitarian life of God?

If we believe that perichoresis (mutual indwelling) of the three persons of the Trinity is not a static state of being, but is a dynamic and continuous activity, then it is never 'or' it is always 'both' - distinct but one.

PS did you like my pompous title?!

The missions of the Son and the Spirit - each of them is a means to the other

Which of the two missions [of the Son and the Holy Spirit] is the means and which is the end? Thinking in terms of redemption accomplished and applied, it is easy to consider the Spirit's work as the means of delivering the Son's work. In that case the Son does the the thing itself - reconciling God and man - and the Spirit serves his work by applying it to individual lives. Pentecost, in this view, happens in order to fulfill and extend Calvary and Easter. On the other hand, when we consider the intimacy of spiritual fellowship that the indwelling of the Holy Spirit involves, it begins to look as if all God's ways lead up to the sending of the Spirit.

If God's goal is to dwell among his people, the atonement was a necessary step to make indwelling possible. The temple of human nature had to be cleansed to make it ready for the Spirit's indwelling. So the Son by incarnation prepared one perfect human temple, his own body, for the Spirit to be present in. And by atonement the Son purified the other temples, preparing them to receive the Spirit on the basis of the Son's finished work. "Christ redeemed us from the curse of the law by becoming a curse for us ... so that we might receive the promised Spirit through faith" (Gal 3:13-14), Calvary and Easter, in this view, happen in order to make Pentecost possible. If we have to ask whose work is the means and whose is the end, our answer must be either that the question is badly formed, or that each of them is a means to the other. The Spirit serves the Son by applying what he accomplished, and the Son serves the Spirit by making his indwelling possible. Both the Son and the Spirit, together on their twofold mission from the Father, serve the Father and minister to us.

(pp.148-149, Fred Sanders, Embracing the Trinity: Life with God in the Gospel)

Reconciliation - notes and questions

Listening to: Caitlin Rose: Own Side Now

"God... through Christ reconciled us to himself and gave us the ministry of reconciliation; 19 that is, in Christ God was reconciling the world to himself, not counting their trespasses against them, and entrusting to us the message of reconciliation. 20 Therefore, we are ambassadors for Christ, God making his appeal through us. We implore you on behalf of Christ, be reconciled to God." (2 Corinthians 5:18-20)

This passage has been going round my head a lot lately.

Notes:

  • Relationship to the Father as sons is the goal achieved by reconciliation.
  • Paul does not say, "God is reconciled to you, now please be reconciled to him"... Paul never says that in his letters, although that is usually how we present the Gospel ('God has moved toward you, now move toward him' is poor). Instead Paul says that in Christ, the representative man, the new humanity has been reconciled to God! As Torrance says, the covenant has been fulfilled from both sides already.
  • Nevertheless, there is a note of urgency as out of "fear of the Lord" Paul seeks to "persuade", "appeal" and "implore" his hearers to be reconciled.

Questions (a big plea for help!):

  • How does verse 19 differ from verse 18? "reconciled" v. "reconciling", "us" v. "world", "through Christ" v. "in Christ", "giving" v. "entrusting", "ministry" v. "message"... what's the significance?
  • How does this passage compare with Romans 5:10, "we were reconciled to God by the death of his Son.... now that we are reconciled [past, linked to death], shall we be saved by his life [future, linked to life]"? ... cf. also 2 Timothy 2:11: "If we have died with him [past, death], we will also live with him [future, life]" (also Romans 6:8)

Michael Horton's summary of the Gospel

What is your greatest fear? If I were asking that question in many parts of the world, answers would probably cluster around basic needs such as running water, food, vaccines, and shelter. For most of us in the United States, though, our greatest fears are more likely to be things like the fear of loneliness, some cataclysmic event that throws me off the ladder of upward mobility, divorce, or the inability to find any ultimate meaning in life. None of these fears is illegitimate, yet none is ultimate. These fears haunt us only because we have the luxury of having them haunt us. Until we are confronted with the reality of God—in all of his blinding majesty, weightiness, and frightful claim on our lives—we are overwhelmed by secondary troubles. But when for some reason there is the slightest glimpse of God in his holiness, we either do our best to domesticate him, turn him into a pet by suppressing the truth, or run for the hills to escape the confrontation.

God should be your greatest fear. Yet there is no salvation from God's just judgment from anywhere else than God himself. Only the same God who fills us with fear is able also to give us peace. If we are to escape this judgment, it will only be the result of the greatness in God's heart and not something in our own. That God has moved toward us—even lunged toward us—not in judgment, as we should have expected, but in loving embrace and reconciliation, clothing us in Christ's righteousness so that we can be acceptable in his holy presence, is the good news that you are called here and now to embrace. Christ lived a perfect life in the place of sinners, bore their sins on the cross, and was raised again for our justification. This means that "there is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus." Not because of anything that you have done, experienced, attempted, or decided, but because of what he has accomplished for you, can you be assured of God's favor. It is good news, not good advice. It is not a call to self-improvement, but to die to self altogether and be raised a new person, in Christ. It is the free gift of forgiveness of sins, right standing with God, adoption as his heirs, and liberation from the tyranny of sin. As his ambassador, I am calling you in his name to be reconciled to God by turning away from all other saviors and lords and embracing Jesus Christ as your righteousness, holiness, and redemption. Come to him now. His love is greater than your enmity toward him; his grace is greater than your sin; his peace is greater than your fears.

(HT 9 Marks)

Listening to a recording of a piece of classical music you often think that there are bits you like more or less than another recording. Similarly in this presentation of the Gospel of course there are always things you would change, but it is still a delight to hear the melody played so well! Amazing, and very Pauline.

Sunday, May 01, 2011

Another bit of wedding advice

Listening to: GF Handel: The Messiah (Pinnock)

Weddings are often the highlights of my year, so although I didn't watch all the Royal Wedding I enjoyed watching some of the highlights (esp the cartwheeling verger).

The sermon was very brief, and understandably couldn't say very much, but I think Huw Edwards' brief final comment on the BBC was the best analysis it is likely to receive. He called it "advice".

The same summary could be given for many wedding sermons I have heard, from evangelicals as much as anyone else. Usually the advice is very thoughtful and helpful, and the the Bishop's was too.

He was realistic about the difficulties that face married couples, and the reasons not to build our security on your spouse. Nevertheless, he said this was "a day of hope".... why?

Firstly, because of the potential for them to be "what God meant each one to be".

Secondly, because they had made a "solemn decision that, whatever the difficulties, [they] are committed to the way of generous love".

Thirdly, because they have each other to change them into "their work of art".

What about the God of hope?

The Bishop briefly, but nicely, described "a generous God who so loved the world that he gave himself to us in the person of Jesus Christ". He encouraged William and Kate to live "in the Spirit of this generous God...following the example of Jesus Christ".

This is good but inadequate. In the Bishop's sermon God is the God of hope because of his example and what he enables, not for what he has achieved in our place and promises to achieve in us.

So it included no substitution and no promise, and because of that there was no Gospel.

Despite including so much that was good and true, without the good news, the advice was hopeless. Even the attractive 'promise' of his opening words by St Catherine of Siena threw the happy couple back on their own efforts to emulate the generous God: "Be who God meant you to be and you will set the world on fire."

From that very moment, I was reminded of Oswald Bayer's quotation:

But whatever the new human being of the modern age is, that is what he or she must first become. The gospel of freedom, which is universally said to exist, puts the human being under the pressure to redeem himself at the very same time, and calls for him to achieve the potential that is by very nature his already. But if freedom is not promised and imparted, if instead it is characteristic of me from the outset, if I define myself in relation to it, then I am weighted down, in my individual and collective subjectivity, with having to fulfill the promise of what has been provided for me - not freed for freedom but at the same time " to freedom condemned" (Satre). It is not that I am able to be free, but that I have to free myself.

(italics original, pp.65-66, Oswald Bayer, Martin Luther's Theology: A Contemporary Interpretation)

So wedding preachers, please give us God's acts and promises as well as the advice, or you'll crush us all!

Ramblings on mustard seed faith

"The apostles said to the Lord, 'Increase our faith!'

And the Lord said, 'If you had faith like a grain of mustard seed, you could say to this mulberry tree, 'Be uprooted and planted in the sea,’ and it would obey you.'" (Luke 17:5-6)

One of the themes of New Word Alive was 'faith'. We were wonderfully taught that it is the object of your faith that matters most and not the strength of your faith.

  • Mike Reeves taught us that true faith is in God, not faith in your faith.
  • Steve Casey taught us that faith is confidence in the finished work of the Lord Jesus Christ for now and eternity, but false faith is confidence in this world for now and eternity.
  • Rico Tice, in preaching on the suffering Christians of Heb 11:36ff, taught us that faith is in God, not your agenda for God.

It is who our faith is in, and not the quantity of our faith that saves us. A mustard seed is enough to move a tree or a mountain.

But the size of our faith does matter because, while it may not affect our salvation, it does determine how much of that salvation we know here and now. A person of little faith is just as secure and just as loved by God as the person of great faith, but they may live indistinctive lives. A person of great faith will live out of the salvation they know they have received and make a great difference to the world as they serve their neighbours and spread the Gospel, despite great personal cost.

  • The size of your faith does not make a difference how much you receive from God (the vertical dimension).
  • However, the size of your faith does make a difference how much you give to others (the horizontal dimension).

How does Jesus increase the faith of the disciples in Luke 17? He increases their faith by telling them they have already received all they need from him with their week faith. He takes their eyes of their faith and encourages them to live out of what they have already received.

Saturday, April 30, 2011

Sojourn Music: The Water and the Blood

I love Sojourn Community Church, I love Sojourn Music, I love Isaac Watts and I love this video.

So this looks like a great album.

Let the witnesses correct our notebooks

I'd want to say more, but this is well put:

[the modern theologian or ordinary Christian] is not justified in comporting himself in relationship to those [biblical] witnesses as though he knew more about the Word than they... Still less is he a high-school teacher authorized to look over their shoulder benevolently or crossly, to correct their notebooks, or give them good, average, or bad marks. Even the smallest, strangest, simplest, or obscurest among the biblical witnesses has an incomparable advantage over even the most pious, scholarly, and sagacious latter-day theologian From his special point of view and in his special fashion, the witness has thought, spoken, and written about the revelatory Word and act in direct confrontation with it. All subsequent theology, as well as the whole of the community that comes after the event, will never find itself in the same immediate confrontation... For this reason theology must agree to let them look over its shoulder and correct its notebooks.

(pp. 31-32, Karl Barth, Evangelical Theology)

Wednesday, April 27, 2011

Tim Keller on Friendship - a model law/Gospel sermon

It may sound strange, but I think Tim Keller preaches the best law/Gospel sermons I have ever heard.

He is a great preacher in many ways, not least because most of his sermons take you on a journey. What is not obvious is that this journey is often law/Gospel. It is not obvious because he does it better than the simplified version preached by many who would explicitly say that they are preaching law and Gospel (particularly in including the power as well as the penalty of sin, the attractiveness of the good life that 'the law' describes, deeply rooting everything in our cultural and existential experience, climaxing in Christ but in a way naturally connected to the topic and all without jargon).

The theme of friendship in the book of Proverbs is probably the last place you would expect to see the law/Gospel structure, but that is an indication that we haven't really realised the depth of it. Keller's sermon on a selection of proverbs (17:17; 18:24; 25:17,20; 26:18-19; 27:5, 6, 9, 14, 17; 28:23; 29:5) is excellent for its content alone and I would encourage you to listen to it just for that. But if you do listen to it, consider also the law/Gospel journey he takes you on.

I'll attempt to outline his sermon using his own language in black and then show what lies behind what he is doing in my words in blue:

[THE LAW - describes the way life ought to be. The law is good as it shows the creation standard of how we should live. Therefore we should delight in it and live it out]

1. The Uniqueness of Friendship

Friendship offers something different to other relationships (familial, romantic) but in most societies is pushed out. Particularly in our busy and mobile culture.

2. The discovery of a friendship

Friendship requires a common foundation which is a common object of love. Friendship cannot be forged alone, but must be discovered.

3. The forging of the friendship

Once discovered the friendship needs to be forged (i.e. strengthened)

The 4 marks of true friendship are:

  • Constancy - availability, even in the difficult times
  • Carefulness - emotional connection given voluntarily meaning you mourn when they mourn and rejoice when they rejoice
  • Candour - we love our friends enough that we say difficult things for their own good even though it costs us
  • Counsel - Two way: Openness about yourself as well as rebuking and advising them

Conclusion of points 1-3

discovery + forging + time = friendship [the law is nothing if not logical, input the works and out comes the result]

[THE TURN - most good narratives have a 'turn' (I think the term exists in plot analysis, although wikipedia refers to it as 'the climax'). I can't think if I have heard this term anywhere talking about law/Gospel, but I think it is helpful to distinguish this moment when the Law ends and the Gospel come in. Keller is a master at this. At this point the law is fully understood and its weight felt. Up to now it has been presented as advice and a model. What this deeply attractive model has been doing to us is then brought to the surface and spelt out.]

Introduction to point 4

Having painted this picture of a perfect friendship two things happen:

  1. [Firstly the law reveals the power of sin, and shows us how we suffer under Sin in contrast to the way the world ought to be] We have a feeling of longing - Friends are taken away faster than we can make them so we do not have all the friends our hearts need.
  2. [Secondly the law reveals the penalty that is due us because we are part of the problem as we don't just suffer but cause suffering] We find the profile crushing - One of the reasons we don't have friends is because we fail to be great friends ourselves. We find it difficult to be transparent and we are reluctant to give the gift of emotional connection.

[THE GOSPEL: the solution is Christ and his substitutionary death and resurrection for us]

4. The power of friendship

Where then do we find the power to be the friends we need to be to have the friends we need to have?

[Jesus fulfils the law as he lives the perfect life, and he does it all for us:]

John 15: Jesus calls us his friends. But he is the perfect friend who lays down his life for us.

Genesis 1-3: We walked with God (a Hebrew way of describing friendship) but we turned our back on him. Most friends we do this to would turn on us in response but God didn't do that.

[Jesus died suffering the power and penalty of sin so that we could be freed from both:]

The cross: Christ lost his friendship with God so that he could have friendship with us. He went to hell for the sake of his friends.

[As he took our death now he gives us his life to us so that we share in all he has - inc his friendship with God:]

As we now have friendship with God, all our friendship eggs are not in the human basket so we are liberated to be the friend that we ought to be.

[In the church we taste the new creation that he has bought for us:]

God, in Christ, also creates the church where we share a common object of love, and yet are different so have 'constructive clash' (iron sharpening iron), so we can experience rich friendships in the church now.

[Only bit I think Keller is missing is a pointer to the future hope of perfect friendships with God and other people]

The law/Gospel dynamic

Lutheran spirituality, properly speaking, is not some static state of bliss, but a dynamic oscillation between lows and highs, knowledge of sin and knowledge of forgiveness, repentance and assurance.

(p. 28, Gene Veith, The Spirituality of the Cross)

I often have trouble explaining Lutheranism to other Christians. This is probably mainly my poor verbal communication skills, but I think it is also because most people have a static view of the Christian life.

Perhaps they see one movement at their conversion, but even that is a transfer from one static position to another. In contrast Lutheranism always sees God doing something to us with a purpose.

This law-Gospel dynamic is one of the fundamental features of Lutheranism and something I bang on about so much because I now also see it as fundamental to how the Bible works and my whole existence. However, I now prefer now to talk about death-life, because it emphasises God's purpose in the law/Gospel, is more comprehensive, avoids confusion about biblical v. systematic theological terminology, is more clearly storied and most importantly also roots it more in union with Christ.

One thing I want to clarify from the quote though is that it is not a circular motion, where high leads to low before low leads to high. The 'low'/death happens as a consequence of the experience of sin and suffering in this old creation. The 'high'/life is eternal with no dark side to it. The constant oscillation is a result of our current situation as simul iustus et peccator living in the now/not-yet. One day the dynamic will change.

Tuesday, April 26, 2011

1 Timothy 2: The mission of GOD in desiring ALL to be saved

God desires all people to be saved (1 Tim 2:4).

But this is not a dispassionate or passive 'wish'. God is active. The God who desires all to be saved is "God our Saviour" (v.3). We see that in the flow of the whole chapter:

v. 5: It all begins in the reality that there is one God. He is Lord of all the earth, Jew and Gentile, those in authority and those under authority, rich and poor, male and female (cf. both Rom 3:30, Eph 4:5 and Gal 3:20).

v. 5-6: Then it moves on to what God has done in Christ, "who gave himself as a ransom for all".

v. 7: Then Paul moves on to what Christ has done in appointing Paul to be an apostle (cf. Rom 1:1, Gal 1:16).

v. 8-15: Then he moves onto the church's role in spreading the mission. They are to pray, be unified (like their God, cf. Eph), they are to live holy lives.

So for Paul there is a narrative of God's actions in bringing about his desire. But is a narrative that flows from the sending of the Son, to the sending of the Apostles to the sending of the church. There is no unmediated way of salvation. There is one mediator, Jesus Christ, who we know through his body, the church.

[With thanks to Dave and Chris, for reminding me of the pursuing desire of God, and my housemate who is preaching on 1 Timothy 2 in a few weeks.]

Sunday, April 24, 2011

Christ in Philippians 4:8

"Rejoice in the Lord always...

Finally, brothers, whatever is true, whatever is honourable, whatever is just, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is commendable, if there is any excellence, if there is anything worthy of praise, think about these things." (Phil 4:4,8)

I don't think Paul is speaking directly about the Lord in verse 8... but he could have been. It's certainly worth meditating on that list and rejoicing in how Christ fulfils it all:

  • true
  • honourable
  • just
  • pure
  • lovely
  • commendable
  • excellent
  • worthy of praise

[PS in case you have ever wondered, this blog is named after Philippians 4:8. I can't say that I have always listened to Paul as I should, but it is my aim, so feel free to hold me to account when I fail.]

Reasonable faith

faith...is no blind leap in the dark. Far from it. The Bible teaches that faith is an exercise of reasonable trust in a God who is really there and has proved himself to be completely trustworthy. In fact, it would be utterly unreasonable and irrational not to trust in someone who has proved himself to be infinitely dependable. The whole Bible bears witness to the reality that God has been, is now, and will always be truthful and worthy of our trust. We may not always understand what God is doing or why he is doing it, but we have no good reason to doubt him.

(p.73, Do I Know God?, Tullian Tchividjian)

Out -> inside -> out

Now, our Scholastics and papists have taught an external piety; they would command the eyes not to see, and the ears not to hear, and would put piety into our hearts from the outside. Ah, how far this is from the truth! But it comes in this way: When the heart and conscience cling to the Word in faith, they overflow in works, so that when the heart is holy, all the members become holy, and good works follow naturally.

(Easter Sunday Sermon: Of Christ's Resurrection, on Mark 16:1-8)

Martin Luther criticised an ethics which taught that by doing good things you could develop good habits that would filter down into your heart. He saw this ethics in Medieval Scholastic theology, but originating in Aristotle ("Virtually the entire Ethics of Aristotle is the worst enemy of grace. This in opposition to the scholastics" [Disputation Against Scholastic Theology, 1517]).

But that does not mean that he thought that personal change was a simple case of inside->out.

Our hearts are not changed spontaneously but in response to the external word, which could only be understood correctly by prayer, meditation and experience (Or Anfechtung, see his three rules).

Therefore, Bonhoeffer was standing in Luther's line when he explained that:

only the believers obey, and only the obedient believe.

It is really unfaithfulness to the Bible to have the first statement without the second. Only the believer obeys - we think we can understand that. Of course, obedience follows faith, the way good fruit comes from a good tree, we say. First there is faith, then obedience. If this meant only that faith alone justifies us and not deeds of obedience, then it is a firm and necessary precondition for everything else. But if it meant a chronological sequence, that faith would have to come first, to be later followed by obedience, then faith and obedience are torn apart...

space should be kept and had to be kept for that external deed required to enable faith - the step, in this case, to the church, where the word of salvation is preached... You can leave your house on Sunday and go to hear the preaching. If you do not do it, then you willfully exclude yourself from the place where faith is possible...

it is not the works which create faith. Instead, you are given a situation in which you can have faith.

(italics original, pp. 63-67, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Discipleship)

[Note that as well as this 'religious work' he also gives examples of an alcoholic giving up alcohol or a rich man giving away his money]

[Note also that Bonhoeffer is not saying that the 'first step' is a 'good work', but that is a work, which allows space for faith, which leads to good works.]

Post-mortum response to the unveiled word

the Word of God is so weak that it suffers to be despised and rejected by people...This weak Word, which suffers contradiction by sinners, is the only strong, merciful Word, that can make sinners repent from the bottom of their hearts. The Word's power is veiled in weakness. If the Word came in full unveiled power, that would be the final judgment day.

(p.173, Deitrich Bonhoeffer, Discipleship)

It would be an interesting question to ask Rob Bell, whether it makes any difference that post-mortum repentance would be in response to the glorified and strong Word of Christ.

I think that when Paul says that he preached "the word of the cross" (1 Cor 1:18), he wasn't just referring to the content, but the form of Gospel he preached. It was weak and foolish, carried by jars of clay, just as Jesus seemed to so many in first century Judea.

At his second coming the Word will be much more a "word of the resurrection", and will be carried by angels blasting trumpets. Glory will be unveiled and strength exerted.

If Rob Bell sees people repenting, and trusting, in response to that Word then is there something quantitatively different to our repentance and faith?

Saturday, April 23, 2011

"Follow me"

It is significant that Jesus did not invite the disciples to tea, but rather said ‘Follow me’. Augustine found the idea of an effectual call in other biblical examples. So, Jesus commands, ‘Lazarus, come out’ (Jn.11:43), a speech act that literally wakes the dead. For Augustine, something similar happens each time God summons a person to new life.

(p. 343, Kevin Vanhoozer, "Effectual Call or Causal Effect? Summons, Sovereignty and Supervenient Grace", Tyndale Bulletin 49.2 (1998): 213-251)

Tough to stomach

There are so many things that we read in the Bible that are difficult to stomach. The obvious things to say when that happens are:

  • If it is the truth, it doesn't matter how you feel about it; and
  • God is God, and he is the one who gets to decide what is true and what is good. Get over it.

However, I think more can be said about why it is actually not just necessary but also good to swallow what the Bible says, even if we don't like the way it tastes.

1. Not a Stepford God

Firstly, it is an indication that we are dealing with an independent person. And a new personal relationship with our Heavenly Father is what makes the Gospel attractive. Tim Keller says this better than anyone I have read:

“If you don’t trust the Bible enough to let it challenge and correct your thinking, how could you ever have a personal relationship with God? In any truly personal relationship, the other person has to be able to contradict you.

“For example, if a wife is not allowed to contradict her husband, they won’t have an intimate relationship. Remember the (two!) movies The Stepford Wives? The husbands of Stepford, Connecticut, decide to have their wives turned into robots who never cross the wills of their husbands. A Stepford wife was wonderfully compliant and beautiful, but no one would describe such a marriage as intimate or personal.

“Now, what happens if you eliminate anything from the Bible that offends your sensibility and crosses your will? If you pick and choose what you want to believe and reject the rest, how will you ever have a God who can contradict you? You won’t! You’ll have a Stepford God! A God, essentially, of your own making, and not a God with whom you can have a relationship and genuine interaction.

“Only if your God can say things that outrage you and make you struggle (as in a real friendship or marriage!) will you know that you have gotten hold of a real God and not a figment of your imagination.

(Tim Keller, The Reason for God, pages 113-114)

2. True Truth

Secondly, as Keller mentions in that final paragraph, it is also an indication that we have come up against true truth. In his brilliant address, The Weight of Glory says the same thing:

The natural appeal of [the imagery of 'glory'] is to me, at first, very small. At first sight it chills, rather than awakes, my desire. And that is just what I ought to expect. If Christianity could tell me no more of the far-off land than my own temperament led me to surmise already, then Christianity would be no higher than myself. If it has more to give me, I must expect it to be less immediately attractive than “my own stuff.” ... If our religion is something objective, then we must never avert our eyes from those elements in it which seem puzzling or repellent; for it will be precisely the puzzling or the repellent which conceals what we do not yet know and need to know.

3. The way to find new vistas we could not conceive

Thirdly, we trust God from experience and his promises that if we go through accepting these difficult truths we will find that actually it opens up even more beautiful and awe-inspiring vistas than we would otherwise have seen. Lewis, having taken us on just that journey in The Weight of Glory, explains how pushing through his initial distaste with the concept of glory led him to discover something that is richer and more satisfying than if he had just rejected it out of hand:

If I had rejected the authoritative and scriptural image of glory and stuck obstinately to the vague desire which was, at the outset, my only pointer to heaven, I could have seen no connexion at all between that desire and the Christian promise. But now, having followed up what seemed puzzling and repellent in the sacred books, I find, to my great surprise, looking back, that the connexion is perfectly clear. Glory, as Christianity teaches me to hope for it, turns out to satisfy my original desire and indeed to reveal an element in that desire which I had not noticed. By ceasing for a moment to consider my own wants I have begun to learn better what I really wanted.

Today I have listened to Rob Bell quizzing Adrian Warnock whether he is happy with the idea of God condemning people to hell. The doctrine is difficult for both to swallow, but Adrian Warnock choses to swallow and Rob Bell doesn't.

But I have also listened to Jack Miller, saying "cheer up, you're a lot worse off than you think." Original sin is a difficult doctrine for many to swallow, but Jack Miller movingly shows how it is only through fully absorbing it that we find freedom and adoption.

Finally, I would say - bring your concerns and questions to God. Wrestle with him, but with the hope that he and not you will prevail.

Gift giving

I have just received a package from Amazon containing a book I have bought for a friend. In intention this book is for my friend, but nobody knows that yet. I didn't tell Amazon, I haven't told anyone else and there is no indication on the book itself that it is for my friend.

Does the book belong to me or is it my friend's book? I think you could argue both ways at the moment.

However, when I wrap it up and give it to my friend saying 'this is for you,' then it will be clear that it is now his book. The act of giving, with the words accompanying it, achieve something. It is a speech-act which acomplishes what it says.

Jesus' death and resurrection can be like this. He died and was raised for us, but the event itself does not tell us that.

Jesus' own words and the Bible as a whole interpret the meaning of the event, but it becomes deeply personal when, as Christ's ambassadors Christians say 'you are forgiven,' and just that thing occurs. Forgiveness actually happens in that moment. It has already happened in the cruxifiction and resurrection of Christ, but it is applied in the declaration of absolution that Christians make on their Lord's behalf. Modern evangelicals may baulk at the weight of Jesus' instructions to his disciples, "if you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you withhold forgiveness from any, it is withheld" (John 20:23), but there is no more fundamental part of Gospel-ministry.

Under English law I cannot give a house to someone with only spoken words. It is considered that land is such an important asset that for it to be given away additional formalities have to be observed. So land can only be legally given by way of deed. A deed is written document signed by both parties, which until recently had also to be sealed (e.g. with impressed wax). This deed gives certainty to all the parties that the gift really happened and was not just empty words.

Baptism corresponds to this. It is a binding, visible promise of God that we have died and been raised with Christ and it achieves what it promises. If later in life we have doubts about our true identity or whether we have been forgiven, we point to the cross and resurrection of Jesus but through the word and sacrament that we have already received as a personal address to us. This is what Paul does in Romans 6, and what Luther did when he responded to the devil's acqusations by crying out "I am baptized!"

I may have been given a beautiful house but it is another thing to receive it and live in it.

There are a number of different ways I can respond to the gift:

(i) If I believe that this house is now both mine and more beautiful and solid than the house I currently live in I will joyfully move in all my possessions, explore every room, make myself at home and invite others to share in my joy by inviting them to stay.

(ii) But while I may believe that this house is mine I may doubt that it is really that nice a house. My heart may remain in my old house, and I may want to live there most of the time. When the floods come then I will finally realise that this house I have been given is the best, but in the meantime wise friends will warn me of the dangers of living in my old house, and extol the beauty and security that the new house offers. They won't spend time persuading me that the house is mine, but they will spend time persuading me that the house is a uniquely wonderful place to live.

(iii) Sadly, I may love the house but even with the deed in my hands not believe that it is really mine. Perhaps I think that past or present sins disqualify me from such a gift. I might feel I need to earn the house and start sending the giver cheques out of my wages - even though he never asked for them. To this person wise friends will point to the promise; the words and the title deeds. 'This house is yours, enjoy it!' 'You have been baptised, the promise is yours free of charge, live out that reality!'

(iv) Finally, I may doubt that the house exists at all and the house I live in is the only house there is. I may have heard the promise and been given the deeds but concluded that they are worthless pieces of paper. Wise friends will explain how they have seen the house, how it is attested by reliable witnesses and fits with the rest of our experience. To this person you may give Lee Strobel's The Case for Christ.

Friday, April 22, 2011

Good Friday - How to Contemplate Christ's Holy Sufferings - Martin Luther

I. THE FALSE VIEWS OF CHRIST'S SUFFERINGS

1. In the first place, some reflect upon the sufferings of Christ in a way that they become angry at the Jews, sing and lament about poor Judas, and are then satisfied; just like by habit they complain of other persons, and condemn and spend their time with their enemies. Such an exercise may truly be called a meditation not on the sufferings of Christ, but on the wickedness of Judas and the Jews.

2. In the second place, others have pointed out the different benefits and fruits springing from a consideration of Christ's Passion. Here the saying ascribed to Albertus is misleading, that to think once superficially on the sufferings of Christ is better than to fast a whole year or to pray the Psalter every day, etc. The people thus blindly follow him and act contrary to the true fruits of Christ's Passion; for they seek therein their own selfish interests. Therefore they decorate themselves with pictures and booklets, with letters and crucifixes, and some go so far as to imagine that they thus protect themselves against the perils of water, of fire, and of the sword, and all other dangers. In this way the suffering of Christ is to work in them an absence of suffering, which is contrary to its nature and character.

3. A third class so sympathize with Christ as to weep and lament for him because he was so innocent, like the women who followed Christ from Jerusalem, whom he rebuked, in that they should better weep for themselves and for their children. Such are they who run far away in the midst of the Passion season, and are greatly benefitted by the departure of Christ from Bethany and by the pains and sorrows of the Virgin Mary, but they never get farther. Hence they postpone the Passion many hours, and God only knows whether it is devised more for sleeping than for watching. And among these fanatics are those who taught what great blessings come from the holy mass, and in their simple way they think it is enough if they attend mass. To this we are led through the sayings of certain teachers, that the mass opere operati, non opere operantis, is acceptable of itself, even without our merit and worthiness, just as if that were enough. Nevertheless the mass was not instituted for the sake of its own worthiness, but to prove us, especially for the purpose of meditating upon the sufferings of Christ. For where this is not done, we make a temporal, unfruitful work out of the mass, however good it may be in itself. For what help is it to you, that God is God, if he is not God to you? What benefit is it that eating and drinking are in themselves healthful and good, if they are not healthful for you, and there is fear that we never grow better by reason of our many masses, if we fail to seek the true fruit in them?

II. THE TRUE VIEW OF CHRIST'S SUFFERINGS

4. Fourthly, they meditate on the Passion of Christ aright, who so view Christ that they become terror-stricken in heart at the sight, and their conscience at once sinks in despair. This terror-stricken feeling should spring forth, so that you see the severe wrath and the unchangeable earnestness of God in regard to sin and sinners, in that he was unwilling that his only and dearly beloved Son should set sinners free unless he paid the costly ransom for them as is mentioned in Is 53, 8: "For the transgression of my people was he stricken." What happens to the sinner, when the dear child is thus stricken? An earnestness must be present that is inexpressible and unbearable, which a person so immeasurably great goes to meet, and suffers and dies for it; and if you reflect upon it real deeply, that God's Son, the eternal wisdom of the Father, himself suffers, you will indeed be terror-stricken; and the more you reflect the deeper will be the impression.

5. Fifthly, that you deeply believe and never doubt the least, that you are the one who thus martyred Christ. For your sins most surely did it. Thus St. Peter struck and terrified the Jews as with a thunderbolt in Acts 2, 36-37, when he spoke to them all in common: "Him have ye crucified," so that three thousand were terror-stricken the same day and tremblingly cried to the apostles: "0 beloved brethren what shall we do?" Therefore, when you view the nails piercing through his hands, firmly believing it is your work. Do you behold his crown of thorns, believe the thorns are your wicked thoughts, etc.

6. Sixthly, now see, where one thorn pierces Christ, there more than a thousand thorns should pierce thee, yea, eternally should they thus and even more painfully pierce thee. Where one nail is driven through his hands and feet, thou shouldest eternally suffer such and even more painful nails; as will be also visited upon those who let Christ's sufferings be lost and fruitless as far as they are concerned. For this earnest mirror, Christ, will neither lie nor mock; whatever he says must be fully realized.

7. Seventhly, St. Bernard was so terror-stricken by Christ's sufferings that he said: I imagined I was secure and I knew nothing of the eternal judgment passed upon me in heaven, until I saw the eternal Son of God took mercy upon me, stepped forward and offered himself on my behalf in the same judgment. Ah, it does not become me still to play and remain secure when such earnestness is behind those sufferings. Hence he commanded the women: "Weep not for me, but weep for yourselves, and for your children." Lk 23, 28; and gives in the 31st verse the reason: "For if they do these things in the green tree, what shall be done in the dry?" As if to say: Learn from my martyrdom what you have merited and how you should be rewarded. For here it is true that a little dog was slain in order to terrorize a big one. Likewise the prophet also said: "All generations shall lament and bewail themselves more than him"; it is not said they shall lament him, but themselves rather than him. Likewise were also the apostles terror-stricken in Acts 2, 37, as mentioned before, so that they said to the apostles: "0, brethren, what shall we do?" So the church also sings: I will diligently meditate thereon, and thus my soul in me will exhaust itself.

8. Eighthly, one must skillfully exercise himself in this point, for the benefit of Christ's sufferings depends almost entirely upon man coming to a true knowledge of himself, and becoming terror-stricken and slain before himself And where man does not come to this point, the sufferings of Christ have become of no true benefit to him. For the characteristic, natural work of Christ's sufferings is that they make all men equal and alike, so that as Christ was horribly martyred as to body and soul in our sins, we must also like him be martyred in our consciences by our sins. This does not take place by means of many words, but by means of deep thoughts and a profound realization of our sins. Take an illustration: If an evil-doer were judged because he had slain the child of a prince or king, and you were in safety, and sang and played, as if you were entirely innocent, until one seized you in a horrible manner and convinced you that you had enabled the wicked person to do the act; behold, then you would be in the greatest straits, especially if your conscience also revolted against you. Thus much more anxious you should be, when you consider Christ's sufferings. For the evil doers, the Jews, although they have now judged and banished God, they have still been the servants of your sins, and you are truly the one who strangled and crucified the Son of God through your sins, as has been said.

9. Ninthly, whoever perceives himself to be so hard and sterile that he is not terror-stricken by Christ's sufferings and led to a knowledge of him, he should fear and tremble. For it cannot be otherwise; you must become like the picture and sufferings of Christ, be it realized in life or in hell; you must at the time of death, if not sooner, fall into terror, tremble, quake and experience all Christ suffered on the cross. It is truly terrible to attend to this on your deathbed; therefore you should pray God to soften your heart and permit you fruitfully to meditate upon Christ's Passion. For it is impossible for us profoundly to meditate upon the sufferings of Christ of ourselves, unless God sink them into our hearts. Further, neither this meditation nor any other doctrine is given to you to the end that you should fall fresh upon it yourself, to accomplish the same; but you are first to seek and long for the grace of God, that you may accomplish it through God's grace and not through your own power. For in this way it happens that those referred to above never treat the sufferings of Christ aright; for they never call upon God to that end, but devise out of their own ability their own way, and treat those sufferings entirely in a human and an unfruitful manner.

10. Tenthly, whoever meditates thus upon God's sufferings for a day, an hour, yea, for a quarter of an hour, we wish to say freely and publicly, that it is better than if he fasts a whole year, prays the Psalter every day, yea, than if he hears a hundred masses. For such a meditation changes a man's character and almost as in baptism he is born again, anew. Then Christ's suffering accomplishes its true, natural and noble work, it slays the old Adam, banishes all lust, pleasure and security that one may obtain from God's creatures; just like Christ was forsaken by all, even by God.

11. Eleventhly, since then such a work is not in our hands, it happens that sometimes we pray and do not receive it at the time; in spite of this one should not despair nor cease to pray. At times it comes when we are not praying for it, as God knows and wills; for it will be free and unbound: then man is distressed in conscience and is wickedly displeased with his own life, and it may easily happen that he does not know that Christ's Passion is working this very thing in him, of which perhaps he was not aware, just like the others so exclusively meditated on Christ's Passion that in their knowledge of self they could not extricate themselves out of that state of meditation. Among the first the sufferings of Christ are quite and true, among the others a show and false, and according to its nature God often turns the leaf, so that those who do not meditate on the Passion, really do meditate on it; and those who hear the mass, do not hear it; and those who hear it not, do hear it.

III. THE COMFORT OF CHRIST'S SUFFERINGS

12. Until the present we have been in the Passion week and have celebrated Good Friday in the right way: now we come to Easter and Christ's resurrection. When man perceives his sins in this light and is completely terror-stricken in his conscience, he must be on his guard that his sins do not thus remain in his conscience, and nothing but pure doubt certainly come out of it; but just as the sins flowed out of Christ and we became conscious of them, so should we pour them again upon him and set our conscience free. Therefore see well to it that you act not like perverted people, who bite and devour themselves with their sins in their heart, and run here and there with their good works or their own satisfaction, or even work themselves out of this condition by means of indulgences and become rid of their sins; which is impossible, and, alas, such a false refuge of satisfaction and pilgrimages has spread far and wide.

13. Thirteenthly. Then cast your sins from yourself upon Christ, believe with a festive spirit that your sins are his wounds and sufferings, that he carries them and makes satisfaction for them, as Is 53,6 says: "Jehovah hath laid on him the iniquity of us all;" and St. Peter in his first Epistle 2, 24: "Who his own self bare our sins in his body upon the tree" of the cross; and St. Paul in 2 Cor 5,21: "Him who knew no sin was made to be sin on our behalf; that we might become the righteousness of God in him." Upon these and like passages you must rely with all your weight, and so much the more the harder your conscience martyrs you. For if you do not take this course, but miss the opportunity of stilling your heart, then you will never secure peace, and must yet finally despair in doubt. For if we deal with our sins in our conscience and let them continue within us and be cherished in our hearts, they become much too strong for us to manage and they will live forever. But when we see that they are laid on Christ and he has triumphed over them by his resurrection and we fearlessly believe it, then they are dead and have become as nothing. For upon Christ they cannot rest, there they are swallowed up by his resurrection, and you see now no wound, no pain, in him, that is, no sign of sin. Thus St. Paul speaks in Rom 4, 25, that he was delivered up for our trespasses and was raised for our justification; that is, in his sufferings he made known our sins and also crucified them; but by his resurrection he makes us righteous and free from all sin, even if we believe the same differently.

14. Fourteenthly. Now if you are not able to believe, then, as I said before, you should pray to God for faith. For this is a matter in the hands of God that is entirely free, and is also bestowed alike at times knowingly, at times secretly, as was just said on the subject of suffering.

15. But now bestir yourself to the end: first, not to behold Christ's sufferings any longer; for they have already done their work and terrified you; but press through all difficulties and behold his friendly heart, how full of love it is toward you, which love constrained him to bear the heavy load of your conscience and your sin. Thus will your heart be loving and sweet toward him, and the assurance of your faith be strengthened. Then ascend higher through the heart of Christ to the heart of God, and see that Christ would not have been able to love you if God had not willed it in eternal love, to which Christ is obedient in his love toward you; there you will find the divine, good father heart, and, as Christ says, be thus drawn to the Father through Christ. Then will you understand the saying of Christ in Jn 3, 16: "God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten Son," etc. That means to know God aright, if we apprehend him not by his power and wisdom, which terrify us, but by his goodness and love; there our faith and confidence can then stand immovable and man is truly thus born anew in God.

16. Sixteenthly. When your heart is thus established in Christ, and you are an enemy of sin, out of love and not out of fear of punishment, Christ's sufferings should also be an example for your whole life, and you should meditate on the same in a different way. For hitherto we have considered Christ's Passion as a sacrament that works in us and we suffer; now we consider it, that we also work, namely thus: if a day of sorrow or sickness weighs you down, think, how trifling that is compared with the thorns and nails of Christ. If you must do or leave undone what is distasteful to you: think, how Christ was led hither and thither, bound and a captive. Does pride attack you: behold, how your Lord was mocked and disgraced with murderers. Do unchastity and lust thrust themselves against you: think, how bitter it was for Christ to have his tender flesh torn, pierced and beaten again and again. Do hatred and envy war against you, or do you seek vengeance: remember how Christ with many tears and cries prayed for you and all his enemies, who indeed had more reason to seek revenge. If trouble or whatever adversity of body or soul afflict you, strengthen your heart and say: Ah, why then should I not also suffer a little since my Lord sweat blood in the garden because of anxiety and grief? That would be a lazy, disgraceful servant who would wish to lie in his bed while his lord was compelled to battle with the pangs of death.

17. Behold, one can thus find in Christ strength and comfort against all vice and bad habits. That is the right observance of Christ's Passion, and that is the fruit of his suffering, and he who exercises himself thus in the same does better than by hearing the whole Passion or reading all masses. And they are called true Christians who incorporate the life and name of Christ into their own life, as St. Paul says in Gal 5, 24: "And they that are of Christ Jesus have crucified the flesh with the passions and the lusts thereof." For Christ's Passion must be dealt with not in words and a show, but in our lives and in truth. Thus St. Paul admonishes us in Heb 12, 3: "For consider him that hath endured such gainsaying of sinners against himself, that ye wax not weary, fainting in your souls;" and St. Peter in his 1 Epistle 4, 1: "As Christ suffered in the flesh, arm ye yourselves also with the same mind." But this kind of meditation is now out of use and very rare, although the Epistles of St. Paul and St. Peter are full of it. We have changed the essence into a mere show, and painted the meditation of Christ's sufferings only in letters and on walls