Thursday, February 19, 2009

Worms just a little lower than the angels

Chris Oldfield comments that "the gospel dignifies who we are by calling us into question."

Few people I have read calls humanity to question more than John Calvin. Marilynne Robinson (Pulitzer Prize winning novelist) observes that the extreme disparagements of humanity under sin by theologians such as Calvin comes from an understanding that we have dignity as creatures made just a little lower than the angels (Psalm 8:5).

Cauvin [Calvin] employs a characteristic language [...] including extreme disparagements of the physical body, and more generally of humankind under the aspect of sin or fallenness. [This is done] in the service of an extraordinarily exalted vision of the human soul. It is a form of hyperbole - purity is corruption, pleasure is illusion, wisdom is folly, virtue is depravity, by comparison with the holiness that can be imagined, not as the nature of God only, but as the nature of humankind also [...]

The self-abnegation that is always the condition of a true perception of the self or of God can only be understood as the rigorous imagination of a higher self. This is more complex than it sounds. Cauvin has an unsettling habit of referring to himself or to any other human being as a "worm." [Understood as a reference to Psalm 22] the word describes temporal estrangement from God and at the same time ultimate identity with Christ. In context it is the farthest thing from a term of contempt.

(pp. 182-183, The Death of Adam: Essays on Modern Thought)

Thank you Steve for lending me that book all those years ago.

The human-Godward movement freely given to us in Christ

James Torrance (last quote from him I promise - but thanks Glen for the recommendation) sums up a strength and (possible) weakness that I've read in much modern systematic theology (which I have just started reading in the last year):

The God-humanward and human-Godward relationship (movement), both freely given to us in Jesus Christ. When we considered the existential model of worship, we noticed that the God-humanward movement of grace is given to us in Christ. In virtue of it, we are summoned to respond in faith, in decision, in repentance and obedience [isn't this common?]. But the weakness here is that the only human-Godward movement is ours. In other words, it does not do full justice to the meaning of grace, for it short-circuits the vicarious humanity of Christ. Grace does not only mean that in the coming of Jesus Christ, God gives himself in holy love to humanity. It also means the coming of God as man, to do for us as a man what we cannot do for ourselves - to present us in himself through the eternal Spirit to the Father. In other words, the human-Godward movement, in which we are given to participate (as in worship and communion), is given freely and unconditionally.

(p. 53, James B Torrance, Worship, Community and the Triune God of Grace)

There is something important and true in this, and it has connections with Lutheranism's 'universal justification'. But I would like someone to tie this perspective into conversion, regeneration, and the work of the Holy Spirit in believers. In short I feel the wonderfully objective and past nature of our salvation has blossomed, but the subjective and present nature of it has been left undeveloped and the two have not grown together (c.f. Colin Gunton's comments).

I am left wanting balance. Sadly, Pia Desideria while historically interesting does not show how it can be achieved.

Tuesday, February 17, 2009

For you, even if you do not know it

These words from the French Reformed Baptisimal liturgy are beautiful:

Little child, for you Jesus Christ has come, he has fought, he has suffered. For you he entered the shadow of Gethsemane and the horror of Calvary. For you he uttered the cry "It is finished!" For you he rose from the dead and ascended into heaven and there intercedes - for you, little child, even though you do not know it. But in this way the word of the Gospel becomes true. "We love him, because he first loved us."

That describes the foundation of my belief that it is right to baptise infants. As James Torrance expands:

The work of salvation is from beginning to end the work of God. Baptism is the sign of what the triune God does. God forgives, God cleanses, God regenerates, God adopts, God sends the Spirit of his Son into our hearts whereby we cry "Abba, Father." Our response to this is to say amen in faith- our passive recipient response. There is nothing more passive than dying, being buried, being baptised.

[...]

Two things are important here: (a) Christ did not die for adults only! He died for adults and children..."Little child for you..." (b) God's grace is not conditioned by anything in us, not even by our faith! Nevertheless, baptism must always be an act of faith in the Christ who died for us and for our children. It is not a sign of our faith, but of the Christ in whom we believe [...] "...for you, little child, even though you do not know it..."

(pp. 76-80, James B Torrance, Worship, Community and the Triune God of Grace)

Sunday, February 15, 2009

Watching in the night

'At the end of 430 years, on that very day, all the hosts of the Lord went out from the land of Egypt. It was a night of watching by the Lord, to bring them out of the land of Egypt; so this same night is a night of watching kept to the Lord by all the people of Israel throughout their generations.' (Exodus 12:41-42)

'But concerning that day or that hour, no one knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father. Be on guard, keep awake. For you do not know when the time will come. It is like a man going on a journey, when he leaves home and puts his servants in charge, each with his work, and commands the doorkeeper to stay awake. Therefore stay awake—for you do not know when the master of the house will come, in the evening, or at midnight, or when the rooster crows, or in the morning— lest he come suddenly and find you asleep. And what I say to you I say to all: Stay awake.' (Mark 13:32-36)

'And they went to a place called Gethsemane. And he said to his disciples, "Sit here while I pray." And he took with him Peter and James and John, and began to be greatly distressed and troubled. And he said to them, "My soul is very sorrowful, even to death. Remain here and watch." And going a little farther, he fell on the ground and prayed that, if it were possible, the hour might pass from him. And he said, "Abba, Father, all things are possible for you. Remove this cup from me. Yet not what I will, but what you will." And he came and found them sleeping, and he said to Peter, "Simon, are you asleep? Could you not watch one hour? Watch and pray that you may not enter into temptation. The spirit indeed is willing, but the flesh is weak." And again he went away and prayed, saying the same words. And again he came and found them sleeping, for their eyes were very heavy, and they did not know what to answer him. And he came the third time and said to them, "Are you still sleeping and taking your rest? It is enough; the hour has come. The Son of Man is betrayed into the hands of sinners. Rise, let us be going; see, my betrayer is at hand."' (Mark 14:32-42)

With great thanks to my friend Jonny who showed me the Exodus connection.

And in case you ask I don't really understand Mark's 'Little Apocalypse'. I find it interesting how much of what it talks about happened in the Passion story, but I can't tie it up all neat and tidy. However, that does make clear that the focus is on the cross as the centre-point of history around which all else turns (even the remaking of the world).

Who do you say I am?

In his lectures, Christology, Dietrich Bonhoeffer made the plea that in theology we give priority to the question of who over how, and that we always seek answers to the question of how in terms of who.

[...]

We can too readily assume that Christianity is meaningful, useful, relevant, even true, only if it seen to offer solutions to [...] practical problems. We can too readily subsume theology (as Ritschl did in the nineteenth century) under the category of means and ends.

(pp. 69-70, James B Torrance, Worship, Community and the Triune God of Grace)

My prayer as I 'lead' a new round of Christianity Explored from tomorrow that I remember this. Too often recently I have stressed how Christianity meets felt needs, and so missed much of the Gospel which is a person (as Mark says at the beginning of Mark's Gospel; 1:1).

Mark's Gospel, which Christianity Explored looks at, is deeply concerned with Jesus' identity. I didn't really get it at the time but I am sure that that is why the forerunner of UCCF's FREE Gospel Project was named 'Identity'. [I remember that project particularly well as that 'Identity Gospel' was the first time I ever read the bible as an adult.]

Too the end of reminding myself who Mark says Jesus is, I have just quickly read through the Gospel and noted down all the instances of people explicitly saying who they think Jesus is (a very incomplete way of looking at it I know, but hopefully helpful).

  • Mark: "Jesus Christ, the Son of God" (1:1)
  • God the Father: "You are my beloved Son; with you I am well pleased" (1:11)
  • Man with an unclean spirit: "Jesus of Nazareth...the Holy One of God" (1:24)
  • Unclean spirits: "You are the Son of God" (2:11)
  • His family: "He is out of his mind" (2:21)
  • The scribes from Jerusalem: "He is possessed by Beelzebul...He has an unclean spirit" (2:22-30)
  • Disciples: "Teacher" (4:38, followed by stilling of storm when they ask:"Who then is this", v.41?)
  • Man with unclean spirit: "Son of the Most High God" (5:7)
  • Those from the ruler's house: "Teacher" (5:35)
  • People at the synagogue in his hometown: "the carpenter, the son of Mary and brother of James and Joses and Judas and Simon" (6:3)
  • Some people: "John the Baptist...raised from the dead" (6:14)
  • Some others: "He is Elijah" (6:15)
  • Some more others: "He is a prophet, like one of the prophets of old" (6:15)
  • Herod: "John, whom I beheaded, has been raised" (6:16)
  • Syrophoenician woman: "Lord" (7:28)
  • Some people: "John the Baptist" (8:28)
  • Some others: "Elijah" (8:28)
  • Some more others: "one of the prophets" (8:28)
  • Peter: "You are the Christ" (8:29)
  • Peter, James and John: "Rabbi" (9:5)
  • God the Father: "This is my beloved Son; listen to him" (9:7)
  • Father of a boy with an unclean spirit: "Teacher" (9:17)
  • Disciples: "Teacher" (9:38)
  • Rich Young Man: "Good Teacher" (10:17) and "Teacher" (10:20)
  • James and John: "Teacher" (10:35)
  • Bartimaeus, a blind beggar, the son of Timaeus: "Son of David" (10:48) and "Rabbi" (10:51)
  • Crowd: "he who comes in the name of the Lord" (11:9)
  • Peter: "Rabbi" (11:21)
  • Pharisees and some of the Herodians: "Teacher" (12:14)
  • Sadducees: "Teacher" (12:19)
  • One of the scribes: "Teacher" (12:32)
  • One of his disciples: "Teacher" (13:1)
  • Judas: "Rabbi" (14:45)
  • Jesus: "I am [the Christ, the Son of the Blessed]" (14:62; in response to the High Priest's question; 14:61)
  • Jesus: "You have said [I am the King of the Jews]" (15:2; in response to Pilate's question)
  • Pilate: "the King of the Jews" (16:9)
  • Soldiers (mockingly): "King of the Jews" (16:18)
  • The chief priests with the scribes (mockingly): "the Christ, the King of Israel" (16:32)
  • Centurion by the cross: "the Son of God" (15:39)
  • Angels: "Jesus of Nazareth" (16:6)

[The different colours represent different groups of people, and the bold words are those that echo Mark's introduction in 1:1]

I glean a few things from this (which are quite obvious, sorry):

  1. The book is structured round the key confessions of Jesus as Messiah and Son of God. It is clear that both are important.
  2. God the Father's declaration at Jesus' Baptism, and the Transfiguration is as important as Peter's in 8:28. The dramatic events around the cross also have the feeling of a voice from heaven.
  3. The trial before Pilate and the High Priest is very important, as is the verdict given by the sign above the cross, and the Centurion.
  4. The disciples at no point during the Gospel come to a realisation of who Jesus is, with the one possible exception of Peter's confession in 8:28.
  5. The outsiders are the people who see the truth; those with unclean spirits, the Syrophoenician woman, Blind Bartimaeus and the Centrurion.

Wednesday, February 11, 2009

Churches doing student mission

Here is a question for my UCCF affliated readers: How does UCCF see churches doing student mission? And how does this relate to how UCCF sees mission to students being done on campus?

I had an interesting conversation with a Fusion affliated person the other day who provoked me to thought. I love UCCF and explained that they love the church (as Dave Bish is always saying) but couldn't answer that particular question for myself.

... just wondering.

PS. Sorry for the use of the word 'affliated' and for bothering everyone else with things that maybe are not that important.

The roots of Evangelicalism

Colin Gunton mentions in passing that:

Evangelicalism arises out of: (a) the Reformation and (b) Pietism.

I've heard that before but cannot remember where. The question is do we know our own history? How far are we aware of where we have come from.

I would say we are doing better at remembering one of our parents (the Reformation) and less good at remembering the other. I would even go so far as to say that Evangelicalism may be suffering for it.... but that may just be from my limited view in the corner I inhabit. But there is room for us to remember all our history much more than we do.

Once we remember we may then attempt to reflect.

Colin Gunton comments that to the extent Evangelicalism relies on the Reformation it is more objective, and on Pietism more subjective. PT Forsyth comments:

'after the Reformation period, [theologians] dwelt upon justification until they lost sight of sanctification altogether. Then the great pietistic movement had to arise in order to redress the balance.' (The Work of Christ)

...I wonder whether I should read Pia Desideria... its only 136 pages apparently.

Tuesday, February 10, 2009

What do you want me to do for you?

Mark is quite subtle in some ways about how he expects his readers to respond to the Gospel of Jesus Christ. Rico Tice in Christianity Explored this evening pointed us to two different responses to Jesus.

The two accounts are clearly meant to be read together as they immediately follow on from one another and contain exactly the same question from Jesus: 'What do you want me to do for you?' (10:36, 51). Clearly they are also important as they occur immediately before the entry to Jerusalem and the Passion narrative.

James and John's respond to the question: 'Grant us to sit, one at your right hand and one at your left, in your glory' (v. 37). Bartimaeus responds: 'Rabbi, let me recover my sight' (v. 51).

It is difficult at first to see how the two answers relate to one another. Presumably one is supposed to be the opposite of the other. But how?

I am open to being persuaded otherwise, but I think the answer can be gathered from 3 observations:

  1. Jesus asks the question what he can do.
  2. Jesus' response to James and John is to ask whether they can do what he will do (ie. drink the cup he will drink). Their answer is 'yes', and Jesus almost grudgingly confirms that they will, but adds that this will not make him approve them to sit at his side.
  3. The link verse between the two narratives is 'the Son of Man came not to be served but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many' (v. 45).

Reading the narrative of the request of James and John on its own may lead you to conclude that the point is to teach us that to follow Christ means to take up our cross; to be 'slave of all' (v.44). However, reading the two narratives together shows that this is secondary, although essential. First, we must accept that we like the blind beggar have nothing to give to God we can only receive.

This is a difficult truth to take to heart.

In the Christianity Explored course the final question is 'If you could ask God one question, and you knew it would be answered, what would it be?'. One of our group tonight confessed it would be 'What do you want me to do for you?' According to the Gospel that is the question that Jesus asks!

'nor is he served by human hands, as though he needed anything, since he himself gives to all mankind life and breath and everything' (Acts 17:25)

Monday, February 09, 2009

Can God be known?

'Can God be known? Yes, God can be known, since it is actually true and real that He is knowable through Himself. When that happens, man becomes free, he becomes empowered, he becomes capable - a mystery to himself - of knowing God. Knowledge of God is a knowledge completely effected and determined from the side of its object, from the side of God. But for that very reason it is genuine knowledge; for that very reason it is in the deepest sense free knowledge. Of course it remains a relative knowledge, a knowledge imprisoned within the limits of the creaturely. Of course it is especially true here that we are carrying heavenly treasures in earthen vessels. Our concepts are not adequate to grasp this treasure. Precisely where this genuine knowledge of God takes place it will also be clear that there is no occasion for any pride. There always remains powerless man, creaturely reason within its limitations. But in this area of the creaturely, of the inadequate, it has pleased God to reveal Himself. And since man is foolish in this respect too. He will be wise; since man is petty, He will be great; since man is inadequate, God is adequate. 'Let my grace suffice for thee. For my strength is mighty in the weak' holds good also for the question of knowledge.'

(p.24, Karl Barth, Dogmatics in Outline)

I really, really love that quote. The only think I don't quite understand is quite what Barth means by it being 'free' knowledge.

The challenge is to ask how I am rejecting that revelation and the promise of knowing God it contains, and choosing to 'know' God in other ways?

The sole and proper witness of God

'God himself is the sole and proper witness of himself' (John Calvin, Institutes 1.11.1)

'He who we can know only through his own utterances is a fitting witness concerning himself' (Hilary of Poitiers, On the Trinity I, xviii)

I'm re-reading Calvin's Institutes this year. A little way in I'm thinking that I need to do some reflection on what I'm learning from it.

Perhaps the thing I'm most struck by so far is Calvin's determination to let God describe who God is. I am perhaps more aware of this because of reading a little Karl Barth recently, but it is great seeing that conviction that God is the proper witness of himself worked out in Calvin's explanation of what God is like.

Tuesday, February 03, 2009

Christ and Culture

James KA Smith is an interesting fellow. He came to York (and indeed my church) last year for several months, but I never got to know him. I would love to have the time to read some of his books.

Anyway his review of Carson's Christ and Culture Revisted is really exceptional. It makes you realise the issues at stake and ask yourself: how would I right the book better? Smith doesn't really give you the answer, and I don't know it. Which is both disconcerting, and challenging.

Sunday, February 01, 2009

Perfection and Presence: God With Us, According to the Christian Confession

If you fancy listening to 6 hard-core theological lectures, John Webster gave The "Kantzer Lectures in Revealed Theology" just over a year ago at the Henry Center.

The blurb reads as follows:

Dr. Webster presented the first Kantzer Lectures at Trinity on September 11-18, 2007. These six lectures offer a theological description of the double theme of the Christian gospel, God's perfect life which he has in himself and God's presence with his creatures.

The series began with an account of the source of the Christian confession of God's perfection and presence, which is God's loving gift of himself as Lord and companion of creatures, on the basis of which God may be known, feared and loved above all things. This was followed by an account of God's perfection: the fullness, majesty and glorious freedom of the life which God has from and in himself as Father, Son and Holy Spirit. As the one who has life in himself, the perfect God also gives life to creatures, and sustains them by his presence. The nature, modes and history of this presence were explored in a Trinitarian analysis of God's works in creating, reconciling and bringing creatures to completion. Finally, life in the fellowship of the saints was presented as the creaturely counterpart of the presence of the perfect God.

Taken as a whole, the lectures were an exercise in positive or revealed theology, seeking to display the instruction of the gospel and commend the consolation which it offers. The series brought together pastors, professors and students from various institutions and churches around the Chicagoland area. The lectures will be published in book form by William B. Eerdmans.

Webster describes it more briefly as a meditation on Immanuel, 'God with us', which does not diminish that it is 'God with us' and keeps in mind the uncreated perfection of God.

He took our punishment

If you fancy reading my first attempt at an essay on theology for a long time you can read below. Please feel free to blow monster size holes in it, but bare in mind that I am far from trying to say everything about the Atonement (if you even could). It is about 3500 words and came out of this conversation so is the result of an already busy week's reflection.

1. Introduction

Several hundred years before Jesus Isaiah chapter 53 speaks of a servant who is hated, rejected and suffers 'for us'.  Onlookers think that he is being punished for something he has done, but Isaiah tells us that he was being punished for 'our sins', not his.

This is as difficult for us as onlookers to Jesus' death to understand as those onlookers Isaiah describes.  Tom Smail asks the question that has been asked by many others before: 'By what right or justice can punishment be imposed on anybody except the person who has committed the offence? Is the bearing of punishment not one of those things that cannot be done by one person for another' (p. 85, 'Can One Man Die for the People?', in John Goldingay (ed.), Atonement Today).  The reason for this is that 'guilt and punishment are not like fines, things that can be incurred by one person and settled by another.  Intrinsically by their very nature, and morally by every rule of justice, they are inseparably attached to the person who, by what he or she does and is, has incurred them' (p.78, ibid).

There are two assumptions under this objection.  The first is that what was happening at the cross closely resembles of the modern human law court.  HE Guillebaud explains how Christians have often been at fault in leading to this assumption:

it is difficult for our minds to think of Divine things without using human analogies, but these analogies are often very dangerous [...] It must be admitted that "conservative" preachers and writers, in their desire to make the doctrine clear, have sometimes used human analogies in an indefensible manner, and have thereby unintentionally given real ground for objection (p. 146, Why the Cross?)

There are several ways in which what is happening at the cross differs from that of the modern human law court.  The primary difference may be that where we can only imagine distinct parties, at the cross beside the criminal 'there is only One, Who is Judge, Wronged Party, King (or Law), and Substitute' (p.147,ibid), and even the distinction between Substitute and criminal is not absolute as we shall see.

The other assumption underlying the objection is that we know what justice is.  In this essay I will focus on the bible's understanding of justice and explore how according to this the punishment of our sins in Jesus is just.

2. Who's justice? 

There are as many understandings of what is 'just' as their are individuals on the planet.  Some people consider it just that a thief has his hand chopped off, where as many others cannot think of anything more unjust.  More at home are debates about the justice of penalties for speeding and illegal downloads.  One person's justice is another's injustice.

However, despite the arguments of some, this has not led most people to conclude that there is no such thing as justice, or that it is totally unknowable.  In the midst of this confusion attempts have been made to describe a theory of justice which can form a basis for objective decisions about what is just and what is not.  Sometimes such theorists have thought justice is something 'out there' waiting to be discovered, while others have been happy to consider that it is a human creation. 

If justice is a human creation then, like the gods in Terry Pratchett's novel Small Gods, different forms of justice grow or shrink in power according to the number of believers they enjoy.  But as the atheist Terry Practchett demonstrated for religion in his novel, this understanding of justice can make no demands and is open to ridicule.  But even if justice is 'out there' the problems that have been found with every theory of justice show that while we may come more or less close to discovering justice no-one has ever found it.

In contrast to our theories which may be more or less just, or our practice of justice which is also imperfect, God is presented in the Bible as the one who 'does no wrong' (Deuteronomy 32:4) and in whom is 'no injustice or partiality or bribery' (2 Chronicles 19:7).  All of our justice is tainted by self interest and inadequately protects the powerless, but God's justice is characterised by total fairness.  He 'does not show favouritism' (Romans 2:11) and defends the cause of the fatherless, widow and foreigner (the least powerful in Ancient societies; Deuteronomy 10:17-18).

But God is not perfectly just because he obeys a standard that is 'out there' apart from him.  The Bible recognises that this would mean there is a god whom God chooses to obey.  God would no longer be the 'Alpha and Omega' (Greek A-Z; Revelation 1:8) but would be a second power, and a secondary source of all good things.  In short he would no longer be God.  For this reason Solomon asks God for his justice (Psalm 72:1) because justice belongs to God, and has no existence apart from him.  Because justice is found in God 'we must let God's character and actions define our vision of justice rather than letting our vision of justice define our expectations of God' (p. 11, David McIlroy, A Biblical View of Law and Justice).

Philosophically this makes sense, but is it morally acceptable?  Describing justice as defined by God seems a bit like Richard Nixon's comment in his interview with David Frost that the President can on occasion do something illegal because 'when the president does it that means that it is not illegal', by definition.  That comment disgusted the world because it was recognised that the President is under the law as much as any other citizen.  Justice is not flexible to the whims of the most powerful.  Might is not right.  Clearly, there is an important difference between Richard Nixon and God in that Richard Nixon is only human, and according to our belief that all human beings are equal one has no ability to define justice which binds everyone.  But another difference is hinted at by the writers of the Psalms constant pleas to God to remember his justice and act according to it.  Just like their pleas for him to act according to his love and promises these pleas recognise that God is consistent and does not change in his dealings with us.  We can trust him because he is the same yesterday, today and forever (Hebrews 13:8).  Unlike Richard Nixon does not mould justice as it suits, but acts justly always because he only acts according to his own unchanging nature.  In one sense he is bound to act justly, but only because he is bound to act in accordance with his own nature.

In the first chapters of Genesis we are told how Adam and Eve ate of the tree of 'knowledge of good and evil' (that is in biblical terminology the ability administer justice).  They grasped at the ability to judge things for themselves, rather than trusting God's judgment.  We still like to do the same thing but should recognise that our taking judgment upon our own shoulders has brought injustice to the world.  We should let God take the place of judgment and not judge him.  This is an act of faith that God is just, but he unlike anyone else has proved himself by the consistency of his actions. 

Having said that we cannot pull God down from his proper place as the source of justice, the question can still be asked how it is that it was that Jesus could be killed for sins he did not commit.  We can still seek to understand how God can be consistently just when he punishes Jesus in our place, and yet states that: 'he who justifies the wicked and he who condemns the righteous are both alike an abomination to the Lord' (Proverbs 17:15); and that 'no man can ransom another' (Psalm 49:7).

We can begin to understand this by looking at what we have already briefly considered: our inability to be perfect judges.

2. Reaching for the moon: Human justice
 
Human justice is different to God's justice both in the abstract, and in practice. 

Human beings find it impossible to fully grasp justice in the abstract.  We are unable to say describe exactly why something is just or not.  Nevertheless, we are able to say true things about justice.  Similarly, we cannot perfectly practice justice, not simply because we are sinfully self-interested, but also because we are finite creatures.  Nevertheless, we can still administer true justice to a degree.

An important reason we cannot administer perfect justice is because we cannot know everything. Even if we can perfectly know the external events that occurred we cannot judge perfectly. 

We recognise that in most cases a criminal must not only do something against the law but must also have mens rea (a guilty mind).  However, we are unable to even perfectly understand our own minds, never mind anyone else's.  In contrast God can search our heart and know the full extent and nature of everyone's guilt (Jeremiah 17:10; Revelation 2:23).

We also recognise that we are not isolated individuals and responsibility can be shared.  In English law conspirators can be punished to the same extent as those who do the actual act of committing a crime, and incitement can provide a defence to assault.  Judges may be lenient to individuals who have had a life which makes their crime more 'understandable'.  But really we are extremely limited.  A complex web of experiences, choices and influences may have brought an individual to the dock.  A slightly neglectful parent, an exam result, or the time in which you were born are all factors which lead to you doing this or that then.  In addition, while the same criminal act may lead to different outcomes, even ultimately good.  There is always both corporate as well as individual responsibility which makes human justice so limited in its affect.

'There is no such thing as the absolutely individual man with whose acts [...] All men are members of a society in which they live and move and have their being morally, and in all they do, of right or wrong they both affect and are affected by the body to which they belong.  This has to be kept in mind and leads to two apparently contrary inferences.  On the one hand, the scope of the sinner's responsibility is immensely enlarged.  He does not sin, any more than he lives, to himself.  His act tells not only on himself and on God, but on the society of which he is a member. [This] means that reconciliation [and justice] will be a greater work than might at first have been anticipated - more far-reaching and more difficult.  It must embrace in its scope not only the individual [...] but the society to which he belongs, and in which that bad action has originated unmeasured evils which he never contemplated [...] On the other hand, the consideration of man's essentially social nature has sometimes seemed to extenuate his personal guilt.' (p. 191-192, James Denney, The Christian Doctrine of Reconciliation)

Recognising the human limitations our practice justice should be different to God's practice of justice.  They should be aligned but we should recognise that God's judgments will always be different to ours, and must be to be just.  For this reason God forbade Israel from judging corporately:

'Fathers shall not be put to death because of their children, nor shall children be put to death because of their fathers. Each one shall be put to death for his own sin.'  (Deuteronomy 24:16)

We may see this commandment as self-evident but while it was unique it 'is set against a tendency in the biblical world to impugn whole families for the offences of a member of them' (p.363, JG McConville, Deuteronomy).  Indeed 'even Roman law, as codified by a Christian Emperor, permitted the destruction of the family and close associates of a man found guilty of treason against the state' (p. 35, GE Anscombe, 'Prophecy and Miracles' in Faith in a Hard Ground: Essays on Religion, Philosophy and Ethics).  But God's prohibition on corporate punishment by the state, does not prevent God from saying in the same book that:

'I the Lord your God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on the children to the third and fourth generation of those who hate me, but showing steadfast love to thousands of those who love me and keep my commandments.' (Deuteronomy 5:9-10)
If God's justice is different to ours does that mean that we have to give up reaching any understanding of how God could be just in punishing Jesus? I think that while we can only ever understand it imperfectly we can make some steps towards understanding it, and those steps involve grasping more of how corporate identity works, when in our modern Western culture has minimised it.

3. Perfect Justice

While always holding individauls responsible for their actions, God also regularly acts on the basis of corporate identity.

'For example, in Joshua 7, thirty-six Israelite soldiers lose their lives in battle on account of the Achan, and his family members are then executed with him.  In 2 Samuel 21:1-14, seven of Saul's sons are executed for their father's sin [...] Similarly, there are many examples where people receive blessings from God because of the righteousness of others, such as the sparing of Mephibosheth because of the oath between David and Jonathan (2 Sam. 21:7; cf. 1 Sam 18:3; 20:8, 17, 42; 23:18) and the reprieve granted to all Isarel because of the humility and righteousness of King Josiah (2 Kgs 22:9-20).' (p. 246-247, Steve Jeffery et al, Pierced For Our Transgressions)
We are familiar with the idea of corporate identity even if corporate responsibility seems is largely ignored.  If we describe ourselves we usually do so in relation to other people.  I may have many identities such as that of a British citizen, a socialist, a Manchester United supporter, or someone who dresses like middle-class white male.  Some of these I consciously choose to make part of my identity, some I drift into, and some I am born into.  I share in the glories and shame of those identities.  I glory in the win of my favourite team and am ashamed of the crimes of my country.  Similarly I can give a good name to members of my family, or reduce employers expectations of all Bristol University graduates. 

Some identities may be central to my existence, and some I hold to loosely.  But my identity is not solely dependant on me as an individual.  Some socialists may refuse to recognise me as someone like them, but some may.   I may choose to identify myself as a citizen of Iran, but if the Iranian government don't acknowledge me as such my identity may be damaged; but then it may not if they refuse to acknowledge me because I oppose the present regime.  The complexity of human relationships require an infinite god to untangle them. 

The Bible considers it just that Jesus should die the death that is deserved by us because God sees us as sharing a corporate identity.  Similarly it is just that we should receive eternal life that belongs to Jesus alone because of that identity.  Jesus talks of us as part of his kingdom and his family (Matthew 12:49-50), the apostle Paul talks of how we are the 'body of Christ' (Ephesians 4:12), the apostle Peter calls the church a nation and people belonging to Christ (1 Peter 2:9), and John says the church is married to Christ (Revelation 21:2).  All these are corporate descriptions of our union with Christ.  To the early church every good thing that the church enjoys is enjoyed only because we are 'in Christ', that is in united to him.  'In Christ' we have eternal life (Romans 6:23), freedom (Romans 8:2), holiness (1 Corinthians 1:2), wisdom (1 Corinthians 4:10), victory (2 Corinthians 2:14), and a favourable verdict from God (Galatians 2:17).

Martin Luther describes how we share what belongs to Christ, as we are united in one identity with him:

'[faith] unites the soul with Christ as a bride is united with her bridegroom.  By this mystery, as the Apostle teaches, Christ and the soul become one flesh [Eph. 5:31-32].  And if they are one flesh and there is between them a true marriage  indeed the most perfect of all marriages, since human marriages are but poor examples of this one true marriage - it follows that everything they have they hold in common, the good as well as the evil [...] Christ is full of grace, life and salvation.  The soul is full of sins, death, and damnation.  Now let faith come between them and sins, death, and damnation will be Christ's, while grace, life, and salvation will be the soul's; for if Christ is a bridegroom, he must take upon himself the things which are his bride's and bestow upon her the things that are his [...] By the wedding ring of faith he shares in the sins, death, and pains of hell which are his bride's.  As a matter of fact, he makes them his own and acts as if they were his own and as if he himself had sinned' (pp. 18-20, On Christian Liberty)

Martin Luther mentions that we are united with Christ by faith.  That is by believing that he came and identified with us, and identifying with him we share his identity and so his life and favourable verdict from God.

Many of the onlookers to Jesus' death did not want to identify with him.  He seemed of little account, and was suffering the punishment of death.  None of us like to think that we deserve death, and that the place of punishment is where we belong, but if we do then we can identify with the man suffering punishment for sins.  Wonderfully though that means we can also identify with him as he is raised to new life.  Our unification is not just intellectual or emotional though.  Like marriage, citizenship, and so many other identities it is also expressed in ritual.  So the Apostles called on people to believe, 'repent and be baptised...in the name of Jesus Christ' (Acts 2:38), that is into his identity.  As Paul says we are baptised into his body (1 Corinthians 12:13); into his death and so into his resurrection (Romans 6:3).

We have no right to claim an identity with the Son of God if he does not will it, nor if the judge rules it invalid (the Father judges sin in Jesus, and Jesus will judge the world).  Just as I cannot claim the citizenship of France just because I believe it I belong there, I cannot claim my citizenship in heaven with Christ unless he wills it (Philippians 3:20).  Thankfully, we know that the Father, Son and Holy Spirit all desire for us to identify with Christ and share in his riches.  The Father who called the universe into existence out of nothing, calls us into unity with his son (1 Corinthians 1:9) whom he sent (John 8:42).  The Son 'made himself nothing, taking the form of a servant, being born in the likeness of men' (Philippians 2:17).  The Holy Spirit takes up residence in us, so we are united with Christ (1 John 4:13). 

Christ identified with us long before we identified with him, and in fact it is because of this loving act that we then love him (1 John 4:19).  We are told that we were included in Christ before the foundation of the world by the will of the Father (Ephesians 1:4).  The Father happily sent his Son to the world to be our representative before him (1 John 4:14).  Jesus happily and without coercion identified with us by becoming human and sharing our flesh (John 1:14) and shared our suffering and death (Hebrews 2).  Just as we were baptised into him he was baptised into us.  Everyone of the Gospels records how John the Baptist was baptising people who realised that they needed forgiveness for their sins, and who desired to be washed clean of all that they had done.  Jesus joins all these people on the banks of a river and joins in the same ritual.  John the Baptist objects, pointing out that he is the one man who does not need washing, but Jesus chooses to identify with those who recognise their sin to 'fulfill all righteousness', that is to achieve his saving purpose (Matthew 3).  His hanging on a cross receiving judicial punishment alongside two deserving criminals is the centre of his identification with sinful humanity.  But his power, life and holiness is greater than the whole worlds weakness, death and evil.  Death is not the end for him as it is for us apart from him, but leads to new life and not a verdict of condemnation but the declaration 'this is my beloved Son, with whom I am well pleased' (Matthew 3:17).  The amazing thing is that the same declaration can be made of us if we are united with him (Romans 8:14, 1 John 3:1).

Monday, January 26, 2009

Questioning Evangelism

As an aside to my previous post. Questions are sometimes as good as answers to questions we are asked. Randy Newman has done more than most to bring that important principle to my mind. I often forget and theology-dump on people; and even worse do it in an unstructured mess which reflects my messed up brain. However some questions deserve answers as well as more questions. Still they probably should include questions mixed up with them.

You are probably familiar with the simply stated principle Randy Newman has popularised, but if not you can listen to these talks:

Sunday, January 25, 2009

God's justice

Today a non-Christian who often comes to our church asked me how it could be just that if we deserve punishment due to our sin, it is just for that punishment to be received by another.

It is shamefully a difficult question for me to answer well. I say it is shameful because it is so close to the heart of the Christian faith. My response (so far - I have agreed to get back to him) pointed at a few things which would help us some way towards an answer:

  1. Jesus was not a third party to the dispute, but God himself who chose to take the punishment upon himself.
  2. Jesus chose to do this willingly and not under coercion.
  3. We should get our idea of justice from God, and not impose it on him.
  4. Connected to that, God is not seeking to satisfy another god called Justice, but seeking to satisfy himself.
  5. We do not just have an individual identity, but also a corporate one. As a corporate unit we were judged in Christ who is our head.

Sadly my answer, nor that of others, was found to be very satisfactory.

I think the heart of the issue is point 5. Corporate responsibility is an alien concept to us now. Most Christians struggle with the numerous OT passages where God punishes the families of those who rebel (e.g. Num 16) and find that Exodus 20:5-6 ('I the Lord your God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on the children to the third and the fourth generation of those who hate me, but showing steadfast love to thousands of those who love me and keep my commandments') sticks in the throat. We are much more comfortable with Ezekiel 18:20 ('The soul who sins shall die. The son shall not suffer for the iniquity of the father, nor the father suffer for the iniquity of the son. The righteousness of the righteous shall be upon himself, and the wickedness of the wicked shall be upon himself').

I need to think more this week about:

  1. How to fit together individual and corporate responsibility in God's justice (because there is clearly both).
  2. How to communicate the justice of corporate responsibility to a contemporary Western non-Christian.

Any help would be gratefully received (even book recommendations).

Apart from your help my first points of call will be John Stott and PT Forsyth.

BTW this is a different person to that person who asked this question.

Saturday, January 24, 2009

A Centurion for a guide

Trinitarian theology causes me a lot of head scratching. Particularly difficult for me to understand is how 'It is in the Son that God is presented to us in a human life, but through his Trinitarian perichoresis that human life images both the Father and the Spirit so that the specificities of their functions and their relationships come into focus' (p. 105f, Tom Smail, Life Father like Son). However, it is in 'the gospel story where God reveals himself' (p.82, ibid), and it is here, rather than abstractions that things become clearer for me. Tom Smail points to the Centurions's comments in Luke 7 for an example of how Jesus reveals his Father:

"Lord, do not trouble yourself, for I am not worthy to have you come under my roof. Therefore I did not presume to come to you. But say the word, and let my servant be healed. For I too am a man set under authority, with soldiers under me: and I say to one, 'Go,' and he goes; and to another, 'Come,' and he comes; and to my servant, ‘Do this,' and he does it." When Jesus heard these things, he marveled at him, and turning to the crowd that followed him, said, "I tell you, not even in Israel have I found such faith."

Tom Smail comments that:

What that Gentile faith grasps is that, through the exercise of what is proper to his Sonship, namely his obedience to the Father, in which he is a man under authority, he participates in what is proper to his Father - the power to utter a sovereign word that can take the initiative to break savingly into a situation - and becomes a man with authority to issue orders to illnesses.

(p. 105, ibid)

Stumbling around in my head

I'm currently reading Like Father Like Son: The Trinity Imaged in Our Humanity by Tom Smail. It is a good book, and I'm seeing the truth of Jason Goroncy's statement about Tom Smail that 'If only he didn't write so clearly then perhaps he might be taken more seriously as a theologian'.

I'm still trying to thrash over in my head what Tom Smail describes quite well:

'One of Karl Barth's central theological axioms was that when we are talking of God, it is the actuality that determines the possibility and not the other way round. We do not limit our openness to what God has done by prior notions of our own about what he could do; rather, our basis for recognizing what he can do is what he has already done' (p.27)

Karl Barth himself explains how this has massive implications for our understanding of the nature of God:

'If in faith in Jesus Christ we are ready to learn, to be told, what Godhead, or the divine nature is, we are confronted with what is and always will be to all other ways of thinking a mystery, and indeed a mystery that offends. The mystery reveals to us that for God it is just as natural to be lowly as it is to be high, to be near as it is to be far, to be little as it is to be great, to be abroad as it is to be at home.' (p. 152, CD IV:1 The Doctrine of Reconcilliation, 1956; quoted in p.77, Smail)

I keep on thinking over Philippians 2 and this idea. I am far from decided. My difficulty is that Jesus gave up what was naturally his in his incarnation ('though he was rich, yet for your sake he became poor'). And also that though he was crucified, he was also resurrected. Although the NT is clear that Jesus' glory is his cruxifiction as well as his resurrection (e.g. John 12) and that he is glorified because of his cruxifiction (e.g. Phil 2:9 and Rev 5:12). It is difficult for me.

Also difficult for me is understand is precisely how the Son reveals the Trinity. Tom Smail describes how he has two icons of Jesus. One depicting him alone looking out, and one of Jesus with the other two members of the Trinity looking at the Father (he has Rublev's famous one).

Smail comments that 'It is impossible to make any sense of the Jesus of the gospels if we treat him as a solitary individual whose significance is in himself' (p. 67 - which begs the question why you have such an icon - I hate icons). My difficulty is understanding whether we should see the Trinity revealed in Jesus as that solitary individual dying on the cross and rising to new life, or in Jesus as he dies in broken relationship toward his Father, and whom the Father restored by the power of the Spirit. The second option would seem to be right, but does that alter Barth's conclusion that for God it is 'natural to be lowly', when our Father is, and always has been, in heaven. Having said that God the Father obviously suffered seeing his Son crucified, and has throughout human history endured his name being blasphemed. All very difficult for me to make my head around!

And as an aside, listenining to their podcast, Mark Kermode and Simon Mayo have both introduced me to the wonderful phrase 'pharisaic cadre', and to the fact that Richard Nixon was a Quaker.

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

Why do good works?

Martin Luther in The Freedom of the Christian claims that 'no other work makes you a Christian than the one work: "you believe in him who he has sent" (John 6:29)'. This inevitably leads to the question: why then would anyone do anything good?

In The Freedom of the Christian at least his argument seems to have this structure:

  1. The Christian seeks to do certain good works such as fasting because he wants to bring his body under control.
  2. He seeks to bring his body under control because he wants to serve his neighbour more.
  3. He seeks to bring his serve his neighbour more because he spontaneously desires to please God.
  4. He seeks spontaneously desires to please God because his inner man has been created in the image of God and made new by faith.
  5. He is able to freely and cheerfully do this because he has all riches of righteousness and salvation in Christ.

Interestingly he never speaks explicitly of doing works out of gratitude or thanks (although that sometimes seems implied). Nor does he argue that it will bring benefits to the Christian that he would not otherwise receive either in this life or in the future.

Also striking to my eye was his emphasis on subjecting the body which is not heard much in the contemporary church. However, it is also interesting that he does not argue that this should be done because of some value that this has in itself, but instead he sees it as a means to the end of serving others. In this way he beautifully combines the importance of both private good works (bible reading, fasting etc) and public good works (practical help to the poor etc), and shows how they are inseparable, but of different orders of importance.

Tuesday, January 20, 2009

An outline of 'The Freedom of the Christian' by Martin Luther

[I've been meaning to do this for myself for ages. Please feel free to critique as it was a bit rushed. A old translation can be found online here. Newer translations can be bought.]


1. INTRODUCTION

This is a treatise on faith

It can be summarised in the two statements:

(i) 'A Christian is a perfectly free lord of all, subject to none.'

(ii) 'A Christian is a perfectly dutiful servant of all, subject to all.'

Scripture can say contradictory things about the same person because of the distinction it makes between the spiritual (inner) and bodily (outer) nature of man


2. THE INNER MAN - 'A CHRISTIAN IS A PERFECTLY FREE LORD OF ALL, SUBJECT TO NONE.'

2.1 How the inner man becomes righteous and free

Consider the inner man to see how someone becomes righteous, free and pious.

He cannot become so by external things, as both the wicked and godly experience all types of situation, and can do all kinds of works.

Only the Word of God, the gospel of Christ can do make someone righteous and free.

The Word of God cannot be cherished by works, but only by faith (hence justification by faith, not works).

Faith cannot even exist with works because faith makes you see works as damnable.

2.2 Law and Gospel

Objection: if faith alone justifies then why are there so many commands in Scripture.

Answer: There is a distinction between Commands and promises. Commands teach man to know himself, and make him despair, and seek help. The promises fulfill the commands for us. So all things are God's alone.

2.3 Powers of faith

Grasping promises with faith means you share in their power. There are 3 powers of faith:

  • Power of faith 1: All things necessary for salvation are imparted to us.
  • Power of faith 2: It honours him who it trusts as it considers God truthful, righteous and trustworthy.
  • Power of faith 3: It unites the soul with Christ as a bride to a bridegroom, where he shares all our sins, death and pain of hell, and we share his righteousness and life.

2.4 Christians are kings and priests in Christ

Christ is a greater king and priest than the OT because his kingdom and priesthood are heavenly.

United in marriage with Christ, Christians too are kings and priests.

As kings all things serve a Christian's salvation, even death and suffering.

As priests Christians are able to come into the presence of God and pray for each other, and teach one another.

One who does not believe is not served by all things and all things turn out for bad. His prayers are not heard and he cannot come into God's presence.

Excursus: Faith gives all things but if someone seeks salvation in works he will lose the benefits of faith.

2.4.1 Role of those called priests in contrast to lay people

Objection: If all are priests, what is the role of those we call priests.

Answer: to serve and teach (unlike so many priests who are actually tyrants)

2.5 Conclusion

Christ's works, life and words should not be preached as historical facts. He should be preached as an object of faith. By preaching faith is produced and there is Christian liberty and rejoicing over sin and death.


3. THE OUTER MAN - 'A CHRISTIAN IS A PERFECTLY DUTIFUL SERVANT OF ALL, SUBJECT TO ALL.'

3.1 Works which a Christian does for himself

A Christian man is not perfect immediately, but receives the fullness of the Spirit in the future. He must control his body and have dealings with men.

Body must be disciplined by fastings, watchings, and labours to be conformed to the inner man.

The inner man and the flesh are at war. This is because the inner man is clean and loves God so desires to see all things (esp. his own body) join with him in loving and praising God. He is does many good works to subject the body because he desires the approval of God.

Because this is his goal, he only does good works as long as they serve this goal, and not beyond as if there is something good about doing them in themselves, and that they earn righteousness.

3.1.1 'Good works do not make a good man, but a good man does good works; evil works do not make a wicked man, but a wicked man does evil works.'

Example 1: Adam and Eve were righteous but did works so that:

a) they were not idle.

b) to provide for their body

For the approval of God.

But faith and love are not increased by external works but by themselves.

Example 2: A bishop performs acts belonging to his office. These acts do not make him become a bishop, but they are valid because he is already a bishop.

Illustrations 1: tree produces fruit, not the other way round.

Illustrations 2: a builder builds a house, not the other way round.

In the sight of men people are made good/evil by their works, but men can be thus deceived.

Works are to be rejected if they are sought as a means to righteousness, as this changes their nature from good to damnable.

We must preach both commands and promises. Law is necessary for bringing fear and knowledge of sin, but we must also preach faith as if we just preach commands then people get the impression that that works justify.

3.2 Works which man does for his neighbour

The Christian must bring his body into subjection for the purpose of serving others.

As the Christian has all riches by faith he gives willingly and cheerfully without hope of reward. Christ (who we share with by faith) is our great example in this.

  • Christ had everything but emptied himself.
  • Christ loved both his friends and enemies.
  • Our neighbour in need is like we were. We should act as Christ acted towards us toward our neighbour.

We have made Christ a new tougher Moses.

  • Example of faith 1: Mary who did not need to be purified submitted to the law to avoid offending other women.
  • Example of faith 2: Paul circumcised Timothy though it was not necessary for righteousness.
  • Example of faith 3: Christ paying taxes to Caesar (Matt 7)
  • Example of fatih 4: Paul saying Christians should submit to government.

Good things flow from Christ to us by faith (by which we ascend to God), and from us to others by love (by which we descend to our neighbour).


4. THE MIDDLE WAY

People in reaction to those who rely on works for their salvation reject all ceremonies and laws. Both sides are in error.

Rejecting ceremonies etc does not make you righteous anymore than doing them.

Our freedom in Christ is not from works, but from false opinions about works. Our kingship is not of this world, we are still bound by needs of the bodily life.

Two types of people observe ceremonies. The stubborn who should be offended, and the ignorant and week, who care must be taken not to offend. This is how we love them.

Ceremonies have a role as models and plans, but are laid aside when the structure is complete. Hence they are not despised, but not held onto as the real and permanent structure.


5. CONCLUSION ON THE NEED FOR PRAYER

Humans are naturally superstitious and seek salvation by works so we must pray that God teaches us and writes the law on our hearts.

Saturday, January 17, 2009

To understand Paul on salvation we must understand him on sin

Richard Gaffin makes a convincing argument that ' if we are to understand Paul on salvation on salvation, including the order of salvation, we must understand him on sin' (p. 29, By Faith, Not by Sight). He argues this mainly on the recurrence of phrases like 'for our sins' in the most important of Paul's brief summaries of the Gospel.

He identifies several facets of Paul's treatment of sin:

  1. It is 'anti-relational' (primarily the in relation to God)
  2. It is 'illegal'
  3. It is 'universal'
  4. It is an 'enslaving and corrupting power'

Gaffin considers that sin has 'all sorts of disastrous and ruinous consequences' but the two basic consequences are:

  1. 'guilt'; and
  2. 'enslavement'

Classically, described as the penalty and power of sin (although Gaffin doesn't mention this). In my view the NPP (esp. Wright) focuses mainly on the latter, and the old perspective on the former.

I think the old perspective is right to emphasise the penalty, as the power of Satan and sin is primarily that of accusation (after all that is what Satan means). But we must celebrate the freedom from both.

Realised eschatology as the true 'new perspective' on Paul

Part of the recent consensus in Pauline scholarship emerging over the course of the twentieth century, just noted, is that Paul's eschatology has a dual or elliptical focus. For him eschatology is defined not only in terms of Christ's second coming but also by his first, by what has already taken place in Christ, especially his death and resurrection, as well as what is still future at his return. Paul teaches an eschatology that for the church is, i part, present, already realized.

In my view, looking at developments over the history of the interpretation of Paul as a whole, the relatively recent widespread recognition of his realized eschatology represents the truly "new perspective" on Paul, one that is far more important with wider-ranging implications than those developments of the past several decades given that designation. I would observe here that a commensurate impact of this rediscovery is still to be had in the doctrine and life of the church, in its preaching and teaching.

(p.26f, Richard B. Gaffin Jr, By Faith, Not by Sight)

  1. Isn't 'elliptical' a great word to use for this?
  2. How do I need to is my life and doctrine yet to be impacted with this rediscovery I know in my head? How will the penny drop for me?

Stop listening to yourself

I apologise in advance for the ridiculously long quotes in this post, but they are brilliant.

The main trouble in this whole matter of spiritual depression in a sense is this, that we allow our self to talk to us instead of talking to our self. Am I just trying to be deliberately paradoxical? Far from it. This is the very essence of wisdom in this matter. Have you realized that most of your unhappiness in life is due to the fact that you are listening to yourself instead of talking to yourself? Take those thoughts that come to you the moment you wake up in the morning. You have not originated them, but they start talking to you, they bring back the problem of yesterday, etc. Somebody is talking. Who is talking to you? Your self is talking to you. Now this man’s treatment [in Psalm 42] was this; instead of allowing this self to talk to him, he starts talking to himself, ‘Why art thou cast down, O my soul?’ he asks. His soul had been repressing him, crushing him. So he stands up and says: ‘Self, listen for a moment, I will speak to you’. Do you know what I mean? If you do not, you have but little experience.

(D. Martyn Lloyd-Jones, Spiritual Depression: Its Causes and Cures, pp. 20f)

Martin Luther knew better than most how to talk your way out of spiritual depression. However, for him the devil was real and the one to have God's promises spoken to. However, God was also close at hand in the words of those who spoke in his name.

do not dwell on your own thoughts, but listen to what other people have to say to you. For God has commanded men to comfort their brethren, and it is his will that the afflicted should receive such consolation as God's very own [...]

Inasmuch, then, as God desires everyone to comfort his brother, and desires that such comfort be received with a believing heart, be done with your own thoughts. Know that the devil is tormenting you with them, and that they are not your thoughts but the cursed devil's, who cannot bear to see us have joyful thoughts.

Listen, then to what we are saying to you in God's name: Rejoice in Christ, who is your gracious Lord and Redeemer [...]

If you are convinced that [your own] thoughts come from the devil you have already gained the victory.

(pp.96f, Luther: Letters of Spiritual Counsel, ed. and trans. Theodore G. Tappert [1534])

Slightly more seriously, Luther lays down how he dealt with his own doubts about whether he was one of the elect:

I know all about this affliction. I was myself brought to the brink of eternal death by it [...] I shall show you how God helped me out of this trouble and by what means I now protect myself against it every day.

First, you must firmly fix in your mind the conviction that such thoughts as yours are assuredly the suggestions and fiery darts of the wretched devil [...]

Secondly, when such thoughts assail you, you should learn to ask yourself, "If you please, in which Commandment is it written that I should think about and deal with this matter?" When it appears that there is no such Commandment, learn to say: "Begone, wretched devil! You are trying to make me worry about myself. But God declares everywhere that I should let him care for me [...]

Thirdly, if these thoughts nevertheless continue (for the devil is reluctant to give up), you too must refuse to give up. You must always turn your mind away from them and say: "Don't you hear, devil? I will have nothing to do with such thoughts. Moreover, God has forbidden me to. Begone! I must now think of God's Commandments. Meanwhile I shall let him care for me. If you are so clever in these matters, go up to heaven and dispute with God himself [...]

Fourthly, the highest of God's commands is this, that we hold up before our eyes the image of his dear Son, our Lord Jesus Christ. Everyday he should be our excellent mirror wherein we behold how much God loves us and how well, in his infinite goodness, he has cared for us in that he gave his dear Son for us.

In this way, I say and no other, does one learn how to deal properly with the question of predestination. It will be manifest that you believe in Christ. If you believe, then you are called. And if you are called, then you are most certainly predestinated. Do not let this mirror and throne of grace be torn away from your eyes. If such thoughts still come and bite like fiery serpents, pay no attention to the thoughts or serpents. Turn away from these notions and contemplate the brazen serpent [John 3:14], that is Christ given for us.

(pp.115ff, Luther: Letters of Spiritual Counsel, ed. and trans. Theodore G. Tappert [1534])

Incidentally, after some thought, I think that that last paragraph gets at what Paul means when he 'the Spirit himself bears witness with our spirit that we are children of God' (Romans 8:16). The witness of the Spirit is not a feeling or voice in your head telling you that you are elect. It is externalised in the cry 'Abba, Father' (v.15; c.f 2 Cor 1:19-22, Luke 12:11-12). It is not subsequent to belief in the Gospel, but it is belief that the Gospel is true. That is why the Reformers (in contrast to some Puritans) made assurance inseparable from faith. For example, Calvin defines faith as 'a firm and certain knowledge of God's benevolence toward us, founded upon the truth of the freely given promise in Christ, both revealed to our minds and sealed upon our hearts through the Holy Spirit' (Institutes, 3.2.7) and Luther describes it as 'a living, daring confidence in God's grace, so sure and certain that the believer would stake his life on it a thousand times' ("Preface to the Epistle of St Paul to the Romans" [1546] LW vol.35 p. 370)

Having said that Calvin understands the witness of the Spirit slightly differently to me (cf. his commentary on Ephesians 1:13 and on Romans 8:16 itself). He seems to see it more as unconscious change in the heart, but which is manifested in our calling upon God:

our faith has no true evidence, except we call upon God. It is not then without reason that Paul, bringing us to this test, shows that it then only appears how truly any one believes, when they who have embraced the promise of grace, exercise themselves in prayers.

However, it is notable that when Luther recommends clear 'practical' advice it is to listen to other people who speak with the Spirit's voice, and to call upon the Lord in joyful song.

When you are sad, therefore, and when melancholy threatens to get the upper hand, say "Arise, I must play a song unto the Lord on my regal [a portable organ] (be it the Te Deum laudamus or the Benedictus), for the Scriptures teach us that it pleases him to hear a joyful song and the music of stringed instruments." Then begin striking the keys and singing in accompaniment, as David and Elisha did, until your sad thoughts vanish. If the devil returns and plants worries and sad thoughts in your mind resist him manfully and say, "Begone, devil! I must now play and sing unto my Lord Christ."

(pp.96f, Luther: Letters of Spiritual Counsel, ed. and trans. Theodore G. Tappert [1534])

The church is not a theocracy

Have you ever heard the following reason for why we don't have to follow the Mosaic Law:

The Mosaic Law was provided for a theocratic nation, and the church is not a theocratic nation.

Did the NT authors ever use that argument? Not that I can think of.

Tuesday, January 13, 2009

Law and Gospel, God and man

Martin Luther famously identified that law and Gospel must be 'rightly and properly distinguished' for either to be understood properly. He argued that doctrine could be 'falisfied, either by mingling these two into one, or by mistaking the one for the other' ("The Distinction between Law and Gospel: A Sermon by Martin Luther" trans. Willard L Burce, Concordia Journal 18).

In Christianity Explored this evening Rico Tice argued that the disciples initially understood Jesus as human, but did not see him as divine. Strictly this is true. But throughout the Gospels you find that there was a two-fold error that those who encountered Jesus fell into. They neither understood him as divine, but neither could they comprehend quite how human he was.

We know the danger of thinking that Christianity is law-lite by mingling law and Gospel. We also know that we can make Christianity into Gospel without law, or law without Gospel, by mistaking one for the other (and so misunderstanding both).

Similarly, the disciples often saw Jesus as a semi-divine Messiah who would rule and lead Israel, but could not still storms or lay down his life to take it up again because that was too high for him, or for that matter die an ignominious death because that would be too low for him. In this way they mingled the divine and human natures of Jesus and lost both. Also similarly, people now treat Jesus as only human and ignore his deity, or see him as only divine, who visited Palestine dressed in white robes and floating a few inches above the ground (HT Tom Wright for that phrase).

UPDATE

The Chalcedonian Creed says it better than me:

one and the same Christ, Son, Lord, only begotten, to be acknowledged in two natures, inconfusedly, unchangeably, indivisibly, inseparably;

the distinction of natures being by no means taken away by the union, but rather the property of each nature being preserved, and concurring in one Person and one Subsistence, not parted or divided into two persons, but one and the same Son, and only begotten, God the Word, the Lord Jesus Christ;

Rebekah and the Samaritan Woman

There are some remarkable parallels between Rebekah in Genesis 24 and the Samaritan Woman in John 1:1-45.

The descendants of Nahor were part of Abraham's family but somewhat removed, geographically and by faith. Terah, Abram and Lot left Ur of the Chaldeans possibly leaving Nahor with idolatry (Josh 24:2), but certainly leaving him behind in their journey to the promised land. The Samaritans were also the awkward family members to the Jews in Jesus' day, related but with their own land, and their own faith.

They share several other literary connections:

  • Both involve a man alone on a journey in a land of the estranged family.
  • Both men meet a woman at her local well and ask her straight out for a drink (Gen 24:17; John 4:7).
  • The reactions of each of the women differ markedly. One is defensive and suspicious, and one is gracious and open.
  • Both men have offer something wonderful to the women.
  • The reaction of both women is finally to run back to town and describe what has just happened.
  • The town welcomes Jesus and ask him to stay with them for two nights. The city of Nahor also welcomes Abraham's servant and persuade him to stay with them for a night.

In addition both narratives are concerned with marriage, and a marriage into the covenant line, with the promised seed of Abraham.

The Samaritan woman is not just another individual but representative of Samaria, and all the nations. She has had many husbands and not accepted that salvation comes from the Jews (cf. Jer 3:8; Hos 4:15 etc). If you see that then the women's next response to Jesus ('Our fathers worshiped on this mountain, but you say that in Jerusalem is the place where people ought to worship') becomes not just a random theological riposte to try and gain the offensive, but illustrative of exactly how she has had different husbands. Jesus points her beyond the covenant with the old Jerusalem, to himself as the new Jerusalem where the nations will flood too (e.g. Jer 3:17). She has had many husbands, but he is the bridegroom that will really satisfy, as John the Baptist has only just declared (John 3:29).

Do you think I'm drawing lines which are not there?

I really don't think I am, but realise I haven't explained it as fluently as it deserves. Hopefully you get the picture though.