I'm not sure I would be a big fan of Moltmann, although I haven't read him. But in a spare moment today I enjoyed reading Richard Bauckham's preface to The Crucified God.
The God who, omnipotent and unaffected, remains simply sovereign over the horrors of twentieth-century western cultural history is the God against whom what Moltmann calls 'protest atheism', represented by Albert Camus, finds it morally necessary to rebel. But is this God truly the Christian God? For Moltmann and others, the crisis of credibility of classical theism provides Christian theology with the opportunity to return to the biblical story of God, with its centre in the cross and resurrection of Jesus, in which, Christian theology has always believed, God defines for us who he truly is. Here God is not only the authority responsible for the world, to whom protest against meaningless suffering can be directed, but also the fellow-sufferer, who enters into the hell of abandonment and suffers it in love for the godless and godforsaken [...] In Jesus' cry of godforsakeness, God the divine Son not only shares the godforsakeness which is at the heart of suffering, but also takes up the cry of protest against it.
(p.xii, The Crucified God)
With this kind of theology I'd always want to keep the balance that God is both the forsaken and the one who forsakes. But nevertheless I think that is a helpful quote as far as it goes.
I'm not sure either, but he's too insightful and provocative to either ignore, reject, or buy wholesale. You might find this short article by Moltmann called Godless Theology sheds some light.
ReplyDeleteJust read a related and beautiful thought today from Vanhoozer, in conclusion to his essay on Guilt, Goats & Gifts in Postmodernity (in Hill & James (ed.), The Glory of the atonement): "the cross is simultaneously the definitive critique of religion and the enabling condition of true spirituality".
Thanks for the heads up on the article. I'll give it a read.
ReplyDeleteI agree wholeheartedly with your first sentence. Definitely can't ignore him.