Wednesday, January 26, 2011

Three aspects of repentance

"When Peter calls his listeners to 'repent', he is calling them to change

  • their whole orientation toward God, as well as
  • how they view themselves and
  • [how they view] the world...

Peter, the close companion of Jesus, has been transformed in his own understanding of God, himself, and the world.

  • He, who first confessed Jesus as Messiah and believed this man would conquer as the new King, has recently witnessed his leader die a brutal death.
  • He, who once envisioned himself as loyal and righteous, is now painfully aware of his own sin and weakness through his denial and fear.
  • He, who had assumed Yahweh's concern and love was exclusively for the nation of Israel, now discovers with ever-growing clarity that God is concerned with the renewal of the entire world...

that necessarily entails a kind of disorientation and reorientation that simultaneously shakes up and revitalizes every area of his life."

(formatting mine, pp. 122-123, Kelly M. Kapic, with Justin L. Borger, God So Loved, He Gave: Entering the Movement of Divine Generosity)

Firstfruits

As good a summary as you will read on firstfruits in the Bible:

In the Old Testament the firstfruits offering was not only the beginning but also the best part of the whole harvest. As a gift that represented the totality, it was both the first and the finest portion of everything the Promised Land produced. Accordingly, when Paul tells us that God has given us the firstfruits of the Spirit, he is saying that we have received not only the beginning, but also a taste of the best part of the fullness God has planned for the future.

This language shifts the picture from God as recipient to God as giver. Israel's understanding of firstfruits was always as something given to God. Yet now it is God who gives to us the firstfruits...the God of the universe gives offerings to the likes of us and that choice offering is himself...

God's new creation began with Jesus' resurrection - which explains why he is called the 'firstfruits' from the dead (1 Cor. 15:20, 23) - and continues with his Spirit... those who are in Christ and have received the Spirit are now themselves called 'the firstfruits,' having been saved and sanctified by the Spirit (2 Thess. 2:13; James 1:18; Rev. 14:4).

(p. 102, Kelly M. Kapic, with Justin L. Borger, God So Loved, He Gave: Entering the Movement of Divine Generosity)

Random underlined bits

A few random quotes from chapter 4 of God So Loved, He Gave: Entering the Movement of Divine Generosity by Kelly M. Kapic, with Justin L. Borger.

"God takes everything back by giving everything away... God reclaims ownership by paying an exorbitant price for what was already his." (p.70)

"He who hung the earth in place is hanged. He who fixed the heavens in place is fixed in place... Though the people did not tremble, the earth trembled. though the people were not afraid, the heavens were afraid" (Melito of Sardis, p.71)

"Once redeemed by God we are no longer described as slaves to sin, but surprisingly we are still described as 'slaves.' Paul concludes that 'having been set free from sin, [we] have become slaves of righteousness' (Rom. 6:18-19). Later he describes believers as 'slaves of God' (6:22). By itself, the illustration of slavery is an inadequate representation of what it means to belong to God. In fact, Paul himself seems to recognise this when he admits that he put this 'in human terms' (6:19)... While slavery is a good image in the sense that it suggests God's full lordship and our complete submission, it is also undesirable and problematic because of the hardship it suggests." (p.75)

Thursday, January 20, 2011

Kelly Kapic

Kelly Kapic is a guy I think you would all love. I am reading and loving God So Loved, He Gave: Entering the Movement of Divine Generosity. As you can see there is a lot of love going around, and it is Trinitarian love, Evangelical love, Historically-rooted love, and spreading love.

His background is in the study of John Owen (particularly the Trinitarian classic, Communion with God). He reminds me quite a bit of another former student of Colin Gunton; a certain Mike Reeves (in his theology at least).

Here is a taste of some stuff of his on the internet. But you should read his books (as this rather varied group of luminaries agree).

MP3 lecture: "Evangelical Holiness: Assumptions in John Owen’s Theology of Christian Spirituality" (WSC 2010)

Video of the same lecture:

"Evangelical Holiness" by Dr. Kelly Kapic from Westminster Seminary California on Vimeo.

MP3 lecture: Walking with God: John Owen's Vision of the Christian Life (Life in the Spirit: Spiritual Formation in Theological Perspective, 18th Annual Wheaton College Theology Conference, April 16-18, 2009)

MP3 sermon: "John 3:16-18: God So Loved He Gave" (New City Fellowship Church (PCA), March 30, 2008)

Article: "Are We There Yet: An Exploration of Romans 8," Modern Reformation, Vol. 15, Num. 4, (July/Aug 2006)

Article: "Simul Iustus et Peccator" (Tabletalk magazine)

Render to God the things that are God's

'Jesus said to them, "Whose likeness and inscription is this?" They said, "Caesar's." Then he said to them, "Therefore render to Caesar the things that are Caesar's, and to God the things that are God's."' (Matt 22:20-21)

'the language Jesus used here for "image" is eikon, from which we get the English word "icon." In a word, Jesus was able to take us back to the garden, back to the beginning, back to Adam and Eve. The denarius coin might have been made in the emperor's image. But Adam and Eve were "minted" in God's image and likeness - all human beings (including Caesar) have been made as icons of God, imaging the Creator and serving as his representatives in the world...

'Jesus makes it clear that God is not merely interested in our wallets, he wants all of us because he is the Creator of all. Since we are made in God's image - since we are imprinted with the image of God - we should render everything we have, our very selves, to him.

'But who has given everything to God? Who has lived a life poured out for others with a pure heart, upheld justice and righteousness, avoided sin completely, both publicly and privately? Who has loved God with their whole heart, soul, strength, and mind? Who has consistently loved neighbor as oneself? We owe what we cannot pay, discarding what we should love and diminishing what we should exalt. Thus, we find ourselves left with the age-old question posed by Jesus himself when he asked, "What shall a man give in return for his soul?" (Matt. 16:26)...

'Here we encounter the unspoken paradox of Jesus' encounter with the Pharisees. For only Jesus is able "to render to God the things that are God's." Only he can give what is required in exchange for our lives. Thus as he offers himself, he offers himself as a substitute for us, in our place. The paradox of Jesus' response here is that we owe everything to God but we cannot give it, so God himself will give what he demands. This will be God's great gift to the world: himself.'

(pp. 66-67, Kelly M. Kapic, with Justin L. Borger, God So Loved, He Gave: Entering the Movement of Divine Generosity)

As I read this I marvelled. This is the old, old story of substitutionary atonement. Yet it never fails to move my heart that God the Father would give his Son to pay the debt I owe. I've heard it thousands of times, but it never looses it's shine. There is nothing like it!

Man curved in on himself

I've been wondering about the origin of this definition of sin for a while. Kelly Kapic unpacks it.

First Augustine identified that we stop loving God and start loving his material gifts:

"St Augustine spoke of sin as that which bends or curves us to the ground, making us more like the beasts and less like the God whom we were to image. He speculated that we were created to have our heads and hearts raised toward Yahweh, and that sin is that which turns our gaze from him."

Then

Martin Luther picked up this imagery in the Reformation, arguing that sin actually bends or curves us upon ourselves (homo incurvatus in se). We were disigned to embrace God and others, but instead we are now consumed with ourselves.

(p. 37, Kelly M. Kapic, With Justin L. Borger, God So Loved, He Gave: Entering the Movement of Divine Generosity)

So we stop loving God and start loving ourselves. Finally, Melanchthon made the further step of locating that work in the heart.

Choice is not freedom

Christian proclamation should have criticized the Western ideology of freedom by telling the public that having choices doesn't mean freedom. The alcohol-addicted person or the drug-addicted person is also making choices. The problem is that he or she always makes the same choice - to take the drug or drink the bottle - again and again. Having choices doesn't yet guarantee freedom.

(Wolfhart Pannenberg cited in p.37, Kelly M. Kapic, With Justin L. Borger, God So Loved, He Gave: Entering the Movement of Divine Generosity)

Everything bears the stamp of the hidden God

"What can be seen on earth indicates neither total absence, nor the manifest presence of divinity, but the presence of a hidden God. Everything bears this stamp."

(Blaise Pascal, Pensees, cited in p.35, Kelly M. Kapic, With Justin L. Borger, God So Loved, He Gave: Entering the Movement of Divine Generosity)

I don't think that Pascal intended it, but that chimes with a Lutheran approach to natural theology (esp. if you understand the Lutheran concept of "the Hidden God".

Prohibition and provision in paradise

As Bruce Waltke describes it, Satan distorts the perspective of our first parents by emphasizing God's one prohibition, not his provision:

Adam and Eve are surrounded by wonderful trees and provisions in the garden, including the tree of life, but all Eve can see is the one tree of which they cannot partake. Once Satan can get our eyes on what we cannot do, we are sure to do it.

The garden is Paradise: if humanity fails in this ideal setting, then there is no hope for humanity to keep faith anywhere else... In contrast to much sociological thinking, namely, that the way to improve humans is to improve their environment, humanity at its best rebels in the perfect environment. Sodom and Gomorrah, where humanity sunk to the lowest levels of violence and sex, was at the time like the "garden of the LORD" (Gen. 13:10). Our modern world is no better.

(pp. 31-32, Kelly M. Kapic, With Justin L. Borger, God So Loved, He Gave: Entering the Movement of Divine Generosity, citing p102, 101, Bruce Waltke with Cathi Fredricks, Genesis: A Commentary)

Rich in giving

Romans 11:36:

For from him and through him and to him are all things. To him be glory forever. Amen.

These simple words of praise give an all-encompassing view of the world and its purpose. All things come from God, are sustained through him, and will eventually flow back to him as the ultimate Owner of everything...

God did not create to satisfy any inadequacy or need of his own, but out of the fullness of his delight and love, this delight and love flow to the creatures as generosity and back to God as thanksgiving and praise...Our good has by his hand become a means of God's ultimate glory, intrinsically connected (cf. Ezek. 36:22-27)...

As God's giving does not impoverish but enriches him, so we as we offer back to God the fits he has given and sanctified in us, are enriched in his glory and satisfied in and through him.

(pp.24-25, Kelly M. Kapic, With Justin L. Borger, God So Loved, He Gave: Entering the Movement of Divine Generosity)

Monday, January 17, 2011

Theological prolegomenon

This is all a bit niche interest, although it is pretty sweeping in its scope. It is a useful survey of two different responses to the Enlightenment critique of natural theology:

Prior to the Enlightenment, Lutheran scholastic orthodoxy used the concept of the natural knowledge of God to demonstrate God's existence. The Bible, by way of contrast, was regarded as a supernatural source of supernatural revelation. When this scheme was subjected to the critique of the Enlightenment, the consequence was that language about God became irrelevant to genuine knowledge, and the pathway was cleared for modern secularity. But Luther's theme of the law as the antithesis of the gospel had the potential of escaping the Kantian critique. Thus Lutheran theology would have in the category “law” a prolegomenon to the gospel which could make the transition from pre-modern to modern culture without giving up its essential proclamation. If "law" means whatever calls us into question before God, then we can see it functioning as prolegomenon in theologians as diverse as Theodosius Harnack (d. 1889), Werner Elert (d. 1954), and Paul Tillich (d. 1965), as well as in the work of contemporary Lutheran theologians Gerhard Forde and Robert Jenson.

Karl Barth's response to the critique of the Enlightenment and to the Liberal theology of the 19th Century was to reject the idea of prolegomenon altogether. If grace is revelation and revelation is grace, then the antithesis between law and gospel simply disappears. The revelation of God, whether law or gospel, is gracious.

(pp. 414-415, Walter R Bouman, "The Concept of the 'Law' in the Lutheran Tradition" Word & World 3/4 (1983))

The whole article is fairly good. I think the author is right that there are strengths and weaknesses in both responses.

Wisdom on reading well (part 2): Tom Torrance

Part two of a series about lessons authors have given me on how to read the Bible.

I've recently posted notes of Thomas Torrance's very detailed and carefully thought through principles for learning. They all deserve meditating on. I also recently read this by him:

Normally when one reads an author one understands what he says be looking with him at the 'object' to which he points or which he describes, but early in the nineteenth century there grew up the tendency to study the text of an author in its correlation with the 'subject' or the author himself rather than in its correlation with the objective reality he intended, and so to read it as an expression of his individuality or genius [...] Applied to the New Testament, however, this meant that the focus of attention was not so much upon Jesus Christ himself in his ontological reality as Son of God become man, or even as objective historical figure, but upon the creative spirituality of the early Church"

(pp. 35-36, TF Torrance, Karl Barth: Biblical and Evangelical Theologian)

Saturday, January 15, 2011

The terrifying and comforting Triune God who is love!

1. Why the loving community of the Trinity is terrifying

The Father has loved the Son by the Spirit for all eternity. Before we were born the three persons of the Trinity were dancing and conversing together singing the praises of one another. They couldn't love each other more.

...and we killed the Father's only Son.

His wrath will be devastating (Mark 12:1-9).

2. Why the loving community of the Trinity is comforting

The Father has loved the Son by the Spirit for all eternity. Before we were born the three persons of the Trinity were dancing and conversing together singing the praises of one another. They couldn't love each other more.

...and the Father gave us his relationship with his only Son when he sent his Son to die and raised the New Adam from the dead; and the Son gave us his relationship with the Father by calling us brothers as he queued with sinners to be baptised by John and went to die between two robbers; and the Spirit has caught us up into this eternal loving community by breaking into our hearts and opening them to God.

We rejoice, and by his Spirit we intensely and eternally love the Father and Son.

What is the difference?

  1. is the Trinity expelling foreign objects and destroying them.
  2. is the Trinity including foreign objects in Christ and transforming them.
  1. is the Trinity acting understandably.
  2. is the Trinity acting incomprehensibly in Christ crucified.
  1. is the Trinity acting in the Son's divine nature.
  2. is the Trinity acting in the Son's hypostatic union.
  1. is the Trinity speaking to us.
  2. is the Trinity speaking to us by speaking to the Father in Christ.
  1. is God in his eternal being, our act apart from Christ, and his response.
  2. is God in his eternal being, his act in Christ on our behalf, and our response.
  1. is thinking about the Trinity from the outside - looking in through the windows.
  2. is thinking about the Trinity when we've been brought in from the cold.
  1. is law.
  2. is Gospel.
  1. is death to us.
  2. is life to us.

The difference is not whether we are talking about the Triune God who is love or some other God.

The loving community of the Trinity is never good news apart from Christ going to the cross for us.

Sunday, January 09, 2011

Crayons v. Prayer

We pray to the real Jesus where he is now. We reach children's hearts not by offering them crayons to draw Jesus, but by showing them how to talk to him. He is real, and is not a picture.

(p.32, Edmund Clowney, How Jesus Transforms the Ten Commandments)

A false dichotomy but you get his point.

Thursday, January 06, 2011

New edition of Christianity Explored in May

I love Christianity Explored, although I usually tweak bits. But I'm genuinely excited by the changes announced by Barry Cooper:

We’ve made some big changes, based on years of collated feedback. Some of the changes are under the hood, but some are much more conspicuous. For example:

  • the DVD has been completely reshot. It retains the best script elements from before, but adds a wealth of new material. Visually and aesthetically, we’re in very different territory.
  • each session (Bible study + DVD + discussion) focuses on only one theme, making the course leaner and more logical.
  • the session on Grace has been completely rewritten, the session on Resurrection completely reworked, and there is a brand new session based on Jesus’ parable of the Sower.
  • we’ve simplified the resources by incorporating the How To Run The Course book into the Leader’s Guide. That means you only need two booklets (one for the leader and one for the guest) plus a DVD to run Christianity Explored.
  • up to this point, CE has been a ten week course. Now, it’s a much more streamlined and manageable seven. In addition, there are now only three sessions on the Day Away instead of four.
  • unlike the previous edition, every session – including the Day Away – is now grounded in Mark’s Gospel. So although the course is shorter, the walkthrough of Mark is more thorough.

(...more)

Sunday, January 02, 2011

Wisdom on reading well (part 1): Michael Reeves

I thought I'd do a little series on advice that has impacted how I read, and in particular how I read the Bible. This is the first piece of advice (not in order of importance by the way!) although it is implicit rather than explicit:

"Luther opened the Bible to find Christ, Zwingli sought more simply to open the Bible." (p.75, Michael Reeves, The Unquenchable Flame: Discovering the Heart of the Reformation)

This one sentence is probably the most important thing to me I read in Mike Reeves's book. It reinforced the video below which I had seen on Dave Bish's blog.

I found that massively personally challenging. Am I reading the Bible with the clear intention to meet Christ and see his glory? If I'm not, I'm perverted in my use of the Bible.

One caveat. It is helps to come to the Bible with questions and a knowledge of Christ beforehand, but we must then allow the Bible to question our questions and our knowledge of Christ so that we don't find exactly the Christ we expected to find. You could argue that Luther did not do that as well as he should have, and that is why he had a bad attitude to James, Revelation etc.

Where is our authority?

Listening to: Mozart: Die Zauberflöte (Klemperer)

The Father's authority: God the Father is the supreme authority, Creator of heaven and earth.

The Son's gifted authority: He has given all authority to his Son (John 17:2). The Father is in him so he carries the Father's authority, but (importantly) he is also in the Father (John 10:38) so while that authority is delegated it is of the very being of the Father that he acts to give authority to the Son whom he loves. It couldn't be any other way.

The Church's gifted authority: By his Spirit the Son abides in his church and we abide in him (John 15:4). It is a mutual indwelling that mirrors the mutual indwelling that the Father and the Son have together (John 17:11). The Son is gifted authority by the Father, the church is gifted authority by the Son. However, Christ is the head of the body because we do not dwell in the Father, and we are one step removed from the Father who is the source of all authority.

The gifted authority of reason and the civil authorities: The authority of the reason and the civil authorities is also derived from the Son. In the New Creation it will merge with the authority of the church as the personel will totally overlap! Even now it cannot be utterly separated because there is some overlap (Christian judges, Christian bosses etc). What distinguishes the two in the present is the word they have been given to speak. The civil authorities are given the word of order (the word of creation - or better 'continuing creation') and church is given the word of the cross (the word of redemption - or 're-creation').

The power and reality of the gift in the word and Spirit: This connection between the Church and Christ is effected by the Spirit which invariably accompanies the words of Christ (John 3:34). The words of Christ, are found for us in the Bible, and secondarily in the Church's word.

The sacramental word of Christ (the Bible): The Son abides in the Bible so that every word is said by him and about him. He fills every corner of the Bible, but he is not the Bible. The Son is the Word of God the Father, but the Bible is the Word of God the Son. It is through the Son's words dwelling in us that he dwells in us (John 15:7).

The sacramental word of the church (the word and sacrament): The Church hears from the Father in the Son. They hear from the Son in the Bible. They also hear from the Son in the word and sacrament, which re-present Christ of the Bible to us in countless fresh ways as he re-engages an ever changing world and individuals in ever changing situations.

The non-sacramental word of the civil authorities: This word creates order in creation but does not bring the Spirit with it. It cannot create from nothing (as the word of the Gospel can) but can only order creation as it is already there.

The difference that the presence of sin makes: We do not find sin present in either the Father's word to us, or in the Son's word to us. However, the church is caught between the ages. It is both Adam and Christ to the world, although constantly in the process of clothing itself with it's new identity in Christ. It dwells in the midst of the world (in the Johannine sense of fallen humanity), but the world also dwells within it, until the new Creation when it will be purged. Therefore the word of the church is fallible. At times it speaks the truth which comes from Christ, and at other times lies which come from the devil. The words of the church need therefore to be tested to see which spirit inspired them (this is true whether the words are prophetic or preached, and also true of sacraments which can be falsely administered). In one sense the Bible is the word of the church, not directly the words of Christ, but because it is untainted by lies of the Devil it has a priority over the church which remains a mixture of truth and lies until the second coming. It is the priority of being a norm by which to judge the words of the church. A prioritising of the church over the Bible is not wholly incorrect because the Bible was written by the church, but reflects a over-realised eschatology.

[I'm less sure about this bit] The difference that the absence of sin will make: The word and sacraments of the church are words of redemption to the fallen, whether in the world without or in world that still dwells in each of our hearts. Therefore when the New Creation is consummated then the church will stop declaring love to a sinful world that finds it difficult to believe because it will be seen and experienced (1 Corinthians 13:9-10). Instead it will experience love (we will no longer be the bride, but the wife) and we will act it out towards the rest of creation. The church will need to continue to speak to the created world as it rules creation as the civil authority, but it will be the word of continual creation not re-creation.

[This is pretty closely argued, and a massively important subject. I'm laying out a whole swathe of my systematic theology here so if you think I'm in error you should say so. This is why I'm not a Catholic, but also why criticism of bibliolatry can be warranted, but doesn't require you to believe in a fallible Bible. I'm sorry that I gave up on the Bible references for lack of time, but think I could give them for most of the sentences if you ask. I'm sorry as well that I didn't have the patience to edit it.]

All the Bs

If you are a geek like me you'll love this little invention from Google labs. They have come up with an application that searches through Google Books to find the frequency of words and phrases in books published over the last 200 years.

Here are the three Bs; Bach, Beethoven and Brahms in English books 1800-2000:

If music isn't your thing and you're a theology geek then you may want to invent another set of Bs; Balthasar, Barth, Bultmann and Brunner in English books 1919-2000 (click on image for a clearer view):

And then compare the difference in German literature:

Of course you can't say too much because you don't really know the sample, and there may be another Barth which everyone is writing about to skew the stats. What conclusions would you tentatively draw though?

Saturday, January 01, 2011

Wingren and Calvin on the Sacraments

"The question what the sacraments give over and above the Word often springs from a religion of works. The secret presupposition is: if it cannot be shown that there is some special advantage with the sacraments there is no point in making use of them, we should rather content ourselves with the Word. If, however, we start with the conviction that it is hard to believe and easy to fall as we journey, then the means of grace do bring grace, are gifts: then we receive them all with gladness when they all give us the same thing." (p. 158, Gustaf Wingren, The Living Word)

This is similar to Calvin, but I think it is better. Calvin seems to imply that ideally we wouldn't need the sacraments and the word would be enough, because the Word is more spiritual. He also seems to say that we go beyond the sacrament, so that we can leave it behind.

"the sacraments have the same office as the Word of God: to offer and set forth Christ to us" (Institutes, 4.14.17)

"our faith is slight and feeble unless it be propped on all sides and sustained by every means, it trembles, wavers, totters, and at last fives way. Here our merciful Lord, according to his infinite kindness, so tempers himself to our capacity that, since we are creatures who always creep upon the ground, cleave to the flesh, and, do not think about or even conceive of anything spiritual, he condescends to lead us to himself even by these earthly elements, and to set before us in the flesh a mirror of spiritual blessings" (Institutes, 4.14.3)

TFT's principles of instruction

General Principles - for every field of knowledge

(i) adaptation of our capacities in accordance with the nature of the object, and therefore instruction requires a specific adaptation on the part of the learner, a specific mode of rational activity determined by the nature of what is being taught or communicated"

(ii) an attitude, that "reflects the nature of the subject-matter involved"

(iii) asking "the right questions"

(iv) material to think about

(v) holding "together the realm of the image and the realm of idea"

(vi) having "tools with which to think and shape the thoughts in your mind and form your judgements"

(vii) "the community of others" is required

Particular Principles - for knowing Christ

(i) "Jesus Christ is Himself the Truth"

(ii) Jesus Christ "can be communicated only historically" because "The Truth is a historical Person"

(iii) "True Christian instruction requires on the part of the learner or receiver a response of self-denial and self-criticism"

(iv) "Instruction in Christian Truth involves reconciliation with the Truth.

(v) "Christian instruction involves renewal on the part of the learner."

(vi) It requires "the supernatural operation of the Spirit who proceeds from the Father and the Son in order to apprehend the Truth"

(vii) It must be reckoned that Truth "may put the learner at variance with the world"

[Italics original quotations and structure from pp. xxiii-xl, TF Torrance, The School of Faith: The Catechisms of the Reformed Church.]

Friday, December 31, 2010

The King's English

The brilliant and unique Glen Scivener is spending 2011 celebrating the publication of the King James Bible in 1611 by starting another blog.

This is what he says about it:

This blog is just one attempt to raise awareness about the impact of this translation on the English speaking world. I will blog on a phrase per day that has passed into common parlance: popular phrases like “labour of love”, “beast of burden”, “wits’ end” and “scapegoat”; but also phrases that should be more popular, like “filthy lucre” and “gird up thy loins”.

This is a blog for people of all beliefs and I’ll try to keep things as jargon-free as possible. I hope that whether you are a Christian or not you will understand more about the English we speak, and about the King who has shaped it.

Most of my readers probably know about Glen's blogging already, but if you don't you're missing a treat. Unlike me Glen always has something to say and tends to say it well. But the best thing about Glen is that he is a man with just one king.

I'm looking forward to enjoying a constant flow of his grace-filled, provocative, passionate and fresh thoughts on all those phrases. Why not add his feed to your RSS reader and tell others about it as well?

My books of 2010

For what it is worth, my highly personal favourite books of the year were:

  1. Longing to Know: The Philosophy of Knowledge for Ordinary People by Esther L Meek
  2. The Living Word: A Theological Study of Preaching and the Church by Gustaf Wingren
  3. Counterfeit Gods: When the Empty Promises of Love, Money, and Power Let You Down by Timothy J Keller
  4. The Trellis and the Vine: The Ministry Mind-shift that Changes Everything by Colin Marshall and Tony Payne
  5. Perelandra by CS Lewis

Most of the books I read this year were pretty good. Unfortunately I read very little simply for myself because with my law course I didn't have the time. I think that meant that there were no books that were deeply personally significant this year. I read most of these books in order to discuss them with friends or pass on/recommend to others. None stand-out so much that I want to recommend any in particular.

I wish I had spent more time reading fiction and the Bible.

These are the books I read:

Crazy Love (Chan) – Like John Piper’s Don’t Waste Your Life but more focus on love for your neighbour. Perhaps could do with a stronger emphasis on our forgiveness, but I think it is a good thing that this kind of book is a Christian bestseller.

Experiencing the Trinity (Johnson) – A very short introduction to the doctrine of the Trinity. Pretty good although I’m still looking for a good introductory book to the doctrine.

Man and the Incarnation (Wingren) – A book by a Swedish Lutheran on Ireanaus. Particularly emphasising God’s continual creating activity, and our corresponding continual growth into Christ in whose image we are made.

Theology is for Proclamation (Forde) – Forde has a big idea, and it is a good one. In this wide-ranging critique he argues we should evaluate our theology by whether it leads to proclamation. He finds almost all orthodox theologising as lacking, but I didn’t feel like he had really thought through most of his critiques. I think he was just over-ambitious, and over-critical.

The Waiting Father (Thielicke) – A collection of sermons on the parables. I don’t think I’ve ever read such an amazing rhetorician, and then it is all backed by a first-rate theological mind. The down-side was that I was not always certain he was exegeting the text itself.

Letters to a Young Calvinist (Smith) – a very snappily written encouragement to soteriological Calvinists to widen their vision and embrace something more like neo-Calvinism. I thought this was a really great book.

Distinctives (Roberts) – we read this as a home group. I think we were all encouraged to have a bit perspective, and realised how radically that should affect our lives.

The Death of Ivan Ilyich (Tolstoy) – a dark short story about the dying of a stereotypical middle-class man who could have been around today. Vanity, all is vanity!

The Unquenchable Flame (Reeves) – an excellent introduction to the Reformation as expected (see my review note).

Gilead (Robinson) – Everyone says you should read it, and they are right. Gilead is a beautiful illustration of what it means to live and die well. Especially if read in comparison to Ivan Ilyich.

The Temple and the Church's Mission (Beale) – A ponderous book, but with a great central thesis that is probably a lot more controversial in the States than the UK. God intended for Eden to be a temple that would expand and fill the whole world with his presence through the work of humanity. The church, in Christ, picks up the task.

That Hideous Strength (Lewis) – Volume 3 of the Space Trilogy. I enjoyed this the most of all three, although it was probably the least ambitious.

What is the Gospel? (Gilbert) – I don’t like the fact that he included 'response' within his definition of the Gospel. But as a short, accessible and punchy explanation of what ought to be at the forefront of the Church’s teaching I thought it was very well executed.

The Trellis and the Vine (Marshall and Payne) – Argues that one-to-one ministry from the very top-down is essential in growing a church in character, conviction and competency. The central metaphor is important, and I am thoroughly convinced that churches ought to adopt this remarkably simple and word-centred model of ministry. I blogged a little on it.

Perelandra (Lewis) – the second volume of the space trilogy. Lewis attempts to describe the interaction between an unfallen woman, a fallen man and the devil. Very illuminating about temptation, and exposes much of how we assume that ‘sin’ is just the way things are.

Longing to Know (Meek) – a weird book that slips between quite mind-bending philosophy of knowledge and homey illustrations. But I learnt a lot about how we know, and how that applies to our knowledge of God and assurance. The trouble is, and the author will be unsurprised by this, a lot of what I learnt is difficult to express.

Life Together (Bonhoeffer) – a deserved classic which I read for the second time. Compact, practical and challenging. However, I continue to have a nagging doubt about Bonhoeffer. Everyone loves him and rates Discipleship and this book among their favourites, but if you asked me, or anyone else how he changed them I think most would struggle to say anything concrete.

Out of the Silent Planet (Lewis) – the first of the space trilogy. I don’t think this is the best but it sets up the rest of the series.

The Living Word (Wingren) – a powerful polemic for the life-creating power of the preached word and the significance of conflict with the devil.

He Is There and He Is Not Silent (Schaeffer) – I’m afraid I just don’t think I get Schaeffer. He paints with a broad brush over a huge canvas. I like what he is trying to do, but he doesn’t persuade me of anything.

Escape from Reason (Schaeffer) – as above. I feel I ought to love Schaeffer. My pastor is a fanatic. Perhaps I should read something more substantial.

A Sinner's Guide to Holiness (Chapman) – a short booklet on sanctification. Realistic, it was helpful for a friend in explaining the importance and difficulty of holiness in this life.

What Kind of God? (Ots) – This is best book I’ve come across at answering these kinds of questions. I wouldn’t hesitate to give this to someone who is not yet a Christian.

Friendship (Black) – A Victorian book on the importance of friendship. Vaguely Christian, but very perceptive. Reminded me a little of Lewis.

Counterfeit Gods (Keller) – I have been thinking about idolatry all year because this book stuck with me and was augmented by listening to his sermons and the influence that Keller is on friends. I have lived with the challenge and the hope of a better God in Christ all year, and I’m very thankful for that.

Proper Confidence (Newbigin) – Short book of lectures from the end of his life, it is therefore perhaps unsurprising that it is not very tightly written. Newbigin argues for the correct kind of confidence we should have in our faith.

The Reason for God (Keller) – Need I say anything? Second time I read it and enjoyed it as much as the first time. Every Christian should read this book. I don’t think it is good for giving away, but Keller is the best model I know of for thoughtfully dealing with real questions people are asking today.

The Theme of the Pentateuch (Clines) – This was a seminal book for OT studies, and like most seminal books you can see why as soon as you read it. I summarised some of it.

Doubt in Perspective (McGrath) –This is very good short book to give someone who is doubting. It is accessible and short, but goes quite deep.

I'm a Christian, aren't I? (Clark) – I’m sorry but I think this is the only truly bad book I read this year. It is written for nominal Anglicans, but I think it destroys both true and false assurance.

Just Love (Cooper) – I reviewed this here. A good book on the validity of divine retribution, that doesn’t neglect the Gospel.

Some books of the year lists

All the end of year reviews have collectively persuaded me that to read The God who is There: Finding Your Place in God's Story by Don Carson, and Bonhoeffer: Pastor, Martyr, Prophet, Spy by Eric Metaxas. Despite their best efforts I will resist the collective wisdom to read the doubtlessly excellent To Change the World: The Irony, Tragedy, and Possibility of Christianity in the Late Modern World by James Davison Hunter and Defending Constantine. The Twilight of an Empire and the Dawn of Christendom by Peter J. Leithart.

.

Dissecting a frog, and Karl Barth

Analyzing humor is like dissecting a frog. Few people are interested and the frog dies of it." (EB White)

I had a rather surreal conversation with a friend the other day about whether God had a sense of humour. I didn’t really come to a firm conclusion, but I tried to think through what humour actually was and think that it must be something like:

1. An awareness of incongruity

built upon

2. A foundation of optimism

I feel that things don't fit and surprise us because as finite beings we are always engaging with a world much greater than we can ever comprehend fully. Even our own bodies and minds surprise us and amuse us (especially if you are a dad, or slowly becoming your dad, at Christmas).

Good humour is attractive in someone because it shows a combination of both humility (on account of their finitude) and cheerfulness (on account of their optimism). Sadly, often as people we are either humble and afraid, or happy and arrogant.

I was prompted to post on this when reading TF Torrance describing the importance of Karl Barth's sense of humour:

"He was able to laugh at himself, and therefore to criticise himself, and hence to direct even ruthless critique at others in such a way that he could appreciate their intention and respect their persons and their sincerity. In this respect he stood out in marked contrast to the seriousness with which nineteenth century man took himself [...]

The Christian church has no right to despair of 'this weary world' or to be afraid it will crumble away into nothing. Christ is risen! [...] In him we can lift up our heads and laugh in the face of disaster and death… The Christian is the only one with a genuine message of hope and is the one true optimist." (pp.12-13, 23, TF Torrance, Karl Barth: Biblical and Evangelical Theologian)

PS The Wikipedia article on the theory of humour is interesting.

PPS For what it’s worth I tentatively think that while God is full of joy and he tells countless jokes in his creation/redemption, he doesn’t actually have a sense of humour for himself because it is a creaturely characteristic. As the infinite creator the only thing that doesn’t fit in his world is sin, so God laughs at sin (Psalm 2:4 etc) but at nothing else I’m aware of. Although I don’t think that is because he finds sin humourous in the truest sense of the word (which I admit is beyond my grasp!). However theoretically, perhaps as the initiator within the Trinity the Father can surprise the Son, so the Son laughs at jokes told by his Father. But I am far beyond my knowledge. Does anyone know of anything in the Bible to give more of a clue?

PPPS more on comedy try CS Lewis (who I think I got the idea of incongruity from) and Glen Scrivener.

Wednesday, December 29, 2010

Christological titles and stories

Listening to: Balmorhea: Constellations

Prompted, but not in response to, Chris's blog (go read it). This post is largely a riff on Gerhard Forde's argument in pp.62-67 of Theology is for Proclamation, which is where the quotes are from unless otherwise stated. I haven't really thought it all through so please pick holes.

Jesus' question in Mark 8 "Who do you say that I am?" is a question that Jesus cannot answer directly. "Traditionally", Forde says, "titles cannot be self-designations" (cf. John 8:54: "If I glorify myself, my glory is nothing"). Therefore Jesus only makes "an implied christological claim", and "does not speak of himself openly and directly".

Instead he puts others "on the spot to speak for" themselves. As soon as we start to talk about Jesus we find that the question of what title to give him is "inevitable". "We are called upon [like Peter was] to make explicit what was implicit in him".

There are two inter-related dangers in this:

The first danger is that we rewrite the story to fit what the title means in our culture.

Every new title brings with it its own world of meaning, its own story. Inevitably pressure is exerted in countless subtle ways to rewrite the story to fit the title [...] Perhaps that is why the Jesus of the Gospels either refuses the titles or wants them kept secret. The story is not yet over and all the fine titles press toward a different end.

To avoid this danger "the title must be transformed to fit the [true] story." I.e. language, and the culture expressed in language, must be 'redeemed'. But Jesus will ensure that this happens. In his church it will happen in part now and universally it will happen in the future when "every tongue confess[es] that Jesus Christ is Lord".

Most evangelicals today think that content is all that matters and that the form and mediums we use to express it (e.g. the style of music, venues, the language we use) are insignificant. Jamie Smith, sees this as naive and criticises evangelicalism for:

unwittingly reducing Jesus to one more commodity precisely because, in the name of "relevance," they've adopted a worship "style" that simply mimics the mall. Since ... the form/content distinction is specious, you can't simply take Gospel "content" and drop it into the "form" of the mall's worship because that form is already loaded and primed to another end or telos. This doesn't make the the church relevant; it reduces Jesus to a commodity.

However, this wise caution about Jesus being co-opted to serve another end can go to an extreme which is a lack of confidence in the power of the Word to transform what seems unredeemable by the Holy Spirit. Luther and Melanchthon in the 16th century would justify themselves before more radical reformers for being slow to reform the liturgies of the church because they were confident that as long as the Gospel was preached it had power enough to transform everything else. It has the power, and God's promise, to burst out of any constraints placed upon it.

We should find a middle road of confidence but not complacency that is realistic about both the power of the Devil and the power of God over our language and liturgies.

The second danger is that we rewrite the story to fit what we, personally, would like the title to mean.

The hearer, it should be realized, has a stake in the giving of titles. The title represents dreams and hopes: the final ratification of our aspirations; a judge who will finally give evildoers their comeuppance; a Messiah, a Christ who will finally do in all the enemies; a Son of God who will be a universal ruler; a liberator; a man for others; one in whom God-conciousness reaches its zenith [...] We would like nothing better than that all our dreams, without alteration, should be realized in him.

To avoid this danger we must be changed by the title. With Jesus' question "who do you say I am?" we are "drawn into the story" and either it is fitted to us or we are moulded by it. Our dreams and our loves have to be reshaped by the story of Jesus, so that we long to see God face-to-face, we hate evil and love communion with God and his church.

This need for change of the culture and ourselves (not that you can separate the two) cannot be avoided because Jesus will be king, and not let titles rule him. It is also a radical change of death and new-birth. That is why Jesus follows Peter's confession and rebuke with the statement that "if anyone would come after me, let him deny himself and take up his cross and follow me."

We have to reach the "end of our story". We are drawn into Jesus' story by the confession, and if we cannot shape it around ourselves then we will be shaped by Jesus' story of death and resurrection.