Saturday, January 02, 2010

According to the Scriptures?

Paul says in 1 Corinthians 15:3-4:

For what I received I passed on to you as of first importance: that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures, that he was buried, that he was raised on the third day according to the Scriptures

But which Scriptures? Initially I could only think of Jonah, but Craig Blomberg (p. 296, 1 Corinthians (NIVAC)) is helpful:

It is less clear which Scriptures point to the resurrection on the third day. Perhaps [although CK Barrett says the Greek does not suggest this] Paul meant only that the Scriptures testified to Christ's resurrection, with passages like Psalms 16:8-11 and 110:1-4 in view (cf. Acts 2:24-36). In that case, "according to the Scriptures" would modify only the verb "raised" and not the phrase "on the third day." But he may also have found some typological significance in the third-day references to God's vindication of his people in such texts as Genesis 42:18. Exodus 19:16, Joshua 2:22, Ezra 8:32, Esther 5:1, Jonah 1:17 (cf. Matt. 12:40), and especially Hosea 6:2.

In a footnote he says that B. de Margerie "demonstrates how the ancient rabbis linked such texts together in an early midrash on Genesis 22:4", which itself may also be a text that Paul had in mind.

I have also heard Mike Reeves mention Genesis 1:11-13 where on the third day the earth brings forth vegetation (life). That seems a plausible text given Jesus' own prediction of his death and resurrection in John 12:24 ("unless a grain of wheat falls into the earth and dies, it remains alone; but if it dies, it bears much fruit").

UPDATE: As Dave Bish pointed out, Mike Reeves (and others, e.g. Barnabas Lindars), also see a convincing connection between 1 Corinthians 15 and Leviticus 23. In Leviticus 23:9-14 the Israelites are instructed to bring the firstfruits of the harvest to the priest to be waved "the day after the Sabbath", the same day as Jesus rose from the dead as the "firstfruits of those who have fallen asleep" (1 Corinthians 15:20-23).

Friday, January 01, 2010

Alternative audio

Suggestions for reading in 2010

Listening to: Martha Wainwright: Sans Fusils, Ni Souliers, A Paris. Martha Wainwright's Piaf Record

Looking back on 2009 and my reading, I have three convictions. Firstly, I have not read enough of the Bible itself despite making time to read lots of Christian books. Secondly, I have not read many Biblical Studies. Thirdly, I have not read many books that are not Christian.

I feel the third one pretty keenly because I've now been living for over a year with Christians and without a TV and I'm feeling increasingly cut off from our culture. That may just be because I'm getting old, but I'm sure reading only theology/law books and living with Christians doesn't help.

Anyway, just over a year ago I asked for some recommendations of books to read. I read one and a bit books that Steve recommended. I read one that Glen recommended, and two from other authors he mentioned (but not the specific books he suggested). Belatedly I'm currently reading a book by David Wells I bought months ago because he was recommended by Peter (although I'm reading The Courage to be Protestant which apparently covers the same stuff as the book Peter actually recommended but in a briefer way). Somehow I thought I'd read a recommendation of Chris, but looking back now I actually didn't - I just bought one of the books and didn't read it! Anyway, if people want to recommend any non-Christian books (fiction or non-fiction) I should read, then I'm listening. Just don't suggest anything too long. I have a short attention span, and don't like to have forgotten the beginning by the time I get to the end. I'm currently thinking of reading The Passion of the Western Mind: Understanding the Ideas That Have Shaped Our World View by Richard Tarnas, Brave New World by Aldous Huxley, and Amusing Ourselves to Death by Neil Postman. But please feel free to suggest something more fun!

So... any thoughts?

How to read the Bible in 2010

Listening to: Andrew Bird: Noble Beasts

We're starting a New Year and so for many people its time to restart that Bible reading plan, or at least resolve to try and read the Bible more regularly. But more important than just reading the Bible is how we do it, or what use we make of it. I often come to reading the Bible with no aim whatsoever - more fool me. We should ask "what is the Bible for?" Here are three possible answers:

1. To bring Christ to us - the Christological use of Scripture

Jesus Christ, crucified and risen, is the content and theme of the Scriptures. It is all about him. So when we read the Bible we should be expecting to meet him in its pages. Of course it tells us how to live our life, it tells us about the religious customs of the Ancient Near East, it gives us words to express some of our deepest emotions, and all-sorts. But that is all with one aim - to drive us to Jesus Christ, his death and resurrection for us.

When I read my daily Bible reading I want to look to Christ. I don't want to look at the knowledge that I gain in by studying it. I also don't want to look at myself piously using my time to read it.

I love Dave Bish's little video of Mike Reeves on this.

I want to to be transfixed by Jesus this year through reading my Bible. To know Christ, and his work, better.

2. To be proclaimed - the Centrifugal use of Scripture

Luther apparently said that "The church is not a pen-house but a mouth-house". By which he meant that the church is not meant to be studying Scripture but proclaiming it. So we are not Gnostics, reading the Bible to gain secret knowledge for ourselves. We are to declare its content (Christ) to our brothers and sisters in the church, and to those we know who are not yet Christians. When we read Scripture we should be thinking: "What does this have to say to Jack struggling with motivation in his job?" "What relevance does Christ declared here have to Jill who finds a God who sends people to hell intolerable?" "What does the passage I have read have to say to the culture I live in?" We should then take what we have heard in the Scripture and share it with people. Like the Jews, we have been "entrusted with the oracles of God" (Rom 3:2), but entrusted with them in order to declare them to the world. We receive Christ through the Scriptures, but that is a gift for us to pass on.

I want to see my friends and family change by my reading of the Bible this year. To see some turn to Jesus, and others be built up by the truth of the Gospel.

3. To be applied - the Centripetal use of Scripture

Last year I often thought about Bonhoeffer's observation that American Christianity was "Protestantism without Reformation". In context he meant that American Christians hadn't understood that "God's 'criticism' touches even religion". So it is not "us and them" (i.e. the Church and the World) because we too are still sinners. The Church is still sinful, and we need the Gospel as much as the world. As Solzhenitsyn famously said "the line separating good and evil passes not through states, nor between classes, nor between political parties either, but right through every human heart". The condemnation of the "law" and the encouragement of the Gospel is for us.

The "them" who we imagine "need to hear this" is not just our contemporaries either. Practically, I often sense that we are particularly poor at applying the Scripture to ourselves when reading the OT. We often read the OT condemnations against the faithlessness of Israel, as against either non-Christians, or worse as merely historical fact. Instead we should read the OT like the Apostles who saw Israel as the Church - which means both the condemnations and the promises that they heard belong to us too.

So we should always be asking questions like: "what does this say to our church?" "where am I in this parable?" "what is the appropriate response for me to make to this passage?"

I want to be changed by my reading of the Bible this year. To put to death sin, and rejoice in what I have been given.

The first use is the primary one, and in a way contains the other two. But if we don't use the Bible Centrifugally we become hermits and if we don't use it Centripetally we become self-righteous. I fear I often don't use it in any of the three ways, but I pray 2010 will be different.

[Inspired/plagiarised from Leo Sanchez's lecture 'Uses of Scripture' in the Lutheranmind series]

Tuesday, December 29, 2009

Why we get on the merry-go-round in the first place

The lack of recent blog activity (now being overcompensated for) may have made you realise that I've been quite busy recently. I tend to go through phases of taking on too much, and Christmas was a wonderful rest from that. Tim Chester's The Busy Christian's Guide to Busyness is a brilliant book on how it is our lack of faith that often (although not always) leads us to be over busy. I highly recommend it.

But Helmut Thielicke said the same a few decades ago when preaching on the parable of the seed growing secretly (Mark 4:26-29):

Our overactivity, which constantly keeps us on the merry-go-round and yet, no matter how fast we go, gets us nowhere, but only makes us dizzy, is not caused by the fact that we were so nervous or that we had no time. It is just the opposite. We are nervous and we have no time because we think everything will stop without us and because we think we are so tremendously important - we parvenus [newcomers/upstarts] in this old business of creation! And this is why we can never let anything get out of our hands and be entrusted to others. That's why we hold on to everything convulsively and thus wear ourselves out all over again. Undoubtedly, all this is connected with the ultimate decisions of our life and not so much at all with medicine or with the problem of our modern way of life. And because we have thus taken over the management of the bankrupt assets of creation, because we do everything ourselves and therefore must always be producing something, we never get away from constant care and concern. For anybody who takes everything upon himself finds that everything depends on him.

(p.84f, The Waiting Father: Sermons on the Parables of Jesus)

Isn't the true gospel so freeing in comparison to the false gospel of our mastery over the world? No wonder it rest is so important in the bible. Not because passiveness towards the world is the ideal, but because God is active in caring for his creation.

Thielicke on the Parable of the Soils

Helmut Thielicke makes two really important points that I think I often miss when reading this familiar parable:

1. It is a solemn parable

I wonder whether we have caught the sadness that hangs over this story. Jesus spoke this parable at a high point in his life and activity. The people were flocking to him in great numbers [and yet] the parable is really pointing out how frequently the divine seed is destroyed - destroyed in stony hearts, by the heat of the sun, by choking thorns and predatory birds - this is why there is in this parable a deep sense of grief and sorrow. And all this is seen and proclaimed while outwardly the people are coming in droves, inspired with festive enthusiasm, and the hucksters are rubbing their hands with delight over this "colossal" attraction

(p.53, The Waiting Father: Sermons on the Parables of Jesus)

2. It is meant to provoke a response

We should be misunderstanding [Jesus] disastrously if we thought that this was simply an enumeration of the forces which obstruct and choke our faith for our information or even for self-examination. This is more than "analysis." Jesus is never interested in counting and statistics; he always puts us to work. He says: Weed out the thorns; see to it that the seed does not fall on the path; be careful lest you be people so shallow that the Word cannot take root. Jesus says: Be good soil.

(p. 59f, ibid)

Monday, December 28, 2009

Are we sure assurance should be sought for?

[To S]

Luther's whole theology was driven by the question of how he could be assured of God's favour - how he could know that he was saved. He even defined faith as including assurance of salvation.

Our theology is shaped by the questions we asked. Was that the wrong question for Luther to be asking? Should we expect Christians to be sure of their salvation? Perhaps it is even unhelpful.

In contemporary Evangelicalism you could often assume that good emotions, and positive feelings are the primary purpose of all Christian activities. So we don't even think if there is anything wrong with Luther's question. But it is a question we should ask. Why is assurance of salvation essential to Christian faith?

Off the top of my head I would give two answers:

  1. It honours God as truthful. To not be assured of your salvation is to call God a liar, because he promises just that in the Bible, the words of Christians, and the sacraments. "when the soul firmly trusts God's promises, it regards him as truthful and righteous. Nothing more excellent than this can be ascribed to God [this is the] very highest worship of God" (Martin Luther, The Freedom of the Christian).
  2. It is the only way anyone will do good works. We will never be motivated to do truly good works by mere command, even less by fear. Unless we are sure that we have all that we need we will look first to shoring up our own salvation, before seeking to serve others. Unless we know for sure that God loves us we will not love him in return. A few quotes:

"For what reason is faith, as trust in God's promise [of our forgiveness], given priority over all works? In what way does it alone make all works good? Because it alone - and thus God alone, who establishes faith - breaks open the nature of the sinner as one curved in on himself; only he can loosen the fist that is clenched so tightly, so that my existence on behalf of others becomes natural once again and takes place with 'passion and love.' The imagery of receiving and passing on to others brings us to the foundational motif of Luther's understanding of God, that of categorical gift: through the Son, God in the Spirit gives himself to us as Father, in every sense of the word, so that we do not hoard and keep for ourselves what is given to us, which is what we do as sinners, but instead pass it on to others" (p. 283, Oswald Bayer, Martin Luther's Theology: A Contemporary Interpretation)

"if we recognize the great and precious things which are given us, as Paul says [Rom. 5:5], our hearts will be filled by the Holy Spirit with the love that makes us free, joyful, almighty workers and conquerors over all tribulations, servants of our neighbours, yet lords of all." (pp.304f, Martin Luther, The Freedom of the Christian)

"It is impossible to love God until the forgiveness of sins is first grasped by faith. For the heart that truly believes that God is angry is unable to love God until he is shown to be reconciled. For as long as he terrifies us and appears to be casting us into eternal death, human nature cannot bring itself to love such a wrathful, judging, and punishing God. It is easy for complacent minds to fabricate some foolish dreams about love [...] But in its agony and its battles the conscience experiences the emptiness of such philosophical speculations." (p. 126, Apology of the Augsburg Confession)

When Christian friends meet

My Christian friendships should look like this. I should

pour out my sadness to the one who is close to me and ask him for comfort. What that person then gives and promises to me as regards comfort is to be affirmed by God in heaven as well. On the other hand, I should also comfort and and say to another person: dear friend, dear brother, why do you not let go of your affliction? It is certainly not God's will that you experience a single bit of suffering. god allowed his Son to die for you, so that you need not mourn but that you can be joyful. Therefore be of good courage and be comforted; you will do a service and that which is pleasing to God, and you ought to kneel down with one another and pray the Lord's Prayer, which is certainly heard in heaven, for God promises: "I am in your midst" [Matt. 18:20]. He does not say: "I will see it. I will hear it," or "I will come to you," but "I am there already."

(Martin Luther, Matt 18-24 interpreted in sermons; 1537-40, cited in pp. 277f, Oswald Bayer, Martin Luther's Theology: A Contemporary Interpretation).

I.e. Christian friendship should involve:

  • Openness in discussing sins, worries and sadnesses;
  • Application of the Gospel to comfort, encourage, and bring joy;
  • Corporate prayer.

I have friendships with Christians where I'm pretty bad on one or all of those. But Luther is not listing requirements for gritty and serious Christians to put their backs into their Christian growth. Instead, it is a wonderful encouragement that Christ stands behind our words of consolation guaranteeing their truth, and that he stands with us when we pray so that we can have confidence of an answer.

Christ, our peace

"But now in Christ Jesus you who once were far off have been brought near by the blood of Christ. For he himself is our peace" (Eph 2:13f)

We are hopefully used to the idea that we cannot find our righteousness in ourselves, but have to find it in Christ. We know that this means among other things that:

  • We are (now) perfectly righteous in God's eyes, no matter what we think or feel about ourselves;
  • Sin remains in our life, but we are progressively being made righteous by the Holy Spirit's application of Christ's righteous resurrection life;
  • As Christ is the only righteous one, he is our model for what righteous living looks like. That is what is helpful about the WWJD slogan. Jesus, and his cruciform life, is the definition of righteousness.

But what is true of righteousness is also true of peace (wisdom, etc).

  • We have peace with God and his creation, even if we feel that God is at war with us and the world is all against is. We may rarely feel very settled and tranquil in ourselves, but we are (now) perfectly at peace in God's eyes;
  • There remains hostility towards others and towards us, and much of life is chaotic rather than tranquil, but the Holy Spirit is giving us the peace of God, and that is slowly becoming integral to us, even if we're not aware of it;
  • But part of the reason we may not be aware of the peace we already have is because we have a false idea of what peace looks like. Perhaps we think it looks like stillness, or a deserted beach with the sun coming up over the horizon. But if Christ is the one who has, and is, perfect peace, we should look to him to know what peace looks like. He is at war with the devil, mourning over evil, and even when they are defeated will be as active and creative as he has always been.

Questioning people

Listening to: Red Mountain Church: The Gadsby Project

Questioning Evangelism by Randy Newman argues that it is much better to answer a question with another question when doing evangelism. I could do with reading the book, rather than just skimming it, but it strikes me that questions are important not just because they are an effective evangelistic technique, but because of what they communicate in themselves. As such, they are important not just in evangelism but in all our relationships.

1. Questions communicate that we care - people who care ask questions. A self-obsessed person will talk about what themselves, what they think, and what they've done, till the cows come home. They don't want to listen to you, or understand you because that's irrelevant to their relationship with you. In contrast, someone who really cares about you will ask probing questions to find out how you really are (although not in an insensitive way).

2. Questions communicate that the person we're speaking to is not the judge - a danger of suggesting that we always ask questions is that we assume that to be loving is just to listen. But questions also ask people to give an account. They demand an answer. We are always prone to think that we understand the world perfectly, but as soon as we are forced to explain it to others we realise the shortcomings of our understanding. We realise that we are not in a position to judge - the questions are being asked of us. The questioner becomes God to us, and it is now us in the dock, and not God. This is a challenge to the sinner in us who judges themselves to be righteous apart from Christ, and release for the broken saint involved in self-condemnation.

Sunday, December 27, 2009

Top ten books I read in 2009

I like making lists to review my year. Last year I didn't read that much so didn't do a top ten list (2007's list is here) but this year I've read more books in a year than I ever have. I realise I've read quite a lot looking down this post, but this has been an exceptional year for me. I'm unlikely to have so much time for reading again for a long, long time. Besides, a lot of these books are really very short. I'm painfully aware too that reading doesn't produce either holiness or wisdom ex opere operato. Thankfully though many of them do remind me that I have both in Christ, by faith and not by reading!

One theme of my reading this year has been CS Lewis (7 books). You may have missed that on this blog, as I haven't blogged that much about it. A group of people from our church have had a reading/discussion group going through some of his books this year and that was the impetus. I am left with enormous respect for the brain he had. His learning, his skill in communication, his mastery of so many disciplines (fiction, philosophy, theology etc), and his insight into how humans tick is beyond belief. Nevertheless, I have a few concerns with his approach. I was continually struck by two things. Firstly, how rarely he starts with Jesus Christ, and secondly the almost total absence of repentance as fundamental to knowledge of God. But a couple of his books make it into my top ten despite those fairly fundamental problems.

The second theme is probably less of a surprise. Nine of the books are Lutheran. My respect for the distinctives of Lutheranism has only grown this year. I ought to write a post to give an account for why I think that everyone should listen to the Lutherans, and take them as seriously as they take the human situation. However, I have seen that their strength in getting to the heart, and seeing through to what is fundamental, also means that they often become disconnected from the Bible.... but this does need a post to explain.

Before I get into the top ten books I've read this year, I have to mention 2 books which I've only dipped into but which still come with the highest recommendation from me. First, Leiths Vegetable Bible. A dirty little secret is that I became a (flexible) vegetarian this year. This recipe book has made me actually enjoy that transition. While I went over to the dark side on moral grounds, I think this book has made me willing to stay here just on taste grounds too. Hundreds of excellent, honest but not boring, recipes. Even if you're not a veggie you should buy this book. Second, is The Books of the Bible which I've mentioned before. It has made reading lengthy sections of the bible so much more enjoyable.

But without further ado, here are the top ten books I read in 2009:

  1. Martin Luther's Theology: A Contemporary Interpretation (by Oswald Bayer). This book took me almost a year to read. It was so rich I felt I needed a few weeks to absorb each chapter. A truly incredible book, I can't recommend it highly enough. One of Germany's premier Lutheran theologians having a conversation with Luther in order to understand what he has to say to us today.
  2. Loci Communes (1st edition, 1521, by Philip Melanchthon). Luther praised this book more than any other, saying it deserved "not only to be immortalized but even canonized". Written by his sidekick Philip Melanchthon when aged just 23, only 4 years after Luther nailed his 95 theses to the door of the Castle Church. It is a theology shaped around the distinction between 'Law and Gospel'. Short, but packing a punch. It should be much more widely read.
  3. On Being a Theologian of the Cross: Reflections on Luther's Heidelberg Disputation, 1518 (by Gerhard O. Forde). Brings out the powerful, world shaking nature of Luther's message to his fellow Augustinians at Heidelberg early in the Reformation. Will throw you upside down, as you seek to re-evaluate whether you really see things as they are.
  4. Life Father Like Son: The Trinity Imaged in Our Humanity (by Tom Smail). A good brief introduction to the contemporary movement to putting the Trinity back at the heart of our theology. It then asks what implications thinking Trinitarianly would have to our understanding of ourselves as human. Brilliantly provocative.
  5. Out of the Storm: Questions and consolations from the book of Job (by Christopher Ash). A brief exposition of the book of Job. I've read Job many a time, but I don't think I really understood it as good news for sufferers until I read this book. It really opened up God's final speech to me at a time in this year when I really needed to hear it.
  6. When Christ Comes and Comes Again (by TF Torrance). A collection of early evangelistic sermons by Tom Torrance. Beautiful, comforting and thought-provoking. You couldn't assume this level of biblical and theological literacy today (you probably couldn't then!), but he shows us how we can imaginatively present the gospel from a variety of different angles.
  7. Till We Have Faces: A Myth Retold (by CS Lewis). A novel! I have only read two this year, and this is the only one that wasn't explicitly Christian one. I'd read it once before, but reading it again while discussing it with others showed just how deep it goes. I have literally spent hours talking about this book with others in our group that have read it, and I still don't think I've reached the bottom of it.
  8. Miracles (by CS Lewis). Packed full of arguments to take seriously. I particularly liked his argument against David Hume. And his idea of the 'fittingness' of the biblical miracles - and particularly the 'Grand Miracle' of the Resurrection.
  9. Luther: Man Between God and the Devil (by Heiko A. Oberman). Brings out quite how Luther's view of his life and the preaching of the Gospel as apocalyptic struggle against the devil shaped his theology in ways as Moderns we have trouble comprehending.
  10. The Soul of Prayer (by PT Forsyth). This is on the list almost entirely for the final chapter, 'the Insistancy of Prayer', and its explanation of how prayer should include wrestling - that is fighting - against God's will being done (Ooo that's provocatively put, but that's what he says and I think he's right).

For what it's worth here is the complete list of books I read in 2009:

My films of 2009

One of the wonders of living in York is the City Screen cinema by the river. I love this cinema, and saw a good few films there this year.

Its review of the year time, but sadly 2009 hasn't been a vintage year for filmgoers. Nevertheless, for your consideration, here are my top ten films I watched at the cinema in 2009:

1. Slumdog Millionaire
2. The Wrestler
3= Doubt
3= Away We Go
5. Up (3D)
6= Revolutionary Road
6= Gran Torino
8. Star Trek
9. Das Weisse Band - The White Ribbon
10. Moon

With an honourable mention to Synecdoche, New York.

There have been some great films that I've missed. But so you know the sample I'm basing this on. Here are all the films I saw at the cinema this year:

(500) Days of Summer
A serious man
Away We Go
Breakfast at Tiffany's (rerelease)
Che - Part One
Das Weisse Band - The White Ribbon
District 9
Doubt
Frost/Nixon
Gomorra / Gomorrah
Gran Torino
Harry Potter And The Half Blood Prince
Milk
Moon
Revolutionary Road
Slumdog Millionaire
Star Trek
State Of Play
Synecdoche, New York
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
The Wrestler
Up (3D)
Vicky Cristina Barcelona
Where the Wild Things Are

Christ's mediation: pop quiz

Some questions on my mind this evening.

  1. Do you think that most people think of Christ as the mediator between us and the Father, and the Holy Spirit as the mediator between us and Christ?
  2. What impact would it have on our thinking if we remembered more often that Christ was the mediator of the Spirit?
  3. What do we mean by Christ's mediation anyway? Is his cleansing us so we can enter the prescence of God the end of it? If not, what else does it involve?

Sunday, December 20, 2009

The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe film discussion questions

[These are my notes for leading a discussion on the film The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe. Feedback welcome. Sorry for the extent that they're decipherable only to me. I haven't had time to edit them for public consumption]

From dedication of the book: "My Dear Lucy, I wrote this story for you, but when I began it I had not realized that girls grow quicker than books. As a result you are already too old for fairy tales, and by the time it is printed and bound you will be older still. But some day you will be old enough to start reading fairy tales again. You can then take it down from some upper shelf, dust it, and tell me what you think of it. I shall probably be too deaf to hear, and too old to understand a word you say, but I shall still be your affectionate Godfather, C. S. Lewis."

We're a bunch of adults who have decided to watch a 'kids' film, involving talking animals and a secret other world. Is Lewis right that you grow out of fairy tales, and then grow into them again? Why?

  • Escapism?
  • Sentimental longing to relive childhood?
  • Do they enable us to understand the real world in a way which realist fiction or abstract argument can't?

** WATCH FILM **

Any parts of the film you particularly enjoyed, or thought didn't work?

  • Tilda Swinton
  • Colours of Narnia, particularly when Lucy and Edmund first enter. Snow.
  • Soundtrack
  • London scenes. Character development. Parallels of war in England and Narnia.
  • Why Aslan had to die.

Once all four children enter Narnia, it is largely the actions of Edmund that drive the story. What motivates Edmund to join the White Witch?

  • Absence of his father (running back to save his photo in air raid; "Wouldn’t have to go away if Dad was here" at station). Does this excuse him?
  • Book: new school is blamed
  • Estrangement from siblings, in particular from Peter.
  • Problem with authority: Doesn't like authority of Peter and Susan over him ("You think you’re Dad, but you’re not" when Peter tells him off for mocking Lucy’s belief in Narnia; "Yes Mum" his response to Susan when she suggests they go to bed)
  • Desire to be king (Doesn't like it when he thinks Witch will make Peter king as well; sits on Witch's throne: “like it?” she asks - “yes” Edmund replies).
  • Half-believes she is right (thinks that faun may be lying about her, that and that it is Tumnus who is a criminal).
  • Enjoys the Turkish Delight and wants more (book: "this was enchanted Turkish Delight and... anyone who had tasted it would want more and more of it, and would even, if tthey were allowed go on eating it till they killed themselves")
  • In the end he doesn't get anything that he betrayed his family for. No throne, no food.

If Edmund is flawed, is Peter any better?

  • self-righteous
  • quick to round on Edmund at any opportunity (gets angry at air raid about photo Edmund goes back for, gets angry about cricket ball, gives Edmund girls coat out of wardrobe, "I know")
  • He likes authority too. Not happy to ask Professor for help, "we can handle it".
  • Confession to Aslan: "It’s my fault really. I was too hard on him"

Aslan sacrifices himself to save Edmund. Self sacrifice is a common theme in films. The centaur and rhino sacrifice themselves in this film to save Peter. Is Aslan's self-sacrifice different in any way?

  • Planned? No, it is often planned in stories.
  • He is in control though in a way that you don't often get. He has to satisfy the Deep Magic. That is the problem, not the Witch.
  • Only he could "turn death backwards", be resurrected, break the Deep Magic's hold over Narnia, because he is the only innocent one - and god?
  • Why does he have to die? What does it achieve?

[OPTIONAL QUESTION: Tilda Swinton says about the film: "It's about finding self-sufficiency in difficult circumstances and finding the capacity to dig deep, survive and prevail."

Is her interpretation of the film correct?

  • Yes, digging deep and courage important themes.
  • No, self-sufficiency is far from promoted (Children need each other and other animals, need Aslan - “Only Aslan can help your brother now” Mr Beaver on Edmund going to the witch’s palace, Aslan's desire not to be alone as he goes to his death, contrast the Witch who needs no-one and doesn't want to - even says to dwarf who asks if she will kill him: "not yet"). We are created to need others, and particularly to need Christ (and his death). Self-sufficiency is not an ideal to aspire to.

]

Running theme in film is who is telling the truth. Lucy and Edmund contradict on existence of Narnia. Lucy: "She calls herself the Queen of Narnia thought she has no right to be queen at all". Faun has book on his shelf "Is Man a Myth?" Edmund on Mr Beaver: "how do we know we can trust him?" What does film say about how we can know what is true?

  • Edmund at least really knows in deep-down that witch is evil. He lies to himself.
  • The Professor's advice to Peter and Susan on whether to believe Lucy: "If she’s not mad and if she’s not lying then she must be telling the truth"
  • Ultimately, belief in truth is presented in a very personal way.
  • Some are ignorant of truth so doubt it ("Is man a myth?").
  • Truth is inescapable reality whatever stance people take.

Sunday, December 13, 2009

The Deep Magic of Narnia

A lot of Evangelicals have a problem with the atonement theory they see displayed in the Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe by CS Lewis. They are uncomfortable that it seems to suggest that:

  1. the devil had something he could demand of Christ
  2. Christ's death was not to satisfy God's wrath, but to satisfy the devil

But I think that CS Lewis does not say anything wrong, but he leaves the door open to problems coming in.

The Witch appeals to the "Deep Magic" for her claim on Edmund's life. She also says "the Law" demands it. For Lewis the "Deep Magic" seems to be another name for "the Law" in Christian theology. It is built into the fabric of the universe, but it is not an independent god which both the Witch and the Aslan have to obey. It was put in place by the "Emperor-Beyond-the-Sea" (God the Father), and it belongs to him. The Stone Table represents this Deep Magic. It has the words of it written on it, just as the words of the Law were written on stone tablets delivered to Moses.

Any claim that the Witch has against Edmund is derived from the Deep Magic, and more fundamentally from the Emperor who gave it. Aslan says that the offence committed by Edmund was not an offence against the Witch, and so she does not have a natural right to claim Edmund's life. As the Beaver observes, she is "the Emperor's hangman" and it is he who gives the Witch her right. It is ultimately not either the Witch or the Deep Magic which has a claim on Edmund's life, it is the Emperor. The devil in Christian theology is in the same position. He is called Satan ('the accuser') because his power is only in bringing the Law of God to bear on people's lives. As the early chapter's of Job show clearly, he is God's servant and not a truly rival power.

Aslan would not go against the law given by the Emperor who is his father, but his authority does not derive from it like the Witch's does. He subjects himself to the Deep Magic voluntarily, even though it clearly only applies to traitors. In this sense Aslan and the Witch are not two equals under the Deep Magic. Aslan lowers himself to the Witch's level, but that is not where he belongs. It is only as Aslan identifies with Edmund that the Witch can demand anything from him. The parallels with Christ are obvious.

When Christ died on the cross in the place of us, the Law was nailed to the cross (Col 2:14). The Law has been torn down and we no longer will we be put to death by it. Similarly, the Stone Table cracks when Aslan is brought back from the dead.

That's all good stuff, but I think Lewis leaves the door open for problems in several ways:

  • God is distant. It is only in a very indirect way that Aslan seems to be experiencing the Emperor's wrath. Because of this it appears that our biggest problem is not God's anger at our sin, but the devil out to hurt us.
  • Because of this distance of God, it seems almost like the devil is acting as a free agent, albeit under authority of the Law. There is no sense that God has sovereignly arranged for the attack of the devil. Except perhaps in Aslan locating his army's camp at the Stone Table from the beginning.
  • Because Aslan is a lion and Edmund a human, it is not clear that Aslan is only subject to the "Deep Magic"/Law by his identification with Edmund. It could be misunderstood that he is under the "Deep Magic" in exactly the same way the Witch is.
  • The Emperor-Beyond-the-Sea does not seem to be the loving Heavenly Father of the Christian Faith. He is not only distant, but possibly even evil. He does not act for good (it is never clear that he sent his son, Aslan). He is only ever depicted as standing behind the cold justice executed by the evil Witch. The Deeper Magic which means Aslan is raised from the dead is only implicitly the Deeper Magic of the Emperor. In contrast the New Testament is crystal clear that it was God the Father raised Jesus by the power of the Holy Spirit. The whole Trinity is acting in the salvation of sinners. If it is was not then, like here, God the Father is thought to be the angry God, and Jesus the loving God subjected to divine child abuse.

Those are my thoughts. Do you have any others?

These are the only relevant passages in the book:

"You have a traitor there, Aslan," said the Witch...

"Well," said Aslan. "His offence was not against you."

"Have you forgotten the Deep Magic?" asked the Witch.

"Let us say I have forgotten it," answered Aslan gravely. "Tell us of this Deep Magic."

"Tell you?" said the Witch, her voice growing suddenly shriller. "Tell you what is written on that very Table of Stone which stands beside us? Tell you what is written in letters deep as a spear is long on the fire-stones on the Secret Hill? Tell you what is engraved on the scepter of the Emperor-Beyond-the-Sea? You at least know the magic which the Emperor put into Narnia at the very beginning. You know that every traitor belongs to me as my lawful prey and that for every treachery I have a right to kill."

"Oh," said Mr. Beaver. "So that's how you came to imagine yourself a queen - because you were the Emperor's hangman. I see."

"Peace, Beaver," said Aslan, with a very low growl.

"And so," continued the Witch, "that human creature is mine. His life is forfeit to me. His blood is my property."

"Come and take it then," said the Bull with the man's head in a great bellowing voice.

"Fool," said the Witch with a savage smile that was almost a snarl, "Do you really think your master can rob me of my rights by mere force? He knows the Deep Magic better than that. He know that unless I have blood as the Law says all Narnia will be overturned and perish in fire and water."

"It is very true," said Aslan, "I do not deny it."

"Oh, Aslan!" whispered Susan in the Lion's ear, "can't we – I mean, you won't, will you? Can't we do something about the Deep Magic? Isn't there something you can work against it?"

"Work against the Emperor's magic?" said Aslan, turning to her with something like a frown on his face. And nobody ever made that suggestion to him again.

(pp. 128-129)

"though the witch knew the Deep Magic, there is a magic deeper still which she did not know. Her knowledge only goes back to the dawn of time. But if she could have looked a little further back, into the stillness and the darkness before Time dawned, she would have read there a different incantation. She would have known that when a willing victim who had committed no treachery was killed in a traitor's stead, the Table would crack and Death itself would start working backwards."

(p. 148)

How can we be sure of God's love?

A lot of people are very 'down on themselves'. They clearly need words of affirmation and assurance that God really does love them. But that doesn't mean that we stop telling people they are sinners. Only through judgment will we experience God's love. And, as PT Forsyth put into words, only when a person has seen the magnitude of God's holy anger against us will that love be real and trustworthy to the person who can never see how he could be loved.

If God's love were not essentially holy love, in course of time mankind would cease to respect it, and consequently to trust it. We need not a fond love, but a love we can trust, and for ever [...]

the sinner could not trust a love that could not justify itself as holy. It is the holiness in God's love, I urge, that alone enables us to trust Him. Without that we should only love Him, and the love would fluctuate. For we could not be perfectly sure that His would not. It is the holiness in God's love that is the eternal, stable, unchangeable element in it - the holiness secured for history and its destiny in the Cross. It is only the unchangeable that we could trust; and there alone we find it. If we only loved the love of God, we should have no stable, eternal, universal religion. But we love the holy love He established in Christ, and therefore we are safe with an everlasting salvation.

(pp. 113-137, The Work of Christ)

Ultimately, the person who is down on himself can only be sure "because the father not only says but pays" (p.111, ibid)

Tuesday, December 01, 2009

Living witnesses to the Gospel

What kind of life commends the Gospel?

My stock answer would be something like Paul in 2 Corinthians 6:6: "by purity, knowledge, patience, kindness, the Holy Spirit, genuine love". In short, by 'the good life'.

But that isn't the whole picture. As Paul himself says in that passage it is also by "great endurance, in afflictions, hardships, calamities, beatings, imprisonments, riots, labours, sleepless nights, hunger" (vv. 4-5). We commend the Gospel by suffering! I don't often hear that or say that, and I think that is because I'm a closet theologian of glory.

Sinning less is how I see us commending the Gospel. But that isn't a rounded New Testament picture. In many ways it is by appearing foolish, weak and bad in the world's eyes that the Gospel is most proclaimed. Not by seeming to be wise, strong and holy.

Although this does not flow seamlessly, PT Forsyth has his own problem with the idea that it is by sinning less that we commend the Gospel:

The difference between the Christian and the world is not that the world sins and the Christian does not. It suits the world to think that it is; because it offers a handy whip to scourge the Church’s consistency while resenting its demands. But such a distinction is no part of the Church's claim. Nor does it mark off the Christian’s worldly years from his life in Christ. A difference of that kind is merely in quantity — all the sin on the one side, none of it on the other. But the real difference (I must say often) is not in quantity; it is in quality. It is not in the number of sins, but in the attitude toward sin and the things called sin. It is in the man's sympathies, his affinities; it is in his conscience, his verdict on sin, his treatment of it — whether the world's or his own.

(p.109, God the Holy Father)

So both in respect of our physical lives, and our moral lives, it is also being put to death (in the physical body by others, and the moral 'body' by ourselves) that we point people to Christ.

As Paul said "We are...always carrying in the body the death of Jesus, so that the life of Jesus may also be manifested in our bodies" (4:8-10).

Thursday, November 26, 2009

The 360 degree turnaround

Listening to: Mozart: Piano Trios

1. The turn away from people to Christ

"Whoever comes to me and does not hate father and mother, wife and children, brothers and sisters, yes and even life itself, cannot be my disciple" (Luke 14:26) [...]

Jesus' call itself already breaks the ties with the naturally given surroundings in which a person lives. It is not the disciple who breaks them; Christ himself broke them as soon as he called. Christ has untied the person's immediate connections with the world and bound the person immediately to himself.

2. Christ the mediator between person and person

It s true, there is something which comes between persons called by Christ and the given circumstances of their natural lives [...] it is Christ himself. In becoming human, he put himself between me and the given circumstances of the world. I cannot go back. He is in the middle. He has deprived those whom he has called of every immediate connection to those given realities. He wants to be the medium; everything should happen only through him. He stands not only between me and God, he also stands between me and the world, between me and other people and things. He is the mediator, not only between God and human persons, but also between person and person, and between person and reality.

3. The turn back to the world through Christ

There is no genuine love for the world except the love with which God has loved the world in Jesus Christ. "Do not love the world" (1 John 2:15) [for the sake of self, apart from gratitude to God]. But "God so loved the world that he gave his only Son, so that everyone who believes in him may not perish but may have eternal life" (John 3:16) [for the sake of God (and others), with gratitude to God].

4. Abraham as the role model

Abraham had to learn that the promise did not depend on Isaac, but only on God [...] He brings his son to be sacrificed [...] for the sake of the mediator. At the same time, everything that he had given up is restored to him. Abraham receives his son back. God shows him a better sacrifice which is to take Isaac's place. It is a turnaround of 360 degrees. Abraham received Isaac back, but in a different way than before. He has him through the mediator and for the sake of the mediator. As the one who was prepared to hear and obey God's command literally, he is permitted to have Isaac as though he did not have him; he is permitted to have him through Jesus Christ. No one else knows about it. Abraham comes down from the mountain with Isaac, just as he went up, but everything has changed. Christ had come between the father and the son. Abraham had left everything and followed Christ, and while he was following Christ, he was permitted to go back to live in the same world he had lived in before. Externally everything remained the same. But the old has passed away; see, everything has become new.

(pp.92-98, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Discipleship)

I thought this idea of Christ as mediator between people to be really amazing. Not 100% sure that it is the best way to understand things, but its very powerful.

BTW it seems that Bonhoeffer nicked the idea of the 360 degree circle from Barth:

When such a church embarks upon moral exhortation, its exhortation can be naught else but a criticism of all human behavior, a criticism which moves through every one of the 360 degrees of the circle of our ambiguous life

(p. 428, The Epistle to the Romans)

Wednesday, November 25, 2009

Following

Listening to: Bob Dylan: Highway 61 Revisited

"And you were dead in the trespasses and sins in which you once walked, following the course of this world, following the prince of the power of the air, the spirit that is now at work in the sons of disobedience — among whom we all once lived in the passions of our flesh, carrying out the desires of the body and the mind, and were by nature children of wrath, like the rest of mankind." (Eph 2:1-3)

Without Christ we:

  • follow the world; and
  • follow the devil.

As we discussed in Christianity Explored tonight, that is a fairly offensive thing to say to people. But it's not only offensive, its makes no sense to us. How can they we be following the devil if we don't even believe in him? And, it isn't true to say that I mindlessly follow everyone else when I make up my own mind about things?

We follow the world and the devil in two ways:

Firstly, we do the same thing as both of them. We live for ourselves. We carry out whatever our body and mind desire to do. That is the only rule we accept, the rule of ourselves. In our assertion of self-determination, we display our unity with the world and the devil.

But secondly, we not only do the same thing as them, we do the same thing as them because of them. We learnt sin from the devil in the Garden, and we inherited sin from the world. Sin is not original to us.

"But... we are [God's] workmanship, created in Christ Jesus for good works, which God prepared beforehand, that we should walk in them." (Eph 2:4-10)

We now follow Christ. This means that we walk in good works, not in trespasses and sins. We follow Christ in a mirror image of the way in which we used to follow the world and the devil.

Firstly, we do the same thing as him. We walk in love, "as Christ loved us and gave himself up for us" (5:1). Previously we lived to satisfy our own desires. Now we seek to please God, and satisfy our neighbour, just as Christ did.

Secondly, we do the same thing as him, because of him. We are God's "workmanship...in Christ Jesus". We were dead and unable to save ourselves, but we were made alive as a new person because of God's action in Christ.

Tuesday, November 24, 2009

The missing commandment (Part 2)

A while back I posted what I thought was one of my more controversial posts on the absence of the commandment to "love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind and with all your strength" in the letters of the NT. Surprisingly it got no comments!

I've continued to muse on this, and asked a number of people about it. As I've continued to read the NT with this in the back of my mind I continue to be struck that while we are often commanded to love our neighbour, we never seem to be commanded to love God. Today I came across 1 John 3:23. Like Jesus in Mark 13 he seems to group together two commandments in one "commandment" (singular).

this is his commandment, that we believe in the name of his Son Jesus Christ [vertical] and love one another [horizontal]

This seems a good summary of the NT ethic. Faith towards God, and love towards our neighbour. God's love for us is always the primary thing in our relationship towards him. Our love towards others is always the primary thing in our relationship towards them. It is the two-kinds of righteousness thing again. In one dimension we are passive, in the other active.

Serious challenge though: find me a commandment to love God, or Christ, post-Cross.

It is implicit in some places, and it is assumed that we will love God if we are Christians, but I am yet to find a place where we are commanded to do so. My bible knowledge is pretty thin though.

Sunday, November 22, 2009

The doctrine of the Trinity at the end!

Glen Scrivener recently posted a great post on why when doing theology we should start with the Trinity, not with any general teaching about God. I must admit I've been largely sold on this over the last few years, and found that while people may not practice it, nobody ever seems to disagree with the basic idea that the Trinity is where we should begin.... that was up until very recently, when I came across a confident broadside against it in the most surprising place.

Oswald Bayer notes that starting with the doctrine of the Trinity "is the pattern that is followed by an ever-increasing number of dogmatic theologians throughout the world" (p. 335, Martin Luther's Theology; A Contemporary Interpretation). But this is not something which he approves of. He describes as "one of the grandiose blunders of the more recent history of both philosophy and theology" (p. 339)!

He believes that the doctrine of the Trinity is "properly located neither as a bland addition nor in the middle as just one dogmatic theme among many, but correctly in the middle and correctly at the end" (p.334). The reason for this is that "the triune nature of God can only be comprehended only as an unfolding of the pure gospel" (p.335 - reminds me of the title to Tim Chester's Theology Network, "The good news of the Trinity"). He sees a number of problems if we start the doctrine of the Trinity. E.g:

  • "if one proceeds in such a way, one will come dangerously close to... a brand of speculation that ignores time and the situation" (p.335)
  • it "ignores or minimizes the problem of unfaith" (p.335)
  • it has no place for the sufferer's experience of God as his seeming enemy, or take seriously the "reality of evil".

The basic problem though is that those who want to see the Trinity placed at the beginning see what is first in theology as the most fundamental. They are always concerned that we fit what follows to what comes before, and that much theology has fit the Trinity into the procrustean bed of a Unitarian view of God. However, a Lutheran who believes in law and then Gospel believes that what follows is the more fundamental. The Lutheran believes the good news is a surprise.

Bayer believes that we should begin with "'general' teaching about God", but not because he thinks that the Trinity is subsidiary. He has no love for the God who is not Trinity. "The God who comes to us apart from being the triune God, who is purely and completely love, 'looks on,' and has for us the grimace of the devil" (p.338). General teaching about God, even a monotheistic God, is something that belongs to the non-Christian and will be left behind in eternity.

The distinction between what is involved in the teaching about the Trinity and "general" teaching about God [...] is encountered in faith and in the hope that this distinction will be removed, along with the distinction between law and gospel, in the eschaton. The the triune God - he alone - will be all in all (1 Cor. 15:28). Then we also will no longer be assailed by the oppressive, incomprehensible hiddenness that weighs us down even to the point of our death. It will be consumed by open love which itself cannot be comprehended, which will free us from its power and which comes to us conclusively already now in the gospel.

The end that we believe in and hope for, because of the love that has come to us and has been promised to us - the consummation of the work of creation by the triune God - is misinterpreted with regard to its true character when it is claimed that it exists as a timeless principle of knowledge and existence. Its universality cannot be demonstrated in the abstract, not even with theoretical means linked to the Trinity; one cannot apply its truths to every circumstance one can postulate and treat it as an a priori. (pp.339-340)

Glen and others (hi Glen!) are driven by their conviction that we should start all our thinking about God with the Trinity to argue that the Trinity was fully understood by the OT saints. Hence the regular 'Angel of the Lord' etc debates. But while a Lutheran would admit that the Trinity was seen in the OT, just as the Gospel was preached in the OT, they would also want to retain a distinction because:

just as the chief teaching of the New Testament is really the proclamation of grace and peace through the forgiveness of sins in Christ, so the chief teaching of the Old Testament is really the teaching of the laws, the showing up of sin, and the demanding of good. (Martin Luther, Preface to the Old Testament)

For Oswald Bayer there is always a shape and a story to the Bible and to our lives. He sees those who start with the doctrine of the Trinity as flattening the contours of this story, and so missing out on the depths and the heights of the Bible's message about God.

... I must confess its shook up all my thinking. Who knows how it will all settle again.

[A few asides: (a) it is interesting to note that Karl Barth was led the way in both making the doctrine of the Trinity at the beginning of theology, and in arguing that we should deal with Gospel then law. (b) It is also interesting how those who start with the Trinity always seem (IMHO) to be struggling to not say that creation and redemption were necessary for God. (c) In The Cruciality of the Cross PT Forsyth argues that the Atonement (i.e. the Gospel) drives us to the Incarnation, not the other way round. But it could be equally said of the doctrine of the Trinity. The Gospel drives us to the Trinity from our point of view, even if the Trinity is what leads to the Gospel from God's point of view.]

How to seek to have our relationship needs met

Listening to: Sovereign Grace Music: Worship God

In The Four Loves, CS Lewis begins by making a helpful distinction between what he calls "need-love" and "gift-love". He explains that:

The typical example of Gift-love would be that love which moves a man to work and plan and save for the future well-being of his family which he will die without sharing or seeing; of the second, that which sends a lonely or frightened child to its mother's arms

He successfully shows that there is nothing wrong with "need-love". We all have emotional, physical and spiritual needs that we need meeting. So how should we go about having those needs met in our relationships?

Firstly, I think it is helpful to take the point that Ed Welch makes in When People Are Big and God Is Small. We need to examine our "needs" and consider whether they are actually sinful wants. We shouldn't just assume that because we feel the need for something that it should be met.

But given that we have done that, how should we pursue the meeting of those good relationship needs we have? Perhaps we should just look for them from God. Shouldn't he meet our needs for love, recognition, friendship etc? This seems to have some weight because to seek the meeting of our needs elsewhere looks (a) like idolatry; and (b) hopeless, because of people's limited ability to "deliver".

But if we should look only to God, is there still a place for desiring marriage, friendship etc? We know that these things are good things, but maybe only in moderation. You shouldn't love your wife too much, or be too dependent on anyone. Perhaps we just have to keep things in proportion, and ensure we always are more dependant on God. Perhaps Tim Keller definition of an idol is helpful:

It is anything more important to you than God, anything that absorbs your heart and imagination more than God (my italics)

But the first commandment, is not "You are to have no other gods more important than me", but "You are to have no other gods". God is one.

Martin Luther is right when he says that "it is God alone ... from whom we receive anything good". But, no sooner has he seemingly backed some super-spiritual monasticism than he says that "much that is good comes to us from human beings". He believes both these things because:

we receive our blessings not from [human beings], but from God through them. Creatures are only the hands, channels, and means through which God bestows all blessings. For example, he gives to the mother breasts and milk for her infant or gives grain and all sorts of fruits from the earth for sustenance - things that no creature could produce by itself.

In fact, to reject our needs being met through other human beings is to "through arrogance...seek other methods and ways than those God has commanded". In seeking to have our needs met only in God, we could be in danger of actually spurning his gifts and before we know it we would "not be receiving [our needs met] from God, but seeking them from ourselves".

But returning to the practicalities of how we should seek to have our needs met in relationships, this means that if our emotional needs (as well as 'spiritual' ones) are met by God, then we should receive them in the same way as we always receive gifts from God: passively.

But as when we receive our righteousness passively, that does not mean that we are not active. But we are active not in earning or obtaining it for ourself. The activity comes from the faith that we already have everything in Christ, even if we do not see or experience it yet.

On reflection I think that it is in those relationships where I have set out to serve and give, and continued to have to do so, have been the ones that have given the most to me and helped me through the most. But when I think about relationships that I have sought for what they give to me the fruit goes rotten in my hands. They just don't deliver.

Perhaps then we should seek only gift-love in our relationships, but then we will receive need-love anyway. The problems with idolatry come when we are actively looking for our needs met in relationships with other people, instead of passively expecting to receive through them by God's grace. Only in self-giving love are we free (as Jesus was when he gave himself for his people) and only in that way do we actually receive the love and glory we long for (as Jesus received from his Father who glorified him because of his obedience).

In Luther's book The Freedom of the Christian he sets out two famous statements:

  1. "A Christian is a perfectly free lord of all, subject to none"
  2. "A Christian is a perfectly dutiful servant of all, subject to all"

He is basically saying there are two dimensions to life and if we misunderstand this then everything goes astray (The two kinds of righteousness). By faith in Christ we share in his lordship of Creation. Everything serves us and works for our good (Rom 8:28 etc), and this happens freely apart from any effort or works of our own. But at the same time we are called and empowered by this grace to serve everyone we meet. We don't do things to receive justification before God, or good things from people, but we serve everyone without any hope of gain because we already have everything in Christ who gives through his creatures.

By the way, I haven't thought about all this a great deal until very recently, so please feel free to poke holes. It would be helpful if you do. Hopefully, its not totally obscure.

Thursday, November 19, 2009

Thoughts on how to do evangelism

Listening to: Mozart: Cosi fan tutte (interspersed with preview of Thea Gilmore's live album on Amazon!)

[Here are some hasty thoughts on my philosophy on how to 'do' evangelism. Perhaps one day I'll turn it into something proper. As this has quite big implications for my life it is probably more important than almost anything else that turns up on this blog so please do point out anything amiss. Also as a by-the-way, I don't live up to this at all.]


A. HOW PEOPLE BECOME CHRISTIANS

1. Prayer

Because evangelism is God's mission before it is ours, prayer should be the most important activity of evangelism. It is God alone that enables people to see the truth of the Gospel (2 Corinthians 4). The Lord's prayer includes within it the prayer for the coming of the Kingdom of God, and that grows as people become Christians (e.g. Luke 16:16) and its consummation is hastened by every person that is converted (2 Peter 3). Paul commands us to pray for everyone because of God's desire to save all people (1 Timothy 2:1-4).

2. Witness of the spoken word

But of course God uses means and faith comes by hearing the word of Christ (Romans 10:17; cf. 1 John 1:1-3 etc). It is God's word which converts people, because it never comes back without achieving its purpose (Isaiah 55:11). Our imperfect lives, and limited resources are never going to be up to the task of converting people. Even Jesus who lived the perfect life, and had the most impressive show-stopping stunts, 'proclaimed' the good news. The reason the spoken word has priority is that the Gospel is firstly something that happens outside of ourselves. While the Gospel is something that happens to us, and in us, it is firstly something done to and in Christ.

3. Witness of community of love

Jesus also teaches that people will belief in him because of the unity in love of the church community (John 17:23). People looking on the community of people preaching a message of forgiveness and love and will judge the truthfulness of that message on the basis of whether the people doing the preaching are living consistently with what they say. This is why Lesslie Newbigin described the church as the 'hermeneutic of the gospel'. Francis Schaeffer also saw the importance of this for evangelism and termed 'the observable love of true Christians for true Christians' as the 'final apologetic'. The good works of the community is a light for people to see and then believe in Christ (Matthew 5).

4. Witness of individuals living in hope

Christians should seek to do good in all of their lives though to point people to Christ (1 Peter 2:12). Employees should work hard and honestly for their employers to avoid people having contempt for the Gospel (1 Peter 2:15). Spouses by their conduct in marriage may convert their unbelieving partner (1 Peter 3:1; cf. 1 Corinthians 7:16). Sometimes this way of living will be seen in Christians in community by non-Christians but often it will just be individuals that they come into contact with. But they should notice that the individual Christian they know is not living for this world, but has a hope beyond it, and so they will want to know the reason (1 Peter 3:15).

5. Witness of miracles

It is easy to see in the Gospels and Acts how people believed in the Gospel because of the miracles of Jesus and the Apostles (John 10:25, Hebrews 2:3-4 etc). Even today many people do become Christians because of miracles.


B. IMPLICATIONS

1. Pray lots

Self explanatory really. But is prayer a central part of the church's life? And if so, is it prayer for the world or for our own personal needs? Tim Chester comments that in "the UK the traditional midweek church meeting often provided a focus for missionary prayer. But the house groups that have in many cases replaced it can all too easily become insular and self-regarding" (p.219, The Message of Prayer).

2. Call all the witnesses to the stand

Leaving aside the vexed issue of miracles, are in our evangelism are we integrating all the ways in which the gospel is witnessed to? Do our colleagues just see us living as individuals with hope but never as part of a community of love? Do people experience hear the message but never get to see the community of love in action?

I really like the Christianity Explored training graph of amount of Gospel Content v. depth of relationship. I think it was right that both should grow together. But I would make it a 3D graph with spoken word/individual relationships/corporate relationships all increasing together. As we get to know our colleagues more we should speak more about the Gospel, and they should get to know our church community more. And the same with all our networks of relationships (including church relationships).

In short, we should be questioning any activity which does not include all the witnesses to Jesus.

3. The prescription for the church and the world is the same

It is striking that what brings people to Christ, is the same thing as helps them to grow in him. It is as we hear the gospel that we grow stronger (Hebrews 5:11-14), it is as we are rebuked and encouraged by the church that we become more Christ-like (1 Thessalonians 5:11; Hebrews 10:25).

The problems for both non-Christians as well as Christians is unbelief, and the Gospel to believe is the same for both.

Because of that we don't need to have one set of activities for non-Christians and another for Christians. They can and should be the same. But that means we should have an eye to both Christians and non-Christians in all our meetings (as Paul says 1 Corinthians 14:23). Meetings should always be accessible but should also recognise that the felt needs of both Christians (e.g. rousing worship or traditional hymns etc) or non-Christians (e.g. a good moral environment for children) are not what we are here for. The church is in the business of preaching the gospel and bringing people under the Lordship of Christ.

4. Break down barriers to witness

What is it that stops us bringing all these witnesses onto the stand together for people to see and hear?

Perhaps we work in one area, live in another, and go to church in yet another so all three witnesses will never get together. Perhaps we only have time to build relationships with church people because we are too busy with church activities. Or perhaps we only have time to build relationships with colleagues, but not people at church, because we are too busy with work. Or perhaps the activities of church (organisationally and socially) are totally divorced from those of our family, friends and colleagues outside church. Or perhaps we are not being challenged from the pulpit to live the kind of radically unworldly lives that would turn heads.

Wednesday, November 18, 2009

Questions to ask of scripture

What are the questions we should ask when approaching a passage of Scripture?

The first question we must ask of every biblical text is simply this—what does it tell us about God? What does it say about who he is and about what he does?

The second question is: what does this text say about us human beings? What are we meant to be and what has gone wrong?

The third and final question is: what has God done about this and what does he expect of us in the light of what he has done? (source)

I quite like those, so will try and remember them. I may want to change it a little to emphasise that it is God speaking to us, but generally I think they're quite helpful. So like most helpful stuff I know I'll forget, I'll blog them.

Tuesday, November 17, 2009

The way of escape

You do not understand Christ till you understand His cross...

It is only by understanding it that we escape from

religion with no mind,
    and from religion which is all mind,
from pietism with its lack of critical judgment,
    and from rationalism [both liberal and conservative] with its lack of everything else.

(formatting mine, p.26, PT Forsyth, The Cruciality of the Cross)